Do animals deserve rights essay

Publicado em Agosto 2017

That’s also the only way to make money out of war. First of all I have not seen how even raising 90% tax on 1% would help pay for much of what he is saying” Sanders takes even stronger and more genuine positions on foreign policy than does Trump. After all, the liberal said, you are speaking about a lot of important things, if you would just stop talking about Jesus and sins many more people would listen to him. Before that, wages had been increasing continuously for decades. They want to control women. No one wants to put a complete stop to immigration, how is a wall racist? How conveniently she ignores the Islamic method of subjugating women to second class citizens, which is the best they can hope for, or at its worst, condemns them to near slavery and death for the slightest perceived infractions against their archaic religious edicts. The person whose work was previously worth $8 an hour to their employer may not be worth $15 an hour for the same work. In this Iowa town, there are a lot of homeless people downtown. Trump’s supporters are the people who care about the difference, and that turns out to be a whole lot of people. If I had to, I’d be glad to go over and over Hilary’s record and compare and debate, yada yada and I can quite aptly defend my position. When you say “great benefits,” what benefits do you think you’re referring to? Even my factory-working grandfather was proud that his children went to college. I am old enough to have lived through most of what she sights here and it is quite accurate. Immigrants often are more motivated to take risks because they have incentives to want to believe in the American Dream. In North Carolina, I worked with a diversity of people, including many locals. The galling thing about it was that the professors and attendees of that college (of all shades) were generally middle to upper-middle class yet felt comfortable talking down poor people so long as they were white. They REALLY bring down the race, don’t you think? When they feel weak borders is costing them jobs and they SEE IT for themselves – that does more to solidify such beliefs. I did my master’s thesis on the anti-immigration movement of the 1830s-1850s, and found that just like Trump’s ploy against Central American illegal immigration, Whig politicians promoted fear and anger towards Irish immigration in an attempt to drive voters to the poll. Unemployment has increased along with job security for those who are employed. Our current welfare is not designed to help people get out of poverty as much as it is designed to keep them there. I do live in a middle class liberal town. I hope you’re getting what I’m trying to say. Read Joe Bageant. Federal funds helped pay for emergency services (police, fire departments, emergency rooms, etc), offset healthcare costs (women’s health clinics, mental health services, etc), pay for your education and the roads and bridges you use, keep gas prices and municipality costs low, and on and on. This comment section, much like the article drips of misplaced superiority. Among white voters in particular, Sanders’ margin of victory in the most recent poll does drop to just under 5 per cent — but among white voters who make less than US$25,000 a year, his margin of victory actually grows to 15 per cent. People want to be heard. Fifty years ago, men and women of goodwill agreed that every citizen had the right to health care and to a free and credible education. My mother raised me with a working class attitude. Do you disagree? In everyday life, I don’t think much about it. The idea of the “welfare queen” is true. When we have been pushed down for so long, it can become impossible to see whose hands are keeping us there. He has taken strong positions on endless foreign policy issues and has done so for his entire adult life, going at least back to the Vietnam War. Jesus Christ. My grandfather was able to own a house, buy a new car every few years, take his family on road trip vacations, send his kids off to college, and retire comfortably. But there are black panthers and black lives matters people who support HilLIERy. We all Bleed the same color, We will all leave this earth when our time is up. ” This conflation of the Islamic faith with the cultural norms of other areas is another example of creating “others” or enemies in exactly the same way this article is describing. Both my parents were very liberal and I grew up identifying strongly as a liberal and a Democrat. Most of my ancestors were early ethnic immigrants. They are people who, like Trump supporters, agree with the statement, “People like me don’t have any say about what the government does. But good jobs with job security, benefits, pensions, etc have become rare. I’ve dealt with a learning disability since childhood and severe depression for a long time. Saw the enduring oppression of both poor whites and Blacks. Lets first solve the problem of illegal workers entering the country in USA. In contrast, white female servants who became pregnant were often punished with extended contracts, because a pregnancy meant months of lost work time. But you must realize not everyone sees the world that way. He didn’t have the education or desire to try and look at the biases of each station, or see one or the other as right and left. When I lived in Arizona, I did housekeeping with quite a few Navajo people. We mother fuckers are the True Average American. You want to know how bad it is? I see a (terrifying) parallel between the rise of Trump and the support he draws from those who feel they are “voiceless” and Hugo Chavez’s rise in Venezuela two decades ago. There was a period of my life where I was starting to look a bit gaunt. I’d note, by the way, that there is a growing movement in poor communities in cities to have community gardens—but is challenging because open land is a rare commodity in an urban area and because so much of the soil in cities is heavily polluted and dangerous to eat any food grown there, which requires expensive soil testing before starting a garden. My guess is the second option, which would be a “win-win” situation in my book. Good to give back, even better when no strings are attached. After all, they are poor and uneducated in a country that has left them behind and not put much funding into their education. Does she really think any of them will being to read this article, let alone read the whole long thing? You have been helped every step of the way. Not only does it help the nation’s citizens maintain JOBS – it helps them protect their WAGES. What was a 14 year old supposed to do in a situation like that? Some of Trump’s voicemails were released and it showed how chummy he is with those working in corporate media. I doubt you’re saying anything that most people don’t already know, although it’s possible there is more lack of knowledge on this topic than I realize. Are they being misled by THEIR elites for thinking illegal workers coming en-masse’ and working at lower wages hurts them? Why is she railing against TRUMP for wanting to enforce immigration laws? There is a large part of the population that is the first generation to go to college, having grown up in working class towns and farming communities. Sanders has a proven record. But then I sat through, listened and absorbed AF sensitivity training that you must have missed. Politicians are supposed to represent us. A genie appears and tells the Slovak communist and fascist they will each get a wish, but the other will get twice as much. They are a sick perverted greedy & rich scum that want nothing but to take everything from the working class. It also really got me thinking about how this election can become a significant inflection point, rather than just a couple sentences in a future history book. When you say “send his kids off to college,” how do you think that worked, who paid, why do you think that would be a good thing? “The Final Call” is ubiquitous in every cell block. Maybe they didn’t know those things, but what they did know was that poor Mexicans were taking their jobs. She is the greatest threat to the establishment of any candidate running right now. There was a big hole in the ceiling, and parts of the floor were starting to crumble under my feet. Although he says female genital mutilation (which he calls “circumcision,” a common euphemism that tries to put the practice on a par with male circumcision) is not “obligatory,” you will also find this priceless observation in one of his books: “I personally support this under the current circumstances in the modern world. S. It seemed like you were making generalizations that didn’t fit my experience. It is the Democratic states that pay for most of the benefits that poor whites take advantage of, especially in Republican states. I’ve shared it on social media and wish the history part had been really taught in high schools. I know he would be able to relate because he pulled a complete 180 on his views on Mexicans. After all everyone moving up the ladder still keeps those that look like me on the bottom rung…. If you are younger, this is even harder. Bush; Bush’s former Secretary of State James Baker; former Secretary of Defense Frank C. Why did so many people inserted religion into the conversation? Your reference to wealthy Americans like Tyson bringing in workers during the recession was spot on that is exactly what happened in this small town, and there have been massive ripple affects. Anyway, someone can hunt and garden while being on welfare. The poverty Kennedy saw was, in part, a legacy of the era of slavery. We must stop doing what they want: fighting among ourselves and allowing ourselves to be held down by their fear. But I’m a working class liberal with only a high school degree. Mr. You must not read as many conservatives as I do. A long history of race-baiting has created this division. “The author says that Muslims are not her enemy. Sanders has a great political record and Clinton doesn’t, even if you eliminate the few years before Clinton got into politics. We find neoconservatives today all but owning the Republican Party and attempting to axe Social Security and slash unemployment insurance in the name of “personal responsibility. “To me, the defining moment of his candidacy was when two young BLM activists took the microphone away from him, he stepped away in confusion and a few days later his platform was bristling with BLM talking points. Lately I’ve been fielding a lot of white privilege rants from well-to-do college kids in the college town who know nothing about me or my family history–most of my family didn’t even come over from Europe until the 20th century and started off under the shadow of Irish hate–and I let go. I didn’t catch what he said but his friends smirked. Bernie is saying attack the 1%, raise taxes everywhere, provide healthcare and college to everybody. It’s about believing that, given a chance and an even playing field, the poor and working class can achieve their dreams. Immigrants make up large portions of the workforce on numerous industries, including agriculture and construction. If you think that the author falls into oversimplifications, that is all the more reason you should avoid them in your own stated opinions. Italian-Americans, for example, were sometimes called the ‘N’ word. Plenty of liberals are Christians. After washing up, she loses herself in prayer — so much more satisfying that she can’t wait until the next prayer — and looks out onto the street from her balcony. And many of them do seem self-created and perpetuated. The Klan, specifically the Second Klan, didn’t mainly exist in poor communities. Those struggling and suffering need help and opportunities, not blame and scapegoating. Which must be kept up with inflation and be livable – or otherwise we really have the ground work for actual Bernie Sanders type classism revolution against the elites. Thank you so much for writing it. It is precisely those states that receive the most federal funding—in fact more federal money than they pay in federal taxes. It genuinely is a helping hand for most people. Realistically both parties do in different ways. I do hope your genetics don’t get passed on because you represent what is wrong with the world, the worst aspects of humanity. They’re loyal even when you may not be worth befriending. Even then, there was strong tension between the two in a very dysfunctional relationship whereby my father didn’t respect my Hispanic side and my mom was bitter at my white side for it. This has been shown, for example, with respect to why economic inequality increases under Republicans and decreases under Democrats. Scapegoating the poor isn’t helpful. Not to mention that he lives in a half million dollar house, and his wife has had a lucrative career, in small part, at least, due to Sanders’ government connections. Iowa has low rates of inequality, high school dropouts, gun violence, etc. Similarly, they’ve been manipulated into being racist. Gap-toothed, inbred, uncivilized, violent and hopelessly dumb as ditchwater. Enter that call to prayer and the sublimation through religion that Rifaat so brilliantly introduces in her story. What America needs is a viable second party to vie with the establishment. Your same arguments could be made about feudal lords and peasants. He was a white guy born dirt poor. As someone who grew up dirt poor in Republican-dominated southern Kentucky, so I definitely understand everything you said. If you have an opposing view, why not voice it in an intelligently written piece like hers instead of resorting to ridiculously broad generalizations? After it cleared Tahrir Square of protesters, the military detained dozens of male and female activists. C. In the North, too! That is what makes it hard being on the bottom of society. I’m tired of the greed and selfishness that gives rise to a government and economy that only benefits those who have so much that they could scarcely even comprehend what it would be like to have even more. Sanders has never argued that whites don’t experience poverty as well. That is one bizarre article, I felt for sure Jonna Ivin was going to tell us Bernie was the reincarnation of “Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter” before it was over, but Bernie is a Democrat and Democrats were Vampires in the Movie, in real life they were the KKK. Growing up in rural eastern North Carolina during during the era when family farms were disappearing and replaced by textile plants soon followed by factory farming and animal processing plants I watched as what Jonna describes played out. Enjoy real freedom. The summation of the article basically does exactly what the article suggest should not be done. Everything anyone has comes from the society they’re raised in. I’ve been to a Trump Rally that was completely sold out and what I saw was people of all races, creeds, religions (I’m a Buddhist) and sexual preferences. Public assistance programs are easy targets for politicians, thanks in part to the racial divide introduced by slave owners in colonial America. Right-wingers see them as sheep to be shorn – the characteristic role of peasants everywhere. And she is a big money corporatist neoliberal. The problem, as always, is that those who sow the wind typically aren’t the same people who reap the whirlwind. That headline makes it seem like its only talking about living in an actual ghetto. Maybe they want opportunities brought in by more and better paying jobs instead of free stuff, which is just keeping them down. They was a threat to the people who wanted to keep the average American Male and Female from seeing the truth! In most cases, welfare only offers very basic financial assistance. The target of conservative paternalism in both a militarized police state AND neoconservative nation building isn’t “poor white trash”, but some sort of “other”. Poverty level for one person is about $12,000. It was his property he had given up, and it was him who kept the business afloat by fixing machines when they broke, drilling foundation holes, keeping the other workers organized and directed. Trump is not just a rich guy taking advantage of poor white people and getting them to go along with him. Taking it to their bedroom to pour it in front of him as he prefers, she notices he is dead. Everyone tries to their boot on someone else’s throat in the hope of climbing up from the bottom. In fact, a larger percentage of whites than blacks receive welfare. The remaining three executives claimed the others were “rogue” employees, and denied any knowledge of wrongdoing; they were acquitted. Some research, for example, shows a surprising number of people who attend church are atheist or agnostic—with the highest numbers being found among clergy. Smelly white trash stinking up the nation. All I’m saying is that the popularity of Trump can be put in a larger historical context than just the US. My parents did end up doing well in their careers, but it had nothing to do with me. Wealthy plantation owners had succeeded in separating the two races, and they now planted a fear of Blacks in the minds of poor and working white men. It was the White underlings who were tasked with chasing down, disciplining, and killing Blacks. In fact I cannot believe I am even responding now. Follow the money. The only concession to the horror was that girls’ education was quietly taken away by then-Crown Prince Abdullah from the Salafi zealots, who have nonetheless managed to retain their vise-like grip on the kingdom’s education system writ large. ” The economy roared in the 50s, when we had marginal tax brackets in the 70+ percents (90+ in the immediate years following WWII), to foot the recovery bill for wartime spending (including the massive redistribution of wealth known as the GI Bill). Our experts create writing masterpieces that earn our customers not only high grades but also a solid reputation from demanding professors. ” I find it peculiar and symptomatic, how the entire discussion on racism is not just focused on, but strictly and rigidly limited exclusively to the racism of whites. Just wait until you see the next in line, Prince Nayef, a man straight out of the Middle Ages. We’re all in this together. I think a similar thing is happening with Trump. Those of us who have marched and protested have had to navigate a minefield of sexual assaults by both the regime and its lackeys, and, sadly, at times by our fellow revolutionaries. What on Earth in the girl’s urine made you impure? Instead of fighting for better education for the white underclass, we call them ignorant rednecks. S. This shift was important because Reagan had cut social programs that began with the presidencies of John F. Very well written and I am sharing where I can. I guess the answer to that question is the start of a whole different conversation. But politicians and pundits for decades have been telling them that if they just worked hard that they would get what they deserved, the American Dream. I wasn’t looking for a fight. The tax policies from Reagan forward (Clinton managed to push the pendulum backwards a bit but W undid (and Obama perpetuated) all of that) have overtly moved the middle class wealth upwards (don’t worry it will trickle down someday) to the elite 1% (in fact recent data notes that even the 1% are now complaining about getting screwed by the . There was no hate and if there was they would have been told to leave. No one creates or earns anything outside of a social network, which in the modern world means a large complex society built on trillions of dollars of natural resources and public investments. Sander’s followers are equally as compelled by selfishness, laziness, and frustration at their perception of an un-level playing field. I’m not a hateful sort. What the political elites don’t want to acknowledge is that the average American, on many issues, is further to the left than even the Democrats. There were 6 groups (and I know everyone loves to blame Bernie for the BLM even though they protested his rally before Trumps) One small group of Bernie supporters were there inside and with the old nazi salute lady. Meanwhile, many of the wealthy planters who benefitted economically from slavery were granted exemptions from military service and avoided the horrors of battle. Oh they’re just like the chess pieces to the elite, they have no mind – no intelligence, they’re sheep, they’re just fools for not wanting socialized economy. He minimum wage for a tipped position in Arkansas — like the one I held as a bartender — is $2. That while both of these guys are well read and seem smart they ignore the influence of the military industrial complex and the history of the Democratic Party and it’s propensity for war. Southerners didn’t turn against the Democratic party. Under Bernie, why do you automatically assume taxes will go up or go up so substantially that it would be a detriment to the middle class? W. I am just too tired of it, sir. I don’t confuse being an American with being the member of a particular party. Instead, demonstrations in support of child marriage outstrip those against it, fueled by clerical declarations that opponents of state-sanctioned pedophilia are apostates because the Prophet Mohammed, according to them, married his second wife, Aisha, when she was a child. I’m not surprised, considering how socially acceptable it has become to mock poor whites, especially those born and raised in the South. I was angry that wealth and prosperity were all around me while my hands remained clenched in empty pockets. Many of us never had a shot at formal education or “bettering” ourselves. He simply took a convenient electoral weapon away from the neoconservatives and walked away with it. Not in the way actual socialists use the word. There is another uncle who didn’t go to college and became a security guard (it seems he has a learning disability like I have, although they weren’t diagnosing such things back then). I am a male who is a Buddhist, and my wife is a labor and delivery nurse. What was to prevent freed whites, indentured servants, and African slaves from joining forces against the tyranny of their masters? It’s not particularly complicated. I’ve never been for divisive politics. They are always wrong, don’t believe in science, data, evidence, reality and they routinely ignore history and seem to operate under the belief that if they say it’s true, well, then it’s true. It was during this time that he came into close contact with a primarily Mexican labor force. Anyway, it’s not as if suffering is a contest about who suffered more. Almost suggesting people should drop moral and family or societal values in favor of profits and wealth. Further proof that you have a college degree is your very claim that a college degree is not a guarantee of employment. He never said she was Black. I didn’t collect food stamps ironically and I didn’t go without eating ironically. They also hunt and fish. It doesn’t matter if you are white or black, yellow or purple, gay, straight, bi, asexual or into fish tanks. He understood in the end, right? In a free society, democracy must come before all else. I arrived in Arkansas by way of another little town in Louisiana, where all but a few local businesses had boarded up when Walmart moved in. Didn’t they know that, from 1988 to 1990, Bill Clinton gave Tyson Foods $7. E. Escaping poverty is always difficult, unless one lives in a well functioning social democracy like in Scandinavia. 1, 2016. So a overwhelming majority dislike this man. I took their order, brought their food, and when they finished eating, dropped off the check. There is no money growing on trees for that rich baby in the wilderness to accumulate. It’s not just the soil. Maybe the answer lies not in looking up, but in looking sideways and recognizing that our poor neighbors, who may be different than us, are struggling too. When the Kuwaiti parliament was dissolved this past December, an Islamist parliamentarian demanded the new house — devoid of a single female legislator — discuss his proposed “decent attire” law. Of course, you can look at Obama’s U6, which is the number you’re likely talking about (instead of the commonly reported U2), or any other unemployment measures if you’d like, but then you’ll need to compare those figures to the SAME figures for previous presidents. While I don’t believe the Democrats have all the right answers, I do believe they are on the right and decent side of history on most issues. We either assume everyone around us is just like us or that no one around us is like us, both usually being wrong. Except in your imagination. In a Social Darwinian banana republic like ours, the benefits for the upper classes always come at great costs to the lower classes. It is incredibly frustrating to me that the slavery narrative, that the rugged individualism narrative, that the free-loader narrative continue to be perpetuated by the top — and then believed by the poor. In 1964 Hillary Clinton campaigned for Senator Barry Goldwater whose platform included repealing the Civil Rights Act. It’s simply a word. The Scandinavian countries and many other Western countries are doing better than the US now. Where all these things went on, some of us said the hell with it and moved to big cities, typically on the coasts, and worked at getting our lives working. If you disagree with me, then give compelling reasons. And my sense of humor is often dry. The fascist wishes for one of his eyes to be taken. They have no savings and nothing to borrow against. Looking at the bigger picture, the wealth gap causes most of the issues we see regarding crime, lack of education etc. I don’t think that any of those things, individually or collectively, are the impetus of Trump’s popularity with lower class white men. I could have sworn that when I read “Master of the Senate,” the authoritative biography of Johnson’s time as Senate Majority Leader, it described Johnson as the one who tried to push it through the Senate. Hope this helps. S. Also, why is the author blaming only the CEO of Tyson Foods, and not the political spectrum that facilitated and allowed for such practice in the first place? And though I did earn a B. I only have one problem with this article and that is the section about welfare. I’ve been to stock car races, listened to country music, and watched pro-wrestling. Ntil the first African slaves were brought to Jamestown, Virginia, in 1619, wealthy plantation owners relied on indentured servants for cheap labor. Yet in the Democratic Debate in flint Bernie quote on quote says, “When you’re white … you don’t know what it’s like to be poor. You’re life doesn’t even amount to a worthless piece of trash. Working-class passivity, antipathy to intellect, and belligerence toward the outside world start early. I’m a liberal, but I was raised by conservatives and spent part of my youth in the conservative Deep South. Poor people are allowed to read whatever they want. Poor and working class whites signed up by the hundreds of thousands to fight for what they believed was their way of life. Trump told Forbes in April 2011, “Basically I’ve used the laws of the country to my advantage and to other people’s advantage … just as many, many others on top of the business world have. Neighbors Saudi Arabia and Yemen, for instance, might be eons apart when it comes to GDP, but only four places separate them on the index, with the kingdom at 131 and Yemen coming in at 135 out of 135 countries. For someone who works very hard their entire life for democratic ideals, and who might be just a little too moderate for your taste, I think you know that was an over the top remark. ’s two-party democracy offers 120-some million U. It’s a fascinating topic and it is complex. After seeing war and death, it can be hard to re-enter normal life as if nothing changed, especially if you’re dealing with other ongoing issues related to your military service. I fight for racial equality because people of color are not my enemy. As a Diversity Advocate at the Juilliard School, Ariel used her own experiences growing up in a non-traditional family to open up tough conversations with her fellow students. I’ve felt this anger more times than I care to remember. In a 2008 survey by the Egyptian Center for Women’s Rights, more than 80 percent of Egyptian women said they’d experienced sexual harassment and more than 60 percent of men admitted to harassing women. Many comments here absolutely demonstrate just how divided we are because, rather than accept our commonalities and work together to defeat the growing oppression of the vast majority of Americans, we have spent our time fighting over minute details of our differences. Remarkable. Especially for a populist who tends to feel the overall numbers of the people’s opinions do matter. It would be hypocrisy for me to not criticize the political left for the same reasons I’d criticize the political right. The left, that those on the right value hard work and determination and those on the left are lazy and want everything handed to them. I dated a girl there whose family was fundamentalist and lived in a trailer on a rural country road that was on the side of a mountain. Anecdotal evidence isn’t that helpful. Not surprised to see critical comments from those who identify themselves as “Conservative”. Less poverty and inequality. So bad is it for women in Saudi Arabia that those tiny paternalistic pats on their backs are greeted with delight as the monarch behind them, King Abdullah, is hailed as a “reformer” — even by those who ought to know better, such as Newsweek, which in 2010 named the king one of the top 11 most respected world leaders. The man earning $22 an hour driving gravel trucks is making that because that is what the job is worth to his employer. Walt The Problem With Making Hate Speech Illegal Suzanne Nossel The Game Is Over, and North Korea Has Won Jeffrey Lewis Donald Trump Is Dropping Bombs at Unprecedented Levels Micah Zenko Brexit’s Dunkirk Fantasyland Emile Simpson Stephen Miller Has a Point, You Cosmopolitans James Traub Turkey’s Post-Coup Purge and Erdogan’s Private Army Leela Jacinto On a Mission to Mars, Imprisoned in Turkey Lauren Bohn Why Trump’s Foreign Policy Can’t Be Stopped Aaron David Miller The EU Is Alive and Well, But the Referendums Are Coming Bruce Stokes Screw Brad Pitt and the ‘War Machine’ He Rode in On Whitney Kassel Is There Anything Normal About the Firing of James Comey? First off, great article. ” I guess she assumed I would learn to make drinks. It would take a lot of us to make that change, I fear we will not have the numbers anytime soon because people are too prideful, and hatred is too ingrained in us. This fear and mistrust continued for decades, not just in the South, but throughout all of America. If you read the article you will note that the Wealthy Americans purposely brought illegal immigrants to this country for their own financial gain, to exploit them. The other side was my white family, consisting of my father, and my grandparents (divorced, separated, and in different homes, yet who still hung around each other a lot for the sake of me and their sons). Our current welfare is not designed to help people get out of poverty as much as it is designed to keep them there. But I do read a lot. I won’t claim to have it all figured out. This left a tiny portion of the federal budget for social programs on the chopping block, including food stamps, vocational education, and subsidized housing, among others. No, I was raised in a liberal church, attended public school in forced segregation (we loved it! Despite the seeming appearance of wealth and security on my father’s side, it was illusory. If this article was intended to reveal power relationships in a representative-democracy, it was very good, if it was intended to understand why poor white voters vote the way they do, I think there has to be a more normative discussion about what actually matters to poor white people. “Yet, when it was written, we could not have called it a socialist manifesto. Magazines? He eventually returned home to write about the people who had stayed in the poor white community he left. There were plenty of people who were scamming the system, or worked within the limits of the system to maintain their welfare benefits. I’d suggest a good dog. Many older people don’t understand the world has changed. Even if we are to make it racial, your argument is proven false. Life for actual poor people, the working poor, is something you evidently don’t have a good frame of reference for, probably because you don’t live in a part of the country where homeless people are a common sight up-close-and-personal (as opposed to seeing them occasionally from your car or something) and you can get a good sense of how they actually think and act. Across the highway from the bar was the trailer park where I lived. In the article you write “This is a group of people who have almost effortlessly been manipulated by some pretty despicable people into voting against their own interests and aligning themselves with people who have nothing in common with them. Of course I also understood the importance of situational awareness and would not have shared my personal views with you who, if you speak like you write, would have quickly revealed your negative conservative attitude and closed-minded “my way or the highway” views of the world. Martin Luther King Jr was assassinated not murdered! Socialism was, on the Continent at least, “respectable”; communism was the very opposite. I take good ideas and insights wherever I find them. Okay, fair points. Newspapers earlier last century used to have labor sections as they still have business sections. If more conservatives read him than just complained about him, we might be better prepared to deal with these problems. The actual difference is what they both have done over that period of time. I think I even pointed out that, compared to all other candidates, Sanders has the strongest support among low income Americans. As slavery expanded in the South and indentured servitude declined, the wealthy elite offered poor whites the earliest version of the American Dream: if they worked hard enough, they could achieve prosperity, success, and upward social mobility — if not for themselves, then perhaps for future generations. The original state constitution forbade African Americans from even living here. Ariel Horowitz calls herself both an artist and an activist. She is a war hawk, tough-on-crime neocon. Generally speaking, the exploiting class has to pay most of the taxes since they are taking most of the benefit from society. There are a ton of factory towns in this part of Iowa. I’m for civic rights for all: minorities, immigrants, LGBT, Muslims, atheists, etc. If you want to deal with the problems of free trade and immigration, then the only realistic candidate is Sanders. If not for that comfort he’d have likely died homeless. Poor blacks experience not only more multi-generational severe poverty but also more economic segregation, based on a long and continuing history of systemic and structural racism. They looked like most everyone else in the area, blue-collar scruffy types. Carlucci; and former British Prime Minister John Major. Our founding fathers had no interest in democracy. I don’t descend from aristocracy or monarchy, as far as I know. Work harder. … “We want to cut this,” is much more abstract than even the busing thing, uh, and a hell of a lot more abstract than “Nigger, nigger. I am hungry for more…I had just heard a powerful sermon over the Internet given by Bishop T. Anyway, Jesus never used those words at all, since he didn’t speak English. My trailer was parked in the middle of Walmart country, which is also home to J. He doesn’t just talk but has lived by his principles, both in his actions as a private citizen and as a politician. Moreover, we have, ever since, been far from repudiating it” Regarding your comment, Dene, about serving in the USAF and never meeting one person that was a liberal or democrat, you were in a different AF than the one I served in! This is the type of thing that people usually only understand when they’ve been poor in a city. This is unprecedented. What would you rather the poor do, start a revolution and hang all the evil bastards that cause them so much harm? S. ” “Other poor people aren't the enemy, no matter how they look, how they pray, or who they love. First of all, the largest proportion of homeless are veterans dealing with brain trauma or post-traumatic stress disorder, along with everything related to it: increased violence, drug addiction, alcoholism, etc. Now, our top bracket caps out at <$500k — ask yourself, why is that? I also promise you that you won’t hear much views from the left on the MSM. First of all I have not seen how even raising 90% tax on 1% would help pay for much of what he is saying, but that is besides the point. She interrupts her reverie to make coffee dutifully for her husband to drink after his nap. Jonna, I value your essay quite a lot–it updates Thomas Frank’s *Whats the Matter with Kansas* but with much more empathy and first-person perspective. And where big biz joined forces with big religion, specifically by way of the California mega-churches. They are fighting to be heard. ), and consumed any and all knowledge I could with this blessing of a brain I have. He basically handed everything over without any sort of guarantee that he would be entitled to its wealth or earnings later on. Norway itself has a population of about 5 million, or that of a large American city, and a disinclination to take much in the way of immigration. Go live deep in the wilderness all by yourself and see how long you last. ” “You’ve done a lot of answering and correcting on this thread and that is your right I suppose. I’ve spent a great deal of my life living in poverty. This was in 1962. The point is that creates a long political record upon which to judge a candidate. Many careers require doing unpaid intern work, which many people can’t afford. OK – maybe “too stupid” is the wrong phrase. I’m basing my own views on demographic and public opinion data, including data on how people identify themselves. My family of Vets all support him and my disabled Vet father has beem waiting for heart surgery. Sir are you with out Sin, If so continue to throw stones. We will be completely exterminated and the land will be left in the possession of the blacks, and then it will go back to a wilderness and become another Africa or Saint Domingo. He argues that if you want the American Dream you are better off moving to Canada (twice the social mobility of the U. Where does the author see that Trump will stand against this, by the way? We guarantee the authenticity of your paper, whether it's an essay or a dissertation. ” Leftists have little power in our country. Also, plenty of liberals are equally critical of fundamentalism in other religions. I would see “liberals” attributing malicious motives to conservatives at all turns, hurling invective and spitefulness and wishing ill on others for nothing more than their political beliefs. Don’t just dismiss me because I’m presenting evidence that is inconvenient to your beliefs. Fixed: “That evaporated when poor Southern whites bought into the southern strategy and fell (once again) for letting the rich use racism to get them to vote against their own interests”. An entire political and economic system — one that treats half of humanity like animals — must be destroyed along with the other more obvious tyrannies choking off the region from its future. What would America look like today if King had succeeded in uniting poor people of all races? Both were tough men who came of age through tough times and subscribed to a mix of cynicism and idealism that was characteristic of early 20th-century America. (No I wasn’t alive during slavery but i was directly affected by it) Have you ever heard of Willie Lynch? Seeing an opportunity to realize a higher return on investment, elite colonial landowners began to favor African slaves over white indentured servants, and shifted their business models accordingly. But modern DNA analysis flagged Iberian Peninsula as the major source but with almost equal amounts of Irish and British with traces of several other regions. Therefore the head tax is the far-right Republicans’ ultimate goal; by stark contrast, Donald Trump wants to lower the income tax rate to zero for all singles making less than $25,000 a year, and married couples making less than $50,000. You stay over there. My cup is running over because I am a political junkie. ” He bootstrapped his way into politics and has remained loyal to the poor and working class for more than thirty years. As the British labor market improved in the 1680s, the idea of indentured servitude lost its appeal to many would-be immigrants. Then lets solve the problem of the Elites protecting their own – that will be the time for Bernie Sanders. Salwa el-Husseini, the first Egyptian woman to speak out against the “ virginity tests“; Samira Ibrahim, the first one to sue; and Rasha Abdel Rahman, who testified alongside her — they are our Bouazizis. Well, actually most of the people have left most of those places. It was. Loved Your Article. And if they take a job, they might not be able to get welfare benefits. I wish I lived in a society that wasn’t obsessed with class identity and class war. He told me how much he regretted screwing things up with me and not doing more to help me succeed (I’m a successful senior, graduating in a few weeks and going on to graduate school for astronomy). Yet eventually good jobs with good benefits along with well funded public education and state colleges helped to pull my mother’s family out of poverty. Some things you can’t learn from a book! They’re economic non-actors for psychosocial reasons. Most liberals aren’t critical of conservative Christians for their religion, but for their reactionary attitudes. You had me wrapped around your finger, until you dismissed the “Welfare Queen” stereotype as being baseless. Right now all it sounds like is he’s calling out the pitchforks to take on the 1% … because that’s really all he’s got. Donald Trump is far from another “Classist” using “Racism” to divide and rob the nation. TRUMP is attacking the same 1% Establishment from a wider, all encompassing area than Sanders’s narrow “Wall Street -The 1%” rhetoric. To the Klan, it meant one thing and for you, I guess, it means something else. And every politician keeps pushing the same old arguments while doing nothing for the people and getting his re-election money from the big company’s. It is demented and morally depraved to call him a Nazi collaborator. Even illegal aliens could get welfare for their kids, but of course these same illegal immigrants don’t pay their taxes which increases the tax burden of us legal residents who do. And there are millions of Americans who are as smart or smarter, as hard working or moreso than your father. He never stated whites don’t understand poverty. I grew up as a poor, white kid. Hell, Pootie, if immigrants can put together successful businesses of their own, why can’t you keep up with your truck payments? Then — the 1980s and 1990s — as now, clerics on Saudi TV were obsessed with women and their orifices, especially what came out of them. It’s similar to when Republicans did drug testing on welfare recipients, and it turned out that they had lower rates of drug use than the general population. That’s how it is when you’ve bombed the productive capacity of the rest of the industrial world back into the bronze age, and you’re the only person left in the market. I do count my blessings. Fact of the matter is Democrats get MORE poor votes (white and all other colors), specifically ones relying on welfare and food stamp programs from their social welfare policies. Tell history in a way that its not offensive. Thus, in 1847, socialism was a middle-class movement, communism a working-class movement. I was about to thank Colton as well. There have been a number of articles I’ve seen lately with conservative authors expressing this attitude. If poor and working class whites who chant, “Trump, Trump, Trump,” believe they have little in common with these “enemies,” they are mistaken. He supports a two state solution for Palestine and Israel. “So to the author or anyone else: What do you think would fix these deep divides in America? I know it’s a slip of the tongue and he later corrected himself, but this is what makes them think it’s OK to shittalk “rednecks” and “white trash”, as you also pointed out yourself. B. I just hope all people of the world realize that the average American is just one poor mother fucker. She did her homework. That would describe my mother’s family up until grandfather’s generation when they moved to central Indiana and found better paying work with the railroads and factories. Quite a few of them were poor. , and employing them at fifteen chicken processing plants throughout the country. Now, Trump wants power and control, too. Working class represents much diversity—depending on race, ethnicity, religion, region, etc. From a business perspective, a white baby was a liability, but African children were permanent assets. Even though few of them ever benefited from it. The inequality of which we all complain took a big inflection point just then. I’ve never argued that being a white indentured servant or Chinese railroad worker was a life of luxury. I think the future generations may have a chance. If that isn’t good enough for you, go to the library or use your wonderful piece of science called a computer to read more about American history. That will happen when #BernieWinsTheWhiteHouse. And all this for a white male. And don’t for a moment pretend the poor don’t try to fight against this, even as the deck is stacked against them. You must be ignoring the “Mexicans are rapists” or “I’m going to build a great wall, the best wall” or “we should ban all Muslims from our country”. In terms of both total numbers and per capita of each demographic, Americans are more likely to be attacked by a white Christian and then have their lives saved by an Arab-American Muslim. All it takes is one person with a gun to assassinate somebody. If he can’t stand up to the bullies in his own party, how well could he stand up to the globalist Washington establishment? The The Greek word used in the new testament for “sin” is hamartia. All you have to do is look back at the unfunded No Child Left Behind program or the scam of “teacher-based accountability. That did make it cheaper compared to today. Hillary was an 18 year old college freshman when she supported Goldwater in 1964 (she was too young to actually vote for him). The most racist thing said by a candidate so far? They worked hard, and insisted that their children go to college. My parents owned their own small business in a relatively progressive city in the mid-atlantic South and completely bought into the conservative ideology that liberals want to give everything away at the expense of the “true hard-working, educated Americans. If you read enough about Jamestown in its first years, it was more a hard scramble for survival, not Miss Scarlett with her iced tea on the veranda of Tara. I don’t see anything particularly unusual about being working class. These days, it’s harder to believe that. It showed that he could not be trusted. His father dropped out of high school and supported the family as a paint salesman after coming to the U. Another beer, please. I have talked to multiple Social workers and even former welfare recipients who attest that they see abuses in the welfare system all of the time. That is simply because third party candidates have no chance of winning. You don’t truly grasp how much terror groups act against our nation, and it appears you just don’t catch the news often given how many extremists act out on our soil; let alone the dozens of attacks happening in Europe currently with clear ties to various extremist groups. Some that appeared to be homeless weren’t actually homeless, but simply were scraggly people who spent a lot of time downtown. Welfare is considered a moral failure. I was disappointed she took,what I believe was a very well organised argument and then clumsily turned it into a Sander’s argument. According to Wikipedia, about half the whites coming to the American Colonies were indentured servants, average age 24 years. I served my country in the Air Force and not one person I ever met was a Liberal or DemocRAT! An investment in African slaves also ensured a cost-effective, long-term workforce. Just put in your vote for Trump, who will lose the election, then disappear for another 4 write cover letter phd studentship years until some other hate-and-fear-monger wins the republican nomination. You are correct, though, that at least initially few colonists supported revolution. Us dumb asses who have not been sufficiently educated in our own history. But I think that, as usual when trying to prove a thesis like this, she’s trying to prove a level of collusion within a class that is more coincidental than designed. Poor whites in Democratic states have lower than average social problems and this effects their lives in fundamental ways, and so influences how they vote. I’ll admit, it’s an odd construction, but STIR has chosen to err on the side of respect. This has been done in the past by Banning people of other countries on a temporary basis. You are either unable to digest and internalize the data provided in this article, have not read it or prefer to remain ignorant in the face of facts that counter your current belief system. They don’t represent me. All of that has already been proven beyond a doubt. Still, any sane and rational person given a choice between indentured service and slavery wouldn’t likely choose the latter. Really. If you presented evidence and someone dismissed it, you wouldn’t take kindly to that. When will we realize we have more in common with all poor people than with rich capitalists and corrupt politicians who manipulate the system to increase their own wealth, power, and control? I have lived below the poverty level. I am British, but so much of what you wrote rings true in my country as well. That was an increase from 39,000 in 2013 and 24,000 in 2012. As far the Klan, the people opposing it have been diverse. You, on the other hand, come across as arrogant and tiresome, and while maybe you are neither, your commentary is. Bernie absolutely does bait when he makes statements like “white people don’t feel poverty” in order to win black votes even though an overwhelming majority of welfare recipients are whites. I say that because I have had quite a bit of experience with people on both the upper 10% and the bottom 90%. People go to one source and think they’re going to get all the same information from every outlet and that’s simply not true. This is a small, rural community and they vote Republican! The Heartbeat Project, founded by Ariel and co-founder Leerone Hakami, addresses the marginalization of arts education in disenfranchised communities. He is not more of the same. And they stay dumb and drink beer at Royal Lunch and vote Republican because no real liberal voice, the kind that speaks the rock-bottom, undeniable truth, ever enters their lives. Trump shows us all. It also leaves so much room for interpretation that it’s hard to know the intended meaning of it, the moral of the story. Female slaves were often raped by their white owners or forced to breed with male slaves, and children born into slavery remained slaves for life. In December 1967, King and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC) began organizing the Poor People’s Campaign of 1968. It seems if you study history, guns are just a tool, the people behind them and their motives are what actually matter. Trump is running a simple more relateable and realistic platform – he is saying go nationalistic, reverse globalist trade laws which have enabled rampant outsourcing, bring manufacturing back, stop illegal wars, seal up the border. Anecdotally, I have lived in an impoverished rural area, and most families I knew and worked with relied on SSI as a permanent source of income for the whole family. In “ Distant View of a Minaret,” the late and much-neglected Egyptian writer Alifa Rifaat begins her short story with a woman so unmoved by sex with her husband that as he focuses solely on his pleasure, she notices a spider web she must sweep off the ceiling and has time to ruminate on her husband’s repeated refusal to prolong intercourse until she too climaxes, “as though purposely to deprive her. If you’re deemed inferior and worthless, you’re supposed to get out of the way or you get forced out of the way, violently if necessary. In your example of everyone walking to the other side of the room when talking about who has higher education, I would have been on the “educated” side. No he was simply pushing propaganda . Larry Hawkins SC, I think the author of this is brilliant and thoughtful. This is one of the reasons poor whites don’t like the Democrats: they say stuff like this. And why have declines in unemployment and growth of the economy been so much greater when there was a Democratic president rather than a Republican in the White House? You’ve done a lot of answering and correcting on this thread and that is your right I suppose. Qaradawi has since issued a fatwa against female genital mutilation, but it comes as no surprise that when Egypt banned the practice in 2008, some Muslim Brotherhood legislators opposed the law. I was responding to an article that seemed to overly rely on economic interests to explain why poor (or as you point out, middle class, but we will come back to this) rural white people seem to be supporting Trump. With the choice being homeless or Vancouver – I chose Vancouver. Not a single person looked at us. I simply can’t believe that he cares at all about supporting this group or, for that matter, betraying them. The difference is the cultural frame of reference. Maybe if we all look up together, we can see more clearly that the hand of oppression belongs only to those who have always had money, power, and control. But you have some problem with taxes going up to pay for social programs that in return benefit people, including the middle class who you think are being taken? Who would blame them for being angry? How many times have we been told to get a job, or that if we just worked harder we could improve our situation? ” Click To Tweet Like their ancestors who fought in and survived the Civil War, today’s soldiers return to find their situations either the same, or much worse, than when they left. “It’s one of those persistent symbols that come up every election cycle,” says Kaaryn Gustafson, author of Cheating Welfare: Public Assistance and the Criminalization of Poverty. But it doesn’t end there. Which is it? If you share Hillary Clinton’s views, don’t be ashamed of her actual political positions. Heck, even that would be selling you short. Kids these days have to work harder for less gain. His disdain for welfare hadn’t changed. So thank you from the bottom of my heart. That’s it. I don’t have it in me to go back and re-read all 1,166 pages to confirm, but here’s an excerpt of the NYT Book Review of “Master of the Senate” if you’d like to see a citation: The truth is that politicians of Nixon and LBJ’s generation were very wise men who had a much sharper understanding of racial issues in the US than people today give them credit for. It is a culture within a culture, a place with its own mores and loyalties. I get the sense that you were assuming I was a well off white liberal who knows nothing about poverty. I understood their fear and frustration. You had me in the first three or four paragraphs. Most Southerners either identify with or lean toward the Democratic party (the same is true with many rural states, especially Midwestern farm states). Obviously this author also ignores the facts of what Islamic migrants are doing to Europe, like their rape gangs, and Islamic “no-go zones” where the Muslims have more power than the regional government and the police are afraid to go there, all enabled by “tolerance. What exactly do you think happens to all the “undeserved” income received by people at the bottom of the wage scale when there is an increase in the minimum wage? Don Tyson, having lived his entire life in northwest Arkansas, was one of them. He even criticizes Israel and supports a two-state solution. And if Trump does somehow – you have grounds for actual political revolution with classism as its main platform. My only point was that it was better than slavery. This the dumbest thing I’ve ever read! “Another issue that critics raise with the premise for Trump’s proposals is that immigration from Mexico is actually declining. ” Then you prove this by showing how the economic interests of poor white people are not in line with the economic interests of the politically elite. Bernie Sanders was born into a working-class home. Many slaves were horribly tortured. Sixty years ago, the government was interested in the problems of Appalachia. I personally could care less who enters the pointless offices that have become life long occupations for those who feel they’re above the average folk. Making fun of poor Southern whites was okay then–see Lil’ Abner, and the Beverly Hillbillies–but there was also sincere interest in understanding and solving their problems. I grew up white, in a small, dilapidated trailer-park. I’m tired of it all too. Being a poor white doesn’t inevitably make one a reactionary, for it depends on local politics and culture. Voices McMaster’s former staff officer in Iraq: A general must not just stand by while a lie is being promulgated Thomas E. You can even find such writing is Salon if you look hard enough and relegate your searching to pieces published after major elections. Thank you for sharing this. From my experience in rural America, poor whites do not see the ‘welfare’ they receive (SSI, farm subsidies, EITC, Obamacare) in the same light as minorities who receive some of the same benefits. Don’t forget that most wealth in the United States is inherited, not earned. But at least we could always believe that our kids had a chance for a better life. By the way, the data shows that immigrants don’t just take jobs for they also have high rates of starting businesses. Our experienced writers are professional in many fields of knowledge so that they can assist you with virtually any academic task. That happens to be you at the moment. I’ve heard many Trump supporters say that, if Trump doesn’t get nominated and Sanders does, they’ll vote for Sanders. “What’s the Matter with Kansas” etc. The political establishment, including the DNC, and the partisan mainstream media have shown themselves to be dismissive of democracy. I’d point out that Sanders has been railing against the military-industrial complex for all those decades he was an independent, and has brought up the issue of massive fraud in the defense industry. Even after these “revolutions,” all is more or less considered well with the world as long as women are covered up, anchored to the home, denied the simple mobility of getting into their own cars, forced to get permission from men to travel, and unable to marry without a male guardian’s blessing — or divorce either. They are the forebears of ‘po white trash’. The poor have almost no power in our society or in most societies in the world. I remember being proud when I was finally able to buy my monitor after saving up what I could–it was on sale–and yet it went towards the image that I was somehow gaming the system. A decade from now, five of the ten fastest-growing jobs will be menial, dead-end jokes on the next generation—mainly retail clerks, cashiers, and janitors, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Furthermore, we ensure confidentiality of your personal information, so the chance that someone will find out about our cooperation is slim to none. So much of the “whites had it better” has been ignoring a large chunk of American history–yes, the slaves had it terrible and no reasonably intelligent person will even begin to argue that–but the entire narrative loses credibility when it forgets the horrible, inhumane, and torturous treatment of the Irish and Chinese immigrants who were forced into slavery on the railroads. 8 million in tax breaks while turning a blind eye to 300 miles of rivers polluted from chicken waste? That would be hubris. That the fiscal union hypocritically favors Red states is true. I’d suggest you might want to rethink your reasons. G. They have allowed a solid and extensive middle class to be plunged into economic insecurity by policies that favor the rich, they continually vote people into government who don’t want to do any actual governing (which is their job), and they harbor ludicrous fantasies about the rest of the world (e. Yet, if one doesn’t get a college degree, one has no hope of getting one of those jobs that requires a college degree. If you’re to go through this much effort researching and writing a piece this long, the sources should with a doubt accompany it. This area was anti-slavery before the Civil War and sided with the North, at least philosophically, during the war. By 1926, unemployment was 1. Working class seems normal to me. The Declaration of Independence and the first constitution, the Articles of Confederation, expressed a radical vision. The latter would be a hundred times more effective than the wall, but doubling down on the wall is a sign of commitment to his supporters. G. That’s much different than patronizing. As the number of African slaves grew, landowners realized they had a problem on their hands. If one was to rationally choose between the two main parties, the Democrats are the lesser evil. There are two basic facts about welfare recipients. Conservative. It didn’t stop my mother from working hard to graduate from college. Bernie has a far longer and more beneficial history with people of color than Hillary Clinton. Who it is that benefits from cutting American wages? You should not assume that because they are poor and you are wanting to help them out of their poverty, that means they are stupid because they do not want to support you. What had appeared to be the continued convergence of the two parties has been revealed by Mr. Yes, Saudi Arabia, the country where a gang-rape survivor was sentenced to jail for agreeing to get into a car with an unrelated male and needed a royal pardon; Saudi Arabia, where a woman who broke the ban on driving was sentenced to 10 lashes and again needed a royal pardon; Saudi Arabia, where women still can’t vote or run in elections, yet it’s considered “progress” that a royal decree promised to enfranchise them for almost completely symbolic local elections in — wait for it — 2015. Do women have sex drives or not? For a brief period my mom and father lived in the house with her, along with my half-brother (on my mother’s side) but tensions quickly caused that to fall apart. Trump’s one of you guys now, so he will never get my vote either. Understand that now it very well might be Woman. I’m going to leave Malcom X out of this conversation. Don’t forget that California is filled with generations of people who came from the South. Practically no one who isn’t white is voting for Donald Trump. There are poor and homeless people in this town and it isn’t extremely different from being poor and homeless anywhere else. When it comes to essay writing, an in-depth research is a big deal. In fact their voices are heard in MSM only when a candidate like Trump emerges and the rest of the country wakes up and asks ‘What the f*** is going on here? Robert Kennedy, a key advocate for the campaign, was assassinated on June 6, 1968, a month into the campaign. I’m a strong liberal, but I want to make sure that the liberalism I hold to is worth defending. That’s why I’m voting for Sanders. By simply escalating the rhetoric that inflames them, he captured an existing group to get the nomination. Or how many people in general don’t talk about their religious views. I was born and spent my early childhood in a small factory town. Some may ask why I’m bringing this up now, at a time when the region has risen up, fueled not by the usual hatred of America and Israel but by a common demand for freedom. I’m concerned about our future. I’m genuinely curious about what groupings you think make sense. But sensationalized liberal sites such as this only focus on the few uneducated that endorse these policies, when in reality, Democrats have plenty of low socioeconomic classes that some may consider “trash” that vote Democrat for the wrong reasons. A slave owner could beat a slave to death, if they wanted to, and no one would think twice about it. In June, 50,000 demonstrators joined them for the Solidarity Day Rally for Jobs, Peace, and Freedom. Did Ronald Reagan care about poor white people when he trotted out the fictional welfare queen, or did he need a budget item to cut? Where people come from often does limit them, such as being born poor in a poor state. Anthony. Some of these people started life as working poor or else their parents did. His followers believe him, and he gains a lot of support from his promises to renegotiate our trade agreements to improve the value of American labor by American citizens in America. They created this group to control the Republican primary process and, therefore, which candidates got on the ticket. The encouraging news is that most of these people have not turned to Donald Trump’s brand of revanchist proto-fascism; the question is whether, beyond pandering, there will come a time when the U. How smart can they be? That used to be a fairly typical experience for many working class people in the era when the economy was booming and economic mobility was high. This is because the big money donors don’t really care which party wins and often donate simultaneously to candidates on both sides. Most the things that the author takes pride in — economic security, educational accomplishment — aren’t available to them. The Occupy movement might have been even larger. That is where your light shines the brightest. I don’t think Sanders necessarily has to do anything to reach many of them. My point is, using race in politics should be at the minimum. It takes someone like Sanders to point out something so obvious. What is this March that you speak of? American society has made it perfectly clear: if you are poor, it’s your own damn fault. You should know this because I’m going jump out on a limb and say you consider your self educated. Indeed, the younger generation is more liberal, but not because they’ve never experienced conservatism. Donald Trump is a business man. In many cases, advancing the interests of the rest of the world advances the interests of the United States as well, but the nationalist sees helping the rest of the world as a means to an end — advancing the interests of their own country. You could check out Joan Walsh while you’re at it. In fact, most liberals are Christians. Mar. I have on many occasions at this very tavern found an agreeing ear to all of the very arguments made above. But something to ponder for a future article. And in recent years I’ve settled in this small Midwestern college town in Iowa, not exactly a state that is known for its liberal elite. To avoid confusion, let me provide working definitions. ” Their daddies and mamas taught them to accept responsibility for their actions. Meanwhile the elites steal your soul and keep you poor and dumb. And you will learn about it in the context of world history, not just American provincialism. The local towns even have plots for people who don’t have land. Yer needin’ to read for content, darlin’. As an educated (semi-urban) woman, I loathe “family values” social conservatives because they are the ones who tell me that the education I have invested years of time and energy in obtaining has no value, and that a desire to do anything with my life other than serve in solitary house arrest as their personal nanny-cook-housekeeper slave is the epitome of a selfish and lazy character. No one paid him to take a look at their car and fix the problem if he could. Socialism was always about working hard and making sure that the people benefited from the work they did instead of the benefit mostly going to the already rich. I think that you get a lot right in your article, but I think that there are some places where you overstate your case, which weakens your overall message. , and 3,000 participants occupied “Resurrection City” for over a month. It’s just not the same. Typical CNN talking points and very inaccurate view of his actual policies and speeches. I wasn’t very good at my job, but one thing I was good at was listening. There is a whole lot of money in that pocket of Arkansas, but the grand wealth casts an oppressive shadow over a region entrenched in poverty. A poster boy for generations of socioeconomic privilege, Trump joined the New York Military Academy at age thirteen, then studied at Fordham University before transferring to the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania. Coming together united by our shared poverty and struggles is what all of us as Americans need, stop seeing each other as one color or creed or affiliation and realize that for better or worse WE ARE ALL AMERICANS! Some data shows that STEM degree unemployment has increased. There are poor whites all over the country and they aren’t all the same. Listen to those of us fighting. The kinds of comments you make and the questions you ask indicate someone who hasn’t had much in-depth and diverse experience with working class people. Perhaps we need to return to that moment from our national past– a moment of great possibility snuffed out before it could thrive– for clues for how to help the “99 percent” better understand and move from within our commonalities-in-difference. Is this simply a matter of bad luck for the Republicans and good luck for the Democrats? Not on scoring small little points with those with which you may agree more than dissent. It was the liberal elitists who, earlier last century, were one of the main enemies of leftists. One night, the instructors gathered the forty or so trainees for an exercise. On the other side of Country Club Road, trailer parks are tucked back in the woods. That is how so many blacks ended up concentrated in inner cities. And that means educating everybody, not just the small-town valedictorian or the science nerds who are cherry-picked out of the schools in places like Winchester or more rural areas. My coworkers have included many types of people, but certainly I’ve worked with many people who live in or were raised in rural areas. These white servants were mostly poor Europeans who traded their freedom for passage to the American colonies. We must not wait for them to die to become so. “Black” has effectively replaced “African-American,” which was always capitalized. I said “most” by which I meant wealth in a relative sense. Mark wrote: “That being said, I stand by the quote from George Will. That is the way it is in a Social Darwinian society. If you’ve ever tried to live on minimum wage, you’d know why that is the case. Trump is “the chickens coming home to roost” for the GOP. In fact, Jewish Super PACs are supporting Hillary over him because she of course panders to them (like she does to everyone else) while Bernie has called out Israel for numerous attacks on civilians in “self-defense” and the ridiculous amount of money we pour into Israel for some reason. Inked-up weirdos who occupy trailers out near the superfund cleanup sights. ). Just look at all the HATE surrounding his campaign. I wasn’t. My friend who drives a bus has a degree in architecture and obviously architecture degrees became less valuable when construction decreased after the housing bubble busted. I regularly come across conservative pundits and authors offering condescension to poor whites. Did you read the article? The central contention here, that poor whites vote Republican because they are manipulated by cynical politicians who strategically use racism to stir their racial vanity while keeping them poor, is never even stated clearly, let alone argued, though it underpins the entire piece. The largest protest movement in US and world history was against the Iraq War. There is no evidence that Jesus was pointing to a specific sin. Are you sure that Johnson filibustered the 1957 Civil Rights Act? I’ve said I hold nothing against poor whites. Trump knows this; that’s why he said his focus won’t be on minimum wage workers but the middle class–THAT is where his support is coming from. There is a lot of misconceptions about “the media” that are harmful and perpetuated by vague comments like that. They’re morons. And now there is the first major candidate in US campaign history that, along with the largest crowds ever, has raised such large amounts of campaign contributions from small donations. Instead, slaveowners and those who profited from the slave economy took over the government and made a Civil War pretty much inevitable, as the Civil War was the result of what the American Revolution started. On the other hand, do job resume cover letter I assumed a group of liberal, college-educated volunteers would ooze warmth and solidarity. Yet there are plenty of poor whites in Iowa. That is seen in the South. I’m with ya Benjamin. (Maybe even downright com’nist, Pootie. BTW Thomas Frank most recently wrote a book criticizing the liberal class, by which he means the professional class. Thus, poor whites’ belief that they now shared status and dignity with their social betters was largely illusory. Hires with degrees in criminal justice, civil engineering, computer science or accountancy are always in high demand. Not surprisingly, however, poor whites never became the economic equals of the elite. It just so happens with a resource-rich nation like the US there is a lot to take. “A 2014 Bankrate survey, echoing the Fed’s data, found that only 38 percent of Americans would cover a $1,000 emergency-room visit or $500 car repair with money they’d saved. While this seems obviously true on some level, Ivin, in accordance with the conventions of the genre, puts this up as a prop through which she purports to explain all that she finds perplexing about the Poor White Vote. Your reality is not even reality. Many of my family lines go back to early America. The same might as well apply here. Being a poor Irish-American or Chinese-American in past centuries was challenging, to say the least. “The issue is the military industrial complex and all these protracted extended wars no one is calling a war. I see our economic and political system as a corporatist banana republic. Any free white man could whip a Black slave, and most important, poor whites could “police” Black slaves. This article acts like Republicans are the only ones that “bait”. C. In Tunisia, long considered the closest thing to a beacon of tolerance in the region, women took a deep breath last fall after the Islamist Ennahda party won the largest share of votes in the country’s Constituent Assembly. I don’t care about the Democratic party, as I’m an independent, but I will point out some basic facts. I am not American, and I do not intend to be American – however, I am always interested in American culture wars for two reasons: first, because my own country seems to repeat the same wars several years later; second, because it’s interesting in it’s own, like watching some weird reality show 😀 Nevertheless, I would like to comment on just one thing: though I am atheist, I have many religious friends. The causes of death are suicide, alcohol-related liver disease, and overdose, among others. The English and Anglo-American ruling elite had no problem sentencing to death, imprisoning, and indenturing large numbers of the poor English population. Marginalized people have been fighting for equality for decades. He gets that wherewithal from the wages he earns. A Pew study released in 2012 found that the figure had actually reached net zero, and possibly less. Permanent unemployment has became so high that the government simply stopped recording the data during the Reagan administration. Everybody is afraid of each other. India’s Supreme Court in 2008 declared illegal Bangladeshi migrants were hurting Indian laborers, thus the current popular Prime Minister has promised to handle the issue by stopping the illegal economic crossing into India. Sure, they pay more in taxes, as they benefit more from all that they don’t fully pay for such as natural resources. Admittedly, a real blue-collar middle class still exists in some places, just as unions still exist. May we all live to see it. I’d rather stay poor if this is your idea of the country getting better! If Mr. For example, in the Midwest, there are many Catholics (even in farm states like Iowa) and, for obvious reasons, most Catholics are ‘ethnics’ which is to say not of English ancestry (nor other ethnicities such as Scots-Irish). Of course, back then we had tax brackets that went up into the millions of dollars (before accounting for inflation! I really want to understand how liberals’ actions that are motivated by wanting to help are instead interpreted as being patronizing and insulting instead and, incredulously you say, more patronizing than conservatives. I strain to find compassion for those who kick down and kiss up. Even then, my mother had to help pay by working in college. Most liberals want to increase opportunities and resources for people to improve their own lives, the complete opposite of paternalism. I know someone with an accounting degree that is struggling because before he can get a job he has to get experience through an unpaid internship, but it’s not as if he can afford to work for free. One of the most ignored groups in the US are working class liberals. The oversized friendship guinea pig is a reminder of what humanity could achieve if we stopped yelling at each other on the internet. Most Southerners support Democrats, but there is so much voter disfranchisement, voter suppression, and voter demoralization that few of those Democratic-supporting potential voters end up voting. They aren’t all your people, you twit. One recent survey found that 55 percent of this group support Trump, meaning “the white working-class is under-represented among Trump supporters,” Metzgar observes, which means “his supporters are disproportionately college-educated whites. It’s simply because you, and so many others who’ve written analyses to explain what’s going on with Trump supporters, don’t speak the language to really understand, deeply and in your heart, what’s going on with the Blue Collar folks who support Trump. By and large they’re heavily capitalist, free market, economies, but with attached substantial welfare states. I don’t view myself as a victim, though I barely lived through a three year hell that left me with three major joints trashed–not even thirty and I’m forced to use a cane–a damaged spine, brain damage (some of which came from doctors pushing medications that were not fitting the symptoms because it was the pill du jour). Even earlier last century when leftists had more power, you found leftist ideology most popular among the poor and minorities: blacks dealing with Jim Crow, migrant workers confronting big ag, coal miners trying to organize, factory workers striking, etc. I don’t know how us poor, racist white folks even function with our limited intelligence(that’s called sarcasm) I see anyone who doesn’t toe the lib line on here is instantly called stupid, ignorant, etc….. Thank you for writing this piece. The Heartbeat project will take place on the Navajo (Diné) Reservation in New Mexico, and is hosted by Navajo Technical University. Many in the Middle class are a single job loss or health incident from falling into poverty. Polls show that most Southerners support or lean toward the Democratic party. It changed greatly over the centuries. For instance if their is another such “poor people’s campaign”, those organized on factory floors, retail outlets, ports, hospitals, and all workplaces will need guns to defend themselves against the capitalist state’s violence which will surely be mobilized against them. Jonna, I live a couple counties away from Benton, and you nailed it! Whatever portion of the working class had become convinced of the insufficiency of mere political revolutions, and had proclaimed the necessity of total social change, called itself Communist. The neighbors all hired work done because labor is so cheap in the South, for the simple reason poverty and unemployment is so high (there are always people looking for work). All the way back to our first national boogeyman, the British Empire. Expose our children to everyone and everything, talk to them and educate them, maybe through food, travel, or even a black doll to a little white girl, anything that’s just everyday life but it’ll make a difference in the long run. There are simply people who have working class jobs. We fight over guns, marriage, health care, abortion, Democrat vs Republican, rich vs poor, But so seldom do we agree on anything. The same goes for Sanders and the Democratic party. America may soon be in that same predicament if Bernie becomes POTUS. As for what I said about Bernie. I’m not sure how many times she has apologized for the Iraq vote, but it is clear that she was certainly stuck between a rock and hard spot being the actual senator from the actual center of all the attention, NYC. We first started hearing about the average Joe needing to take complete responsibility for his condition in life, with no help from the government, during the seventies, when Cold War conservatives Irving Kristol and Norman Podhoretz dubbed themselves “neoconservatives. I don’t know enough about her to confirm that this is the case with this author, but I have my suspicions. BTW those on the bottom of society don’t tend to like being called peasants. We have a lottery system where some get ahead while many don’t. And furthermore, those racists from different racial groups are fueling each other, they are stoking each other’s fires. But politicians keep implying that for minorities, public assistance is a way of life. That is not to say the class divide was not a steep and ugly ditch back then. Finally there has been the increasing social acceptance of identitarian politics, which largely ignore class (except as a supplement to racial politics) and are often driven (again, regardless of skin-color) by people who are privileged by class, people who redefined racism conveniently to exclude their own bigoted attitudes. The difference is that for those born wealthier they can be lazy, stupid, and do everything wrong and yet they’ll get endless opportunities and second chances, third chances, and on and on. I’m neither Christian, Conservative, nor Liberal. Liberals don’t mind fair-minded criticism of liberalism, just as long as it isn’t motivated by ignorant bigotry. I’m curious. As for Trump voters, they have a median household income of $72,000–that’s substantially higher than the national median household income and definitely NOT working class or poor. Muslims are not my enemy. Eight lynched in one week and five of them charged with rape! Redneck is very much a regional phenomenon, not found in the Upper Midwest. We Democrats have had our chances. ” Sanders actually isn’t a Democrat, except in order to run as a candidate. What you do not grasp is that benefiting from life with your parents in the burbs (having a strong safety net, social enfranchisement, and discounted rent in a safe neighborhood), is a huge privilege, so much so that you think your “learning disability” is in any way comparable to what actual working-class people have to life with. Unarmed man? People need to actually work hard and make things better for themselves! We are better off with a conservative in office. You seem to maybe have met a few poor people at some point in your life and now think that you can generalize about a massive complex demographic. Your piece is so powerful and factual. It’s always been a good way to distract the public from any meaningful conversations about poverty and inequality. I going to say the party i support is the American People, Please Im begging you just admit you are racist. We are a cruel and unforgiving society when it comes to attitudes and public policies directed toward the poor. Apparently the hat angers people. Part of the reason for this is that even the Democratic party establishment feels threatened by these people, as shown by the DNC’s response to Sanders’ campaign. There is a difference between symbolic and operational ideology: Sad that you can’t see that Donakd wants to help all Americans . These are the people who are living in fear of losing what little has been gained. I’ll stay over here. However, it doesn’t take a private school graduate degree to produce a well-thought-out piece like this. Is it a function of the “business cycle” that operates independently of human political choices, like a force of nature or an act of God that just happens to coincide with times when Republicans are presidents? I think that there is some truth in this, but it’s not the whole story. I’m pro-union and in fact I’m a union member. Neoconservatives hated the counterculture and saw it as the beginning of everything that was wrong with America. The culture war issue is a bit more complex, but keep in mind that many of these people are members of very conservative religious groups. The US used to have the highest rate of economic mobility and the largest and wealthiest middle class in the world, but that is no longer the case. Without land, property, or hope for economic gains, many freed Blacks and returning white soldiers turned to sharecropping and found themselves once again working side by side, dependent on wealthy landowners. Please reread the article and maybe it will all sink in? Greater socioeconomic mobility. Furthermore, it is sad and frustrating that most Americans don’t even realize any of this. Lower class whites here don’t particularly seem like rednecks. You must not have read any of the links I sent you, welfare is THE LARGEST item on the federal budget at over 1 TRILLION dollars… It’s a lot more than just “feeding the homeless”… Since you seem to be grossly out of touch with reality, to put that into perspective for you, that’s more than what 10 bill gates’ are worth… properly allocating that much money should be capable of feeding the whole worlds homeless population let alone the measly population of the US… I find it ironic that this article illustrates the point of using discrimination and segregation to divide and conquer the do animals deserve rights essay lower class, and people in the comment section are doing just that. Why on earth would you call her stupid and ignorant? Its a long, hard road ahead for our campaign, but I’m not going to quit until we are beaten, and even then, I hope that what Sanders has done in terms of his political revolution gets carried into House and Senate elections. Not a single Arab country ranks in the top 100 in the World Economic Forum’s Global Gender Gap Report, putting the region as a whole solidly at the planet’s rock bottom. If he DOES do it, then he will attract more than just po’ white folks from the South. To hell with you all. ” they would say “It’s not right and you shouldn’t be doing that anyway. That sounds like you’re describing Sanders, except maybe the part about major news channel cameras. Funny thing is, she still believes the “plantation owners were dividing and conquering” narrative from her college text books more than what the people standing right in front of her said. Which is worse? You will have many more to come…but just haven’t met them yet. I live in one of the poorest counties of the state. So a few Greedy people can profit. They seem to believe they have somehow earned these benefits and that they do not rely on the ‘government’ whereas minorities and others do not. Trump can do that, then more power to him. I was able to move to Vancouver with the help of friends. For my grandfather, owning a car was a point of pride, as he grew up poor. Increasing demand for indentured servants, many of whom were skilled laborers, soon bumped up against a dwindling supply, and the cost of white indentured servants rose sharply. Before that there were many other groups which wealthy conservatives used to distract and scare the masses, like less desirable white immigrants (not just the undocumented ones) such as the Jews, Italians, and Irish. Sorry for swearing. In 1986, Reagan said, “The most terrifying words in the English language are: I’m from the government and I’m here to help. But the way the government reports those statistics doesn’t show that. One truth I don’t think I’ve seen mentioned anywhere is that a lot of the so called ‘Trump’ supporters were raised believing that they should earn their own way, that nobody owed them anything and, if at the end of the day, their hard work gets them nothing but a little trailer and clunker car, at least they can sit in either one and be proud knowing they got it on their own rather than than having it or anything else handed to them. Also they provide zillions of references & footnotes, which you obviously would relish. Party leaders vowed to respect Tunisia’s 1956 Personal Status Code, which declared “the principle of equality between men and women” as citizens and banned polygamy. I now live in Portland and look back on that time as almost a different life, but I keenly remember the socio-economic stratification. And I feel that a good handful of you missed one of her biggest points! But in any case, they feel they can at least be self-reliant. They’ve always known this and it terrifies them. Based upon my experiences over the past seventy years, I can relate to so much of what this author is saying. That social revolution will come no matter what. I kept seeing the current political climate being tied into the language and culture during slavery in America…Your piece has given voice to my processing of our political reality of today. It’s a simple factual point, but important. He was a proud working man, the first generation to be able to provide so well for his family. Besides, that story about the adulteress in John is an interpolation. S. Benton County has been among the most historically conservative counties in Arkansas. Education is the key to get out of poverty – even if you have to take out loans, work part time jobs, take a decade to finish your degree, etc. You might want to read some American history before telling others who is deserving of calling themselves Americans. Nothing good ever comes out of negativity. In Libya, the first thing the head of the interim government, Mustafa Abdel Jalil, promised to do was to lift the late Libyan tyrant’s restrictions on polygamy. As far as her résumé’, some would argue she is the most intellectually qualified candidate since, well, her hubby. No one is asking for ‘free stuff’. There are plenty of examples of similar movements outside the relatively narrow history of the United States. Private nonprofit organizations have been picking up the slack left by inadequate funding in the federal budget. 5 billion in government contracts. This is a group of people who have almost effortlessly been manipulated by some pretty despicable people into voting against their own interests and aligning themselves with people who have nothing in common with them. He was lucky to have been able to save enough money from his factory job, along with my grandmother working as a secretary. I worked in the defense industry, twice. First – LBJ being a ‘greater ally’ than JFK is arguably subjective. A rural Iowan isn’t particularly different than any other variety of Iowan. I am a poor, uneducated, white woman. The government stopped keeping full unemployment data back in the 1980s. I was in the inner circle of one of these companies along with the CEO, COO, and other officers. That is much more useful and much less misleading than saying “the media. But when given genuine opportunities and the resources to act on those opportunities, most people won’t choose to remain poor. Thanks for the apology. The dem party is all about destruction! ” As a senator, LBJ filibustered a civil rights act and then went home to Texas to brag about it. And it’s chutzpah to say they were automatically wrong. Anyway, I’ll still vote Sanders, considering he seems quite honest. This means that any Mexican immigrants arriving in the U. She could have read a lot. S. OMG there are so many delusional morons in this country. Because of their support and the work of my parents, the education lifted that generation out of poverty. “This image of the lazy African-American woman who refuses to get a job and keeps having kids is pretty enduring. You did such as great job of talking about the history of the great racial divide between Blacks and poor whites but you seem to almost give Bernie a pass on this. I fully understand that I don’t have everything figured out. I’m not a socialist. This article is ironic. Two made plea agreements and testified for the government. You don’t seem to grasp the chauvinism implicit in your belief that social mobility is the solution to poverty, as if the jobs they spend their whole lives doing should just cease to exist. He watched news, but he wasn’t very critical or discerning. Hamartia can even mean something as simple as being mistaken, not implying any absolute moral and divine failure whatsoever. Very thought provoking piece, I just wish the title was different, something that wouldn’t immediately turn off most of those people chanting Trump, Trump, Trump. Bill Clinton was a man with a foot in both worlds, much like the political version of Sam Walton or Don Tyson. So wrong. But to the educated hard working tax payer, there is also a non racist appeal in curbing illegal immigration. And I said to myself, if they can stay so poor for so many generations, maybe this isn’t the kind of person we want to be electing to higher office. ” The same can probably be said to folks on both sides of the political spectrum. God has been redefined and restructured in every age. And the notion that Democrats only get their hands occasionally (when their caught) but all Republicans have dirty hands is completely biased and naive. I’m not a Democrat. S. He has been hobnobbing with the political establishment and economic elite his entire life, including with the likes of the Clintons. You write eloquently – I wish you success in life. Unemployment rates and recessions have been worse under Republican presidents, for a very long time. Still, African slaves were cheaper, and the supply was plentiful. ” Conservatives ask: What is wrong with “them? But that doesn’t mean that they don’t have things they take pride in. Christians use every weird scriptural passage to justify their hate, racism, homophobia and misogyny. The hatred of women goes deep in Egyptian society. I hate rhetoric. Don't waste your time and order our essay writing service today! ” In five short sentences, Atwater explained how Republican politicians could appeal to poor whites’ racism (conscious or unconscious) without using blatantly racist language. Two of them Trump supporters stalked their jobs, called and left death threats and some very sick voicemails all the while they were laughing about it in thier Trump Fb group. The article talks about Tyson Food’s CEO hiring illegal workers to save costs. But life sucks and it sucks worse for some than others. I am directing my attention to the people who largely disagree with me. One difference is maybe related to education. However it would be a mistake to describe any European country as “socialist” in the sense many in the US use it. I would capitalize “Asian,” “Hispanic,” or “Jewish,” but “white” is sort of a catch-all term that doesn’t indicate ethnicity. It’s similar to how many gay people don’t talk about their sexual identities and preferences. I suppose my point is that those that mostly agree with you on the main points, vote in a like-minded way, don’t always require a detailed dissenting opinion that basically causes a wider devide which does nothing but separate you from the other, rather than coming together for the betterment of us all. Maybe a nation gets just the pizza it has ordered. ” I would hear viscious class based rhetoric aimed at poor white people – particularly conservatives. So, if you really want to send and ‘eff you’ vote to the rich, you should support Sanders. Its divisive and has limited inclusive value. For example, I pointed out that wages have stagnated and that has been going on since 1974. ” Thank you. We are more than our headscarves and our hymens. My conservative parents taught me to value education, self-education most of all. This was all in my head, but in a city known for its liberalism, I once again felt I didn’t belong. I am ready to barf after wasting my time reading this poor me bull for a lot longer than I should have! A quarter of those parliamentary seats are now held by Salafis, who believe that mimicking the original ways of the Prophet Mohammed is an appropriate prescription for modern life. Yet while the Reagan administration congratulated themselves on the economic expansion, poor people were still struggling. This led to significant tension as my dad saw it as a betrayal. You do not site long lists of sources when you are doing an article for a newspaper. But that’s always been the problem with “conservatives”: You whine about lost freedoms, but in reality you only care about YOUR freedom to do the things that YOU want to do. But it is an accent associated with liberal snobs. “But they all seem to. Economy to be positive rather than negative. As opposed to that supposition , many experts on the relationship between the political parties and the functioning of the economy have concluded that the latter is very much a function of the difference between the economic policies of the two parties. My mom’s family has been part of the working poor for as far back as I can figure, based on genealogical research. It’s just not a good time for that kind of thing right now. And the media black out all lead to Israel. This is particularly a problem as our society becomes ideologically segregated and Americans become ever more trapped in media bubbles and echo chambers. They try to live off the land as much as possible. Many of these feelings have been inherited from the past, having been learned in childhood from parents and grandparents, authority figures and pundits. Had the revolutionary movement been held to a vote we would still be British. I don’t have a team I’m fighting for other than the team that is my own country. Personally, I’ve had it with the South and if they wanted to secede again I’d say bon voyage and there’s the damn door, don’t let it hit your big fat redneck ass on the way out. The actual political left in the US is a silenced majority. No one look it at it from above can know it, truly, because you simply do not live there. To me, the defining moment of his candidacy was when two young BLM activists took the microphone away from him, he stepped away in confusion and a few days later his platform was bristling with BLM talking points. It’s just that I live alone and have always managed to stay employed, even if I wasn’t always making much. The Trump phenomenon is really a throwback to the old-school American dream as opposed to the thin gruel of a compromise offered by the modern welfare state, where all the jobs disappear but you get a welfare check instead. Most of all, we are proud of our dedicated team, who has both the creativity and understanding of our clients' needs. Most liberals would be horrified if conservatives said to Muslims what liberals say to conservative Christians without hesitation. The whites, blacks and other minority American Citizens will be united against the corporate lobby should their wages be unlivable. Thank you. She made a connection. Sometimes my family was living a middle class lifestyle and at other times we were on the lower income end of the class scale. You see the world in terms of power. Protestors built a temporary encampment on the Mall in Washington, D. In 1924, Congress passed a law essentially halting all immigration – with Samuel Gompers, the George Washington of the American labor-union movement, leading the campaign to have it passed. I even saw a certain sadness in his eyes when he talked about my mom, as if he finally realized how petty all of those tensions that made their relationship dysfunctional were. (Cheating on his do homework faster wife, lying about it, then pretending nothing happened. There is a wide variety of views expressed here, representing different economic classes and political positions. A misfortune , to be sure, but not their fault? Unfortunately and mutual support needs to be reciprocated, otherwise it can not exist. All that Trump offers is talk. I’m also a single mother, who only has a high school diploma and is unable to work due to injuries and non-military PTSD. And then she shared it. Midwest has the highest rate of Northern European ancestry in the country and this shapes the culture here. Many slave owners in both the North and South were also political leaders. Even though few of them ever benefited from it. The data shows that poor whites, including in rural areas, have higher rates of welfare than blacks. I think many 24 year olds and younger people today could benefit from following me around for no pay. ” Now that’s a fact. Who is it that gains from open boarder policies? They likely hadn’t changed much, because they were hardly there to begin with. I know its not Dump. How could they not see that there were no WMD in Iraq – or at least no solid evidence of their existence? When facing national problems, liberals ask: What is wrong with “us? As a person from poor white roots, I struggle when I hear poor shaming poor and then turning around and kau tau to their oppressors. I know people temd to forget ua but Trump has a history of smearing hate and fear for money in court, tv, radio and newspapers against Natives. I am with you; I am 65 going on 66 , and am one more white poor mother fucker. You have no problem then with how the Iraq war (and how many other useless wars) made small groups of already rich like Haliburton more rich? You act like that article you sent me is the problem when it talks about 200 undocumented Polish workers brought in by a contracting by the name of Kaszycki & Sons (clearly polish), when Trump is talking about 12 million undocumented Mexicans living in the country, coming in at a rate of 700,000 a year.. The project will include community concerts, collaboration with Diné musicians, and a final performance showcasing the accomplishments of the students. Considering all of this, I’m not sure why you are shocked that I’m working class. The people remaining are disproportionately those who are older, retired, disabled, impoverished, in debt, etc—i. Someone here was gracious enough to offer to provide you with sources if you want them and asked you to sight what you felt wasn’t true. It’s a social condition in a society based on class hierarchy. The Klan didn’t only exist thousands of miles away from the Democratic states where liberals live. The perspective of this article is very well documented and written. He wasn’t highfalutin like the city slickers of California and New York. Most of the main issues of Trump, such as free trade, are also the main issues of Sanders. What is happening to white health in this country is unprecedented and seems to correlate with the rise of Trumpism- See Washington Post bi variate county-level correlations between Trump primary support and white mortality. The main product Trump has always sold is himself, and that is what his campaign is about. Thirty years ago I was just like you Mr, Steele, but I no longer feel the need to argue incessantly point-counterpoint every single fact and minute detail yada yada? It is very helpful for those of us who have a hard time articulating what we know. The Republican party has only dominated the South by disenfranchizing, demoralizing, suppressing, and generally shutting out most potential voters—by voter purges, few polling locations, long lines, etc. But he never became condescending snob. Many liberals in conservative areas purposely hide their political views, such that they might not realize there are more liberals around them than they know. This is a point of view I have never been able to understand. My mom raised me with working class values. Few people need welfare permanently. Don’t pretend to be stupid and clueless. I liked the article for its well researched data, but was saddened to see that it was just another whine-laden political rant in the end. It’s time that those who aren’t poor to begin to take this seriously. She instructs their son to go and get a doctor. Since crying isn’t an option, we swallow the sadness, and it sits and churns and gets spit back out as anger. S. Women are not to be seen or heard — even their voices are a temptation — so there they are in the Egyptian parliament, covered from head to toe in black and never uttering a word. -I would like to see the data you have to support this claim of Trump supporters. I agree completely with your comment. The same kids actually do not know the history of persecution against the poor of any race–certainly they were unfamiliar with the lynchings that occurred against the Asian and Irish communities at the time–and chant “racist bigot” when you mention anything that goes against their worldviews. They said they were doing what the company demanded when they went along with the hiring of illegal workers. But I’ve grown weary of this kind of agreeing to disagree over what amounts to basically political minutia. I say what we can do now, is to raise better people than us. I bet she’d never accept that part of Islam as a guide for her life. Reagan said that in the 70s. Other legal colored Americans of the country – or the CEO? Plantation owners kept skilled white servants, of course, often making them plantation managers and supervisors of slaves. I simply have been humbled by life. No one more ignorant. ” In the post war era, where money was flowing in hand over fist, sure socialism was popular. It leaned to one side, and the faint odor of death hung around the bathroom. The DemocRAT Party offers none of those! There was plenty of poverty in that part of my family for generations, probably going back to Europe, as at least one line of the family came from the violent borderlands of Alsace-Loraine. I simply hold my beliefs at arms length, not assuming my beliefs are right simply because they are my beliefs. Kennedy had visited Appalachia during the 1960 presidential campaign, and was shocked by what he saw — ”the hungry children, … the old people who cannot pay their doctors bills, the families forced to give up their farms. Gompers wanted to create labor shortages that would drive up wages and give unions more bargaining power. I spent some of my most formative years in the Deep South (the last 5 years of my public education), including what some consider the Buckle of the Bible Belt (where I worked at a Christian camp for several summers). Nor do they represent most other Americans. I’m tired of this needless hate between poor people of all backgrounds. I’ve lived in many places over my life. In Winchester, for example, even though we are getting an influx of Washington, D. “Republican politicians appealed to poor whites’ racism without using blatantly racist language. Explain to me how poor and disfranchised are to be blamed that the wealthy and powerful choose to poison them by refusing to fund replacing old infrastructure and by placing toxic waste sites in poor communities. So over the generations they stay stuck or lose ground. “I suppose my point is that those that mostly agree with you on the main points, vote in a like-minded way, don’t always require a detailed dissenting opinion that basically causes a wider devide which does nothing but separate you from the other, rather than coming together for the betterment of us all. Open borders don’t necessarily help the rich more than they help anyone else. If he can’t stand up to the bullies in his own party, how well could he stand up to the globalist Washington establishment? Watching the working class whites was like being on safari. There are simply more people with college degrees than there are jobs that require college degrees. Thank you so much for your story…it is amazingly thoughtful and educational at the same time! It doesn’t take much to see the difference when you have fewer than twenty class-mates, who’s parents still have jobs, and for that to create clear demarcation lines between who you can or cannot relate to. Tyrants oppress, beat, and torture all. Should a person working 40 hours have health care? But he also would literally give someone in need the shirt off his back. That was possibly the most bullsh*t article I have ever read! Donald Trump is getting endorsements from the likes of Charles Evers – try saying to him that he is voting for Trump against his own interests? The problem of ethnic conflict is a different issue. There was a time when being an Islamist was the most vulnerable political position in Egypt and Tunisia. Humans are social animals and we never operate outside of that larger social order. There has always been a strong tradition of education in the Midwest. The case could’ve been made without turning it into a political screed for one particular presidential candidate. You ought to be out here marching with every one of us every time we have a march. He knows this because he has lived it. They just don’t see all of these government benefits as “free stuff,” except when it goes to people that don’t look like them in which case it’s “socialism. And yet, regardless of how many shit jobs I try to work, I can’t crawl out of the hole I’m in. It was odd he even met and dated my mother (Hispanic) in the first place, but perhaps beauty got the better of him. Did you miss who dropped the ball on that?? That run the country. I currently do volunteer work to assist people on the low end of economic ladder in our society. Well said!! And it was white male bodies they needed. I agree that America doesn’t need another third party. Trump, Trump” because the Elite Left fell out of touch with the larger society, and in fact, largely defined itself through the escape of that larger society’s ‘provincialism’, but it would be no more gross than the oversimplifications Ivin indulges in at length. That’s another aspect that the author misses. ” “This becomes clear when one takes a step back from the tiny weird world of the U. He really isn’t that much older than Clinton, just a few years. He has regularly talked about that issue on the campaign. It’s not Bernie’s social revolution. More employment. Just another Religious Republican trying to tell the gays they can’t marry, or telling women then can’t have birth control. It was African slave labor which enabled the colony to actually take hold. My friends include a busdriver, baker, etc. It’s paid for by everyone else. Slave owners saw white servants living, working, socializing, and even having babies with African slaves. Peace Thank you for sharing your deeply insightful and personal story, Colton. ” By the time Bernie graduated from college, he was alone. Soros was a young teenager when WWII began. The party that runs on handouts for everyone? A globalist is someone who seeks to balance the interests of their own country with the interests of the rest of the world. I can’t believe we still have this level of ignorance with so much information available at our fingertips. Jonna….. During the Vietnam War, Trump was granted five draft deferments — the first four for education, and the last for medical reasons. Other that that, decent read. Would you mind if I quoted your second-to-last paragraph (with proper citation, of course) as the header to my FB share of this article? More gullible. You don’t have to believe in trickle-down economics to be skeptical of the good intentions of outrageous charlatans like Lyndon Johnson. Not just the poor who are on the government dole today. Hillary’s youthful political leanings have nothing whatsoever to do with her long-standing record as a committed Democrat. At least that was true at the time. And that currently there are 1000’s who are now missing and expected to be in fundamentalist camps. Many of us do read. Lee Atwater was an adviser to both Reagan and President George H. The author DOES come across as well-read. We have met the enemy and he is us. He speaks to poor whites but at the expense of talking about racial justice and unity. But it’s understandable. And this holds true for both sides–the “ethnic violence” crowd has no leg to stand on when referencing only the minority community either (for that matter, using the term minority loses its value when it only applies to skin pigment, but that’s another rant for another time). People like authoritative confidence. If we can’t face the real problems, then we can’t find solutions to them. I know first hand of the strategy to “divide and conquer” and to use racism and other cultural’religious values to manipulate and control the middle and Lower socio-economic classes. People are more likely to listen to you – and even agree with you – if you don’t sound like a raving fanatic. Political loopholes which motivated him to do it should ALSO be blamed. Reagan’s economic plan, dubbed “Reaganomics,” provided tax cuts that primarily benefitted the rich. It had a beauty parlor, a gas station, and a bar where locals came on Friday nights to shoot the shit over cheap drinks and country music. That is what economic mobility used to mean. All the bush Cruz kashic money is to keep the current power structure. As a lower class white woman, I am so incredibly sick of articles like this one that perpetuate the LIE that poor and working class whites overwhelmingly vote Republican, when it’s actually middle class whites who are far more likely to vote Republican. Instead, I just wish one person (Parent? Just a different group of illegal immigrants). The future generations growing up alongside each other, knowing other cultures and seeing how the same we are all at the end of the day, I believe that will be the base for that change. And yet, the government doesn’t limit SNAP purchases to foods that won’t slowly kill you. For the white underclass, it’s tempting to feel left out of this fight. Not sure whats so hard to understand, there are millions of poor whites. I also came came to the realization that Bernie Sanders is the best candidate for ninety percent of Americans. Last fall, when fielding female candidates, Egypt’s Salafi Nour Party ran a flower in place of each woman’s face. (The doctor was sued and eventually acquitted in March. He has also opposed increased military spending and done so for a very long time. Just like a family will fracture into dysfunction and entropy with everyone operating based on different sets of facts, the world’s 5,000,000,000 people have – and will continue to fall into chaos and entropy IN THE ABSENCE OF a set of facts upon which all men agree: such as, water is wet, gravity and death suck, and we all feel hunger, thirst, pain, lust, etc. These are also the sort of people who tend to be extremely controlling in relationships and more likely to physically or psychologically abuse women. This is a small college town surrounded by vast stretches of farmland. I’m a lone liberal in an almost entire extended family on both mother and father’s side of conservatives. It’s a lot easier to write off a group of people as being manipulated or delusional instead of listening to them about what’s at the heart of their frustrations and trying to solve those problems. The blacks left in rural areas were able to do so by isolating themselves in mostly black areas. This is a well-to-do hipster who was being poor “ironically. D. Until those with power and access decide that it’s beneficial to truly educate people, and make it possible to get an education without going into crushing debt, then the mutt people here in the heartland will keep on electing dangerous dimwits in cowboy boots. No offense, Im from Virginia (Where The Slaves Are From Literally) so I really don’t care about feelings. Most military officers are at the rank of O-5 at the twenty year mark, not O-7 (the lowest general officer rank). I never got a chance to gain insight into my father’s political views in his final days. Instead of wondering which billionaire will finally reach out a hand to raise us up, we should stop waiting and start acting. This isn’t political minutia. But am embarrassed by the crassness and ignorance of so many of my compatriots. Kennedy was assassinated not murdered! Soon, they began to pass laws that stipulated different treatment of white indentured servants, newly freed white men, and African slaves. My generation was the first generation in recent history that has on average done worse than the previous generation. It’s just as much a control mechanism as the use of fear. But what do I Know im just a poor motherfucker from a Slave State. That was back when unions were more powerful and had higher membership rates. I agree with her that many people on welfare do not benefit from it as much as some would assume, but I cannot accept that a large minority of welfare recipients don’t abuse the system. The people you met at an elite private college are not your research paper prices average person, not your average person on the political right or the political left. People who lack power like it when someone speaks out against those they perceive as powerful. But it isn’t against government largesse on principle. In what way do you think suggesting eugenics based on your own sense of superiority isn’t an act of self-righteous hostility? That establishment is out for itself and will continue to prey upon everything (resources, people, moral values) from which it can wring a penny. Trade and employment policies are made by those with the power, for those with the power. It takes talent and skill, and she very likely could have gotten those skills at a public college. There is so much right AND much more wrong with this article. About liberalism, I would note that polls show most Americans now hold positions on many major issues that have been considered ‘liberal’ for decades in mainstream politics. For classism based revolution such as what happened in France 300 years ago there must be first social unity. Theres no evidence that he had any idea of that, and to be honest, its not really his job to look into how that construction company does their business. Certainly the most scrutinized. And that the vast majority are military aged males who are not traveling with any spouse or child. In particular, the conflation of government programs allegedly designed to help the poor with the actual helping of the poor will lead to more than a few sprained eyeballs. I don’t think the blacks can be repressed again, but you never know. Yet many continue to vote for them instead of making the other choice – one where those that want and know how to grow the economy and jobs will raise all boats. Money couldn’t be frivolously spent by either of my families, and my dad’s reckless spending habits (he never considered money important, and would blow all of his spare income making him and his friends happy because that’s what mattered more to him – good times with good people) often earned him the scorn of his family. Trump doesn’t speak to the young to the same extent. Like you, I’ve thought a lot about ethnicity and race. I have one lol. This is absolutely the best article that I have read regarding the current political environment. According to the conservative canon, if you haven’t succeeded, it can only be because of your inferiority. It is possible. ” Meanwhile they grow in power and profit on the conflict which inevitably ensues. And what does gender, or for that matter, sex, have to do with the Arab Spring? (Alternatively, a very public reconciliation involving Bill crying, apologizing, and invoking Jesus would have worked too. Unfortunately, I’m pretty sure none of them will even consider clicking on it due to the title. They are taking more than they are giving. The negative comments are valuable as well as they illustrate your main points. If you think the wealth of the middle class is going to the needy you are ignoring practical mountains of data showing that as patently false. Let us not tout his achievements in social programs when his goal was to keep poor people (particularly blacks) under the government thumb and believing that the Democratic party actually cares for them. Funny that you want to change them now. There’s a certain pride in that that those who insist on ‘entitlements’ will never understand. But comparing an apple to an apple makes for a terrible talking point. I particularly don’t care that they both happen to be running as Democrats. I’ve always had respect for people like that. Capybaras ( Hydrochoerus hydrochaeris) live in social groups of 10 to 20 in the forests of Central and South America. You’ll allow me that choice, won’t you? Then there have been the nation-wide protests against police brutality. We stood in a room and the leader of the group read a list of statements. And nobody notices! You’re not trash, Jonna, but a National Treasure. We may have a peculiar history in terms of race, but we’re hardly unique in the grand scheme of things. A single health problem could put me into massive debt. It’s best not to generalize too much about groups of people. That was an editorial choice. From your belief that “a” degree is not a guarantee of employment – from the perspective of one who claims not to have one and is therefore starting from square one – I would assume you already have a worthless liberal arts degree. Education has become more costly and the value of it has become less, as even those coming out of college these days are struggling to find work. Class isn’t an objective reality but a socioeconomic position relative to other socioeconomic positions within a specific economic social order. It seems to be coming down to the buffoon or the equivocator, and I’m half inclined to write in Christopher Walken at this point, because yes, I’m frustrated, and I feel powerless to change anything, and I have no hope that there will ever be a regular person in office who understands what it’s like to struggle to pay rent, or to have to just suck it up because an uninsured and unemployed driver totaled one’s car, or to tolerate a barrage of racism and sexism because a certain candidate does it and that suddenly makes it okay. Bush, and chairman of the Republican National Committee from 1989 until his death two years later. My mother was a public school teacher and one uncle became a hospital technician. Break it down further — on TV, talk shows vs. Met the man who said those words while working as a bartender in the Ozark Mountains of northwest Arkansas. Some of us were born sons of a toiling god, with the full understanding that life was never meant to be easy and that it comes with more than enough opportunities for personal responsibility. I don’t buy into the concept of extreme wealth as “hard won” in many cases; nor do I buy into the idea that the wall is unbreakable. My suggestion is that to truly understand these voters, one may want to consider other, equally important political issues that these voters seem to care more about than the economy. I worked for my state’s welfare department for a year. I don’t see how, after reading this amazingly well written and thought out submission, anyone would think it was beneficial for us to attack one another and weaken ourselves through division. I have an extremely dark sense of humor. I say no, because those people have so little power. And the Clintons used their own Southern Strategy to make the Democratic party into Republican lite: welfare slashing, tough-on-crime, war hawk policies, etc. But I have at times in the past lived below the poverty line. When I arrived at an elite private college the casual animosity toward poor white people was shocking, but not entirely suprising. , those least capable of leaving and starting over somewhere else. I didn’t finish paying off my student loans (at 8+%) ’til my late forties. On the November day I was sexually assaulted on Mohamed Mahmoud Street near Tahrir Square, by at least four Egyptian riot police, I was first groped by a man in the square itself. Soon the college educated American’s job will be filled with an Indian, or he’ll be working for lower and lower Indian wages. When he describes himself as a socialist, he is using it in one of its earliest senses as a social reformer. It wasn’t as if there was anywhere he could have escaped to, as he was in Nazi-occupied territory. And what, pray tell, are “good intentions”? ” But what sort of personal responsibility is possible in the neocon environment? Whenever I’ve encountered very articulate people who identify as ‘poor,’ I’ve found that they often have a special understanding of ‘rich’ that doesn’t comport with my own. Writing in 2007, the Princeton political economist Larry Bartels 8 concluded that: They’re the same statistics we’ve judged previous presidents by. They have to rely on narratives, imagery, vague statements and promises to figure out who the “best” candidate is. Catholicism killed WAY MORE people than it EVER helped, and because they were some of the ORIGINAL BANKSTERS, are very reluctant to release their powerful influence in the EASIEST GIG in the known universe – that of telling lies for money, and scaring the FUCK out of cavemen unwilling to admit snakes don’t talk, but if they DO, he and nobody like him is listening. Sometimes they tried to escape together. SCLC leaders and the National Welfare Rights Organization lobbied Congress to introduce an “economic bill of rights” for all Americans. He wants to help get the economy back to where it creates opportunities for all Americans, such that they don’t need welfare. So yes, I’m concerned about Islamic immigration to America. That is a distraction from the real problems. Right wing economics means don’t tax the hell out of everyone, make it easier for businesses to thrive and get people to work so that welfare isn’t needed. There are more poor whites than poor blacks. It was a slow but effective process, and with the passing of a few generations, any bond that indentured servants shared with African slaves was permanently severed. Raj Chetty’s data (Stanford) shows that social mobility in America is quite low and has been low for some time. Resist cultural relativism and know that even in countries undergoing revolutions and uprisings, women will remain the cheapest bargaining chips. Conservatives are paternalistic with their support of a strong militarized police state and neocon state building. They aren’t that far from the bottom and they know it. I wondered. Anyway, there is nothing inevitable about elitism, as other countries have leaders who came from modest backgrounds and came to power from old fashioned populist support. A family in the middle quintile, with an average income of roughly $50,000, could continue its spending for … six days. Your father’s good forunte is no excuse to be a self-righteous arrogant asshole about it. Trump and H. Now most media is corporate media and has been bought up by a few mega-corporations, many of which also have ownership in other areas such as big oil and defense contract work. The homeless are not my enemy. I think want I could add has already been mentioned in the comments. ” Click To Tweet War will break out everywhere like hidden fire from the earth. Your experience is a Southern one…I grew up in the North and the bogeymen were a bit different (the Irish.. Read “Why Nations Fail” by by Daron Acemoglu and James A. It’s more a mix of blazing red flags, avoidance-for-self-preservation and pity. It’s the social revolutions of the American public. He got an education and was able to make a do animals deserve rights essay decent living. Like anywhere else, being working class isn’t all that different. It’s not a question of earning it, they see it as a direct result of their failure to support their family. It doesn’t matter if God exists, we don’t need him. I’ve been visiting them my entire life. Makes no difference to me, but you sure as heck won’t be getting my vote any time soon. “We the People of the United States” are committed to “promote the general Welfare”. Until or unless he makes that connection, his pleas will fall on deaf ears. By the end of his life he seemed just so sick of it all. I understand half-joking about something while others don’t catch the joke and wondering if I’m being serious. Now, I’m not saying I’m voting for Trump, but I understand his appeal. He doesn’t gain power by keeping people silent. Isn’t there a portion of Trump’s base that Sander’s “vision” should appeal to, and how does Sanders connect with that group? Instead of providing financial planning services or anything that could help families get out of poverty, the government cut whole communities monthly checks. S. G. And nothing happened. I worked for ten years as Director of a mental health center, dealing with psychological and social issues of people in the South. Why are things ‘just the way they are’ in America. Now both are labeled as unworkable ideas. Trump will never look out for the people only the common interests of the elite and himself. Until recently, money and fame were everything to him. I particularly appreciate you having represented the perspective of a working class white person. As long as we are busy fighting with each other. I suppose the mythical “Willie Lynch” plan has worked beyond anyone’s wildest expectations because it wasn’t the rich White landowners whose wielded the whip, rope, or gun that was used to oppress slaves. As you have acknowledged lobbying is a problem in the country, and very few high ranking Democrats and Republican alike have gotten their seats without monetary support from such sources. My mother and at least one of my uncles probably have learning disabilities, as I do. And blacks have been a consistent one for most of our history. Considering that most wealth is inherited and not earned, it’s obvious that most intergenerational wealth transferrals have little to do with what you describe. My father, being uneducated (barely finished high school), was unaware of the legal agreements ramifications. And you’re so poor you can’t send your children to school. “Among all adult whites,” however, “nearly 70 percent do not have bachelor’s degrees,” the definition of working class used by pundits. I personally went in as a southern liberal and came out four years later with even stronger liberal views reinforced by my experience. Why? What chance do they have living from paycheck to paycheck, praying there will be no layoffs at J. ” In his eyes, Trump is a self-made entrepreneur who refuses to acknowledge the millions of dollars of family, public, and private assistance that helped him realize his gilt, mirrored glass, and pink marble American dream. I think this is why Andrew Jackson is maligned today, as some own who pulled the blinders of this con, and bread egalitarianism that lead to an explosion in abolition and poor all over realizing they could take power, and thus leading minorities and women to the same conclusion. Just wow. All manner of things are used to divide the electorate. Native Americans are not my enemy. It is very different being a poor black from being a poor white. When wages are forced up by government fiat, the usual response from employers (even though many try to hang onto their staff) is to cut extra costs where they can, for example enforcing break times that they were previously lenient about, asking workers to do more than they did before, not replacing staff as they leave, and cutting overtime except when absolutely necessary. But it isn’t a lack of comprehension. “The thing is, the problem with the welfare system is not that people abuse it, it’s that people become reliant on it. Just please be specific. The people need to learn and wake up and look at our past history and how it is the same in many ways as the present and will not change unless the people come together like Bernie says and other educated intellectuals rich or poor, past and present. Fewer social prolems. I never made such a conflation. It is fair to say that, in general, Nixon and LBJ perceived the civil rights movement as a platform for demagogues who were mostly not Black and were both more cynical and less idealistic than themselves. Yet the class divisions remain, sans the race element. Because Bernie has been in politics longer means he’s more qualified to be president? We are all sides of the same coin, a coin that has been held in the pocket of the elite class since the first settlers arrived in the American colonies. They were for the most part criminals given a choice between the gallows and deportation, the original Eurotrash. Two shining examples of the idiocy produced by visceral thinking are primary leaders D. Most of my life has been spent here in the Midwest, specifically Iowa. I’ve had only rudimentary economics taught to me but I know that trickle down doesn’t work. One of the myths put around by the “raise minimum wage” groups is that the increased minimum wage is paid for by the employer. Executive mansions line the lakefronts and golf courses. The point is, no movement involving the subjugation of the poor can call itself credible unless it points out the hurts caused to ALL of those historically involved. I agree that Trump is playing up the message of xenophobia, but I don’t believe that that’s the core reason people are supporting him. LBJ’s welfare model had the disastrous unintended consequence of destroying the traditional family structure of poor families. Likewise, just like the people who are leading the fight against ISIS are Muslims, the people standing up to the actual Klan are the ones described in this article, but neither gets any credit for it from people thousands of miles away who have no idea what is going on. Let the West Coast go on to be one of the worlds’ great countries, let middle america and rural Southern America keep shooting itself in its own foot trying to pretend its moral when in reality it’s anything but. 1 billion. My education turned out to be useless when hiring freezes keep me out of things I’m qualified for, and having attended college makes me “overqualified” for supermarket stocking and flipping burgers. But it’s just as true that welfare and such are a tool of not only the left but also the right, who prefer to pay blood money to the hardcore unemployed rather than work towards equality of opportunity. But both are on the ropes like some old pug boxer taking the facial cuts and popping eye capillaries with no referee to come in and stop the carnage. Why is his stating an inconvenient truth a reason to not support him? He was arguing that whites don’t understand poor black communities. ” Donald Trump sells himself as a scrappy, self-made man whose vision, tenacity, and business savvy alone have made him one of the world’s most famous billionaires, but Trump is not self-made by any measure. Important piece, well-written. It’s not like in the past where anyone willing to work could find work. Our main reason to support Trump is the fact that 100,000’s of unvented Muslims are being let into this country. Take his retirement plan and compare it to a similar annuity. That is all the elite oppressors need from us to continue what they’re doing. Parents were silenced. The Muslim Brotherhood, with almost half the total seats in our new revolutionary parliament, does not believe women (or Christians for that matter) can be president. ” -Bold words for someone who cites to zero data and has made several assumptions while not responding to any of the points raised in the initial post, or the article it was based on. While I think this article makes many good points about how powerful people put on their costumes and act in order to sway the powerless into voting for them in order to gain even more power and influence, I think we may have made an assumption that makes this analysis fatally flawed. It takes money to move and to get further education or training. Ever if some may disagree i think that’s better than the emptyness. There’s certainly a middle ground; but we won’t find it while the affluent and corporations control the majority of our political machine. My speech pattern wasn’t formed by higher education or a silver spoon in my mouth; it was simply a matter of accent. Their eyes focused on the floor, their hands, or something incredibly interesting on the ceiling. Good points. You can not expect poor whites to support black interests, if they are in turn blatantly discriminated against and called racial slurs, to add insult to injury. Those were my neighbors and friends and (to a lesser extent) me, and the stereotypes did not at all reflect the relatively apolitical attitudes of the majority, or the demeanors of even the most conservative leaning. The only fitting response, so far as the central conceit of this article goes, is *No*, you *don’t* “know” why poor whites “chant”, “Trump, Trump, Trump”. I just don’t want to. ” Poor whites have higher rates of welfare than do poor blacks. Bernie Sanders is a millionaire. His complaints about free trade agreements are similar to that of what Trump says. ” Bill Clinton wasn’t president in 1988, Bush One was. He’s not tricking people into being angry and going crazy for him – they were already angry, and he’s figured out how to capitalize on that anger for his own gain. If you have hard information on how “We the People” interpret that commitment, I for one would be very interested in hearing it Bernie Sanders turned out to be right on many foreign issues, from the Iraq War to the Panama Free Trade Agreement, and it goes back to his being critical of neoliberalism and neoconservatism decades ago long before they were shown to be such failures. It’s why the younger generation are increasingly moving to the political left. Just because I live in a middle class town, it doesn’t do me any good. I know that having a strong middle class with disposable income will boost the economy: when more people spend money, more profit is made. Yes that was it. Similarly, my factory-working grandfather was relatively wealthy compared to his own father. It was a comfortable life but money was never spent unless on something needed. Better schools. His positions stand in sharp contrast to the rest of the Presidential field, all of whom are globalists. Almost everyone of all races wants the respect of supporting themselves and their families. My ancestry is a bit different than yours, but fairly similar in some ways. Are Indians wrong for wanting that? And if one doesn’t get one of those jobs, it is hard to pay off one’s college debt. He isn’t even as far left as was FDR. And that won’t do anything to help any of us, because it’ll just burn the country down. By creating this common enemy among rich and poor alike, the wealthy elite sent a clear message: fight with us against abolitionists and you will remain safe. These people where considered a threat not to a poor white man who disliked people of color or a terrorist. “It could be that most Americans support a strong welfare state, low inequality, more opportunities for more people, etc for altruistic reasons because they want a better world for everyone, not just themselves. The implication is that we should be aiming for God or a spiritual ideal. I’m sure even most wealthier people understand these distinctions. Sadly, people think ignorance is bliss and they’ll rather not face themselves. ” And I said, “You are put in the position of supporting your oppressor, because, through prejudice and blindness, you fail to see that the same forces that oppress Negroes in American society oppress poor white people. If something or someone makes us uncomfortable, we simply avert our eyes and create an invisible barrier. I am still poor and White, but I respect character and values more than, as the liberals and people commenting on here say, “voting against my interests”! Their problem is not that they don’t make enough money, their problem is they don’t know enough to produce anything of value. From your belief that “a” degree is not a guarantee of employment – from the perspective of one who claims not to have one and is therefore starting from square one – I would assume you already have a worthless liberal arts degree. Thank you for this well weighted and carefully developed essay. Most people on welfare are working as well. I’m not one for black helicopters and conspiracy theories. He sold what he could, made his peace with me (I didn’t get a long with him very well most of my life, he used to hit my mother and treat me harshly as well), and moved to Florida where my uncles mortgage business was on the rebound. Still, it cost a fair amount for someone who was working class. The greatest irony is that one hears your kind of opinion most strongly from those living in Republican states. There is another set of data that I want to offer you in addition to the incredible Martin Gilens data. Are offset by those returning home, due to a number of factors. They had deep values and morals and didn’t worship an idea of being rich unless they worked hard and made it on their own! The only limits that have yet been discovered are the laws of physics. ” I’m a progressive. Recent Pew data shows that a large percentage of liberals state having guns in their homes. Take the baby of the richest parents in the world and leave that baby alone in the wilderness, and guess what… that baby would not grow up to be rich. To understand this dynamic, to see through the eyes of poor and working class whites as they chant, “Trump, Trump, Trump,” let’s look back at a few unsavory slices of America’s capitalist pie. I qualified for less than $200 a month through the SNAP food stamp program. A perfect illustration of “shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves in three generations. Look into the racial makeup of his imported work force in Florida. I know many on the right don’t like people who have immigrated illegally to the US (or anywhere really…go to Aussie web forums and they bitch about the same stuff.. He lived in a house in Gulf Breeze, FL, that was bought and paid for by my uncle (also an airline pilot on the side). I felt the reference to Bill Clinton in 94 read as a tag on – it certainly jumped out at me that the only Democrat raised in the piece in a derogatory way was he, so it was no surprise that the piece ended as an endorsement for Sanders – which would be fair enough if she hadn’t buried the lead! The Italians…the Jews…whatever). Thank you so much for writing this, Jonna! And if Trump does somehow – you have grounds for actual political revolution with classism as its main platform. S. He hasn’t spent his entire adult life fighting for these kinds of issues. Excuse me Kelly, but are you kidding? It gives it credibility. That is a successful political record, unless you prefer military imperialism and plutocratic corporatism. ” (use your best Mr. Johnson. What happened? Even most NRA members support stronger gun regulation. Augustine never stated it as specifically being an expression of Jesus’ teachings. Humanity is facing endless problems. There were laws that protected and gave rights to poor whites. I would attribute it to have the same value as common sense by Thomas Paine. There is a dark history to the West Coast. I would capitalize “Asian,” “Hispanic,” or “Jewish,” but “white” is sort of a catch-all term that doesn’t indicate ethnicity. There is good data in the article to support the claim that elites have pitted the poorer classes against one another for their own gain. Public polling shows that, on many major issues, the American public is way to the left of the political elite of both parties. That might relate to why my parents instilled in me such a strong love of learning. For God’s sake, look in the mirror! The most came from Honduras, at 18,244, followed by Guatemala with 17,057 and El Salvador at 16,404. 6 percent. Best one yet on the Internet. Voters for the other GOP candidates have even higher incomes. I just have known enough people that fit the description that I have sympathy. As an aside, I do not believe that rich people are happier and poor people are more maligned. YOu have no problem with 747 loads of a billion dollars gone missing? Thanks again. Your either a troll, a sociopath, or simply an asshole. I find that sad. He never said Ban all Muslims that is false.. They will fight the truth even at the cost of their livelihood. I dare you to care about others, kindness is the biggest weapon of all. Likewise, Bernie heavily criticized the Violent Crime bill passed under President Clinton, even though he voted for it because his own constituents demanded he vote for it because of the Violence Against Women provision that helped women’s groups protect women from domestic violence. The “reformer’s” answer to the revolutions popping up across the region was to numb his people with still more government handouts — especially for the Salafi zealots from whom the Saudi royal family inhales legitimacy. Hires with degrees in criminal justice, civil engineering, computer science or accountancy are always in high demand. We are human and prone to emotion. And creating a lot of smoke is what republicans do best. I only make slightly above 20 thousand dollars a year and I don’t have a college degree, but of course I have no wife or kids and my job does offer good benefits. It surely hasn’t ended their litany of problems, but it symbolizes freedom — and nowhere does such symbolism resonate more than in Saudi Arabia, where child marriage is also practiced and women are perpetually minors regardless of their age or education. No class of people with less honor. In 1981, while working in Reagan’s White House, Atwater gave an interview to Alexander Lamis, a political scientist at Case Western Reserve University. We all deserve better, need better, want better, yet even in these comments we are separating each other in to group’s when the only “group” that matters is our shared country. ” And then we got down one day to the point — that was the second or third day — to talk about where they lived, and how much they were earning. He has found work, but mostly temporary. While BDSteele has attempted to enlighten you with his comments, I think the fundamental problem here is a lack of understanding of what paternalism is: “the policy or practice on the part of people in positions of authority of restricting the freedom and responsibilities of those subordinate to them in the subordinates’ supposed best interest. Personally, I’ve had it with the South and if they wanted to secede again I’d say bon voyage and there’s the damn door, don’t let it hit your big fat redneck ass on the way out. I was born in 1975 and so there isn’t a single year in my life that wages weren’t stagnating. Population as a whole — the demographic threat, in other words, will soon take care of itself. Still, his criticisms of the so-called liberal class is important, just as important as his criticisms of many of the people living in his home state. I wasn’t kicking back playing video games on a big screen TV. Most poor whites don’t know about any of this. It goes far beyond a few missteps, as anyone knows who has looked at her political record and its consequences. There were also wealthy plantation owners with slaves and indentured servants, and I fairly certain my Great, Great Grandmother was the latter based primarily on their Marriage Bond issued in 1796. If she had been more transparent from the start of the piece I would just love it – but the buried agenda put me off Still – what a great theory – everyone should read! Then they just had to convince other conservative voters to hold their nose and vote for them, just like the mainstream Republicans in the 60’s, 70’s and 80’s did to them. You may not be “traditionally” or “formally” educated, but this is the most educated thing I have read in a long time. This article wonders how it is that these poor white voters are so ardently against their own interests and vote for wealthy, powerful candidates. Trump has rent the veil behind which the establishment plays its game. Sanders is probably more well liked by Republicans in Washington than Cruz and Trump combined. The arguments you present in this article form the clearest explanation of the roots of the racial and class divisions facing the US that I have ever read. They blindly blame Muslims for the deaths, maimings, brain injuries, and PTSD of their family members rather than being able to critically assess US war policy. California is the twin of Texas. You may never be a Rockefeller, but you know – I wouldn’t want to be them anyway. The reason for this is most people holding liberal views don’t necessarily identify as liberals. He is a standard moderate liberal and only seems radical because the political spectrum has shifted so far right. There stunted subhuman minds are mesmerized by cheap alcohol, Lotto fever, NASCAR and the asinine superstitions of their foot-washin’ faith. He developed a deep respect for their everyday struggle because he knew it was the same as his. I’m one of those people. , employment rates are high) poor whites like any other poor person will gladly take a handout and a help up. You work some job for a basic hourly wage and then you go home. Between 1990 and 2012 there has been a steady increase in white death rates among people with a high school education or less. But it doesn’t make me feel any better knowing that others struggle even more than I do. Where she and I agree is that the Republican Party, since the civil rights era, has made a point of going after the poor, and yes, uneducated white population pretty much everywhere. He said a temporary Ban in order to create a better system to ensure safety.. Wal-Mart, Mcdonalds, and every other employer gets to keep doing business the way they like! Maybe it’s your poor white trash mentality showing, Chief. The only way you could tell who was actually homeless and why that was the case was by talking to them as normal people, something few people ever do, as obviously you haven’t done. There is no evidence even that the accusations against this woman were true or that Jesus believed they were true, as he stated no opinion on the matter. I only make about $20,000 a year. The Democratic party has promised the poor (and others) fruits that it has never actually delivered – prosperity. Still, a working class Navajo has a different culture and lifestyle than a working class rural Iowan, a working class factory-working Hoosier, a working class inner city black, or a working class migrant worker. I’m not on team Democrat. The difference is that Bernie is more forthright by just naming the 1% directly in domestic issues at least, that’s admirable no doubt, while Trump does it in a sly, dumb rhetorical speeches as he gets the republicans themselves to agree with him on near socialized medicare (“leave no man dying in the streets” “the banks are not good people”). These camps are off limits to all law inforcement. Maybe it’s because of the plutocratic vision of trickle-up ‘prosperity’ that most poor whites don’t support right-wing economics. The government doesn’t support education about healthy diet, or programs that seek to make healthy food more accessible. Yes, I am extremely lucky that I have friends who helped me out of a bad situation. The thing is, the problem with the welfare system is not that people abuse it, it’s that people become reliant on it. He could take even stronger positions, but in terms of actually doing something about these issues he has done far more than Trump. Don’t be simpleminded. ” Donald J. It was nobody’s business but theirs and how dare the Republicans—most of whom had mistresses themselves—drag a married couple’s dirty laundry into public view! Yet the message to the white underclass was clear: your tax dollars are being squandered on undeserving people looking for a free ride. Work harder. Overthrowing Syria’s leader is a plot for Israel if you read Clinton’s emails. Political system of representative democracy does not represent a good number of the people ostensibly being represented. It was an interesting read until 80% into the article when it just became a tirade against the 1%, rich elites and a rallying cry for socialism and Bernie Sanders. I was about to share this article on Facebook, but have been struggling to adequately summarize the totality of the message and to do so in a manner that is also succinct enough to encourage as many people as possible to read it. That came long before the 2008 recession. Some people are so determined that someone else is responsible for their care and feeding, that they are blind to the opportunities that come their way. It’s not their problem and they don’t care. More than 970,000 veteran disability claims have been registered with the Veterans Administration. He used to call Mexicans in Pueblo, CO (where I grew up) “wetbacks” who were lazy and good-for-nothings. You obviously need to get out more and meet more of your fellow Americans, most of whom don’t have a college education. “The whites, blacks and other minority American Citizens will be united against the corporate lobby should their wages be unlivable. Obese curler wearing women standing unashamed in orange bikinis two sizes too small, sloping boobs hung over caesarean scars. I flatly don’t believe your description of your grandfather. Imagine how bad it is for those already poor. Sanders is stronger than Trump on the issues you claim to be the reasons for your support of Trump. And to celebrate Democratic Socialism?? It always seems weird to me when people let ideas trump reality. We often hear how the Middle East’s failing economies have left many men unable to marry, and some even use that to explain rising levels of sexual harassment on the streets. Also, keep in mind that it was the West Coast that gave us Ronald Reagan, Richard Nixon, the Southern Strategy, and such. The rural, struggling class gets a disproportionate part of government largesse. One example is Charles Murray who seems to think that poor whites do animals deserve rights essay are inherently inferior and that there isn’t much to be done about it. When a person gains knowledge they are no longer ignorant they become aware. It’s scary being poor, worrying that one parking ticket would mean I couldn’t buy groceries, or deciding whether I should see a dentist about a toothache or pay my trailer park fee. Even a poor person has wealth, even if it is only a few hundred dollars in their bank account. Other war profiteers include Agility ($7. When a poor person works to get out of the hole there is money available to them to continue education past grade 12. It was a one-street town in Benton County. Why has unemployment increased and then lasted longer, and why have recessions occurred so much more frequently and then lasted longer, during Republican administrations than during Democratic ones? That evaporated when the Democratic party became the representatives of primarily Gentry Liberals and African Americans. Research has found abuses of government programs is lower than is found in the private sector. Consequently they have greater financial pressure, and are effectively worse off. Also, I was a little disappointed that this article didn’t mention the racist and classist policies of the Clinton Administration (for example, incarcerating millions of black men under “tough-on-crime” legislation or NAFTA). History; not the one you read in the class rooms of modern day Schools. Nearly everybody at Royal Lunch feels socially inferior. That will ensure a better future for all mankind not just Americans. While we are eager to expose assaults by the regime, when we’re violated by our fellow civilians we immediately assume they’re agents of the regime or thugs because we don’t want to taint the revolution. That said I certainly wish more people would question why did this get wrote? I’m not a dogmatic ideologue and my ideological views are rather mixed, as I’ve borrowed ideas and values from many sources—from people I know, places I’ve lived, and things I’ve read (and I do read widely). He just wants “Presidential Candidate” on his resume. In rural areas, people have traded kitchen gardens for free potato chips and soda (they’re cheaper than vegetables – I get it). So the government and ‘hippies’ were blamed for hampering the timber industry. Right and looks at the electorate as a whole. A wage earner’s only asset is his willingness to give a day’s work for a day’s pay, the price of which he does not determine. While Nixon was deploying his Southern Strategy, a Coastal Elitist Left was emerging as a contemptuous adversarial culture, hostile to the resistance of the masses to its self-perceived progressive goodness. That seems like a fairly good result for money invested. I think it was more about the narrative of the right vs. The paradigmatic example of this genre is Thomals Frank’s “What’s the Matter With Kansas? And this, too, benefits affluent leftists who live in Blue states and prefer to propose impractical solutions for complex social problems from which they isolate themselves. More rich people per capita. I’d be a liar if I said *none* of it was deserved, and a bigger liar if I said I never engaged in invective myself, but the degree to which liberal argument (perhaps out of frustration) had devolved into: “you’re stupid white trash and all conservatives are evil” was disconcerting and disturbing and not what I’d signed up for as a “liberal. You don’t have to have a higher degree or necessarily a silver tongue to be genuine and compassionate. Whether that holds true or not I am not sure. According to Republican economic mythology, human beings are economic competitors; the marketplace is the new Olympia where “economic man” cavorts; the almighty market is rational and rewards efficiency, thrift, and hard work; and free competition “rationally” selects the more worthy competitor, and thus the wealthy are deserving of their elite status. Wages have stagnated for most workers and buying power has dropped, at the same time that costs of housing and education have increased. I’m far from being a comfortable middle class white liberal. I was struggling to survive until I could find work. The younger generations, including poor whites, are becoming increasingly liberal. Clumsy because it’s as if I’m reading something that was written and then re-written to serve a slightly different purpose. Paine was of the mind that the living generation should take care of their own problems, instead of foisting them onto future generations. No one wants to hire an older guy, no matter education. Greater ease in starting new businesses. Those factors included the weakened U. Donald took over The Trump Organization in 1974 and restyled the company in his image — a special blend of ego, flamboyance, and rabid ambition. I don’t like it that they have violated our laws and bypassed the legal channels (my immigrant friends from Canada and AU loathe them even more than the most rabid Trump supporter and the Mexicans who are here legally don’t like associating with them, but that may be a class thing). I have travelled in Islamic Africa and can tell you quite a bit about it. Perhaps due to the lack of well-honed critical thinking skills, white working class frustration has identified Undocumented immigrants, Muslims and blacks as their enemies and thus are looking to Trump as their spokesperson rather than Bernie despite Bernie’s offer of clear and relevant policy solutions. To look at the whole person, rather than what you think the person should care about. Vegetable gardens everywhere. Nor in your father. Job market at the time and a rise in deportations, as well as decreasing birth rates in Mexico that led fewer people to cross the border in the first place. I’ve seen the contrasts and sometimes conflicts between regions and populations. – get an education. We’re falling now…… just hope we can pull out of it before it’s too late. S. I bought my trailer for $1000, and it looked just like you would imagine a trailer that cost $1000 would look. Maybe we should all try to be more understanding and sympathetic to those who are different from us and not assume we have others figured out. A January 2016 survey by the Rand Corporation reported that Republican primary voters are 86. We know. He is quoted in a New Yorker article as saying, “I do know what it’s like when the electric company shuts off the electricity and the phone company shuts off the phone — all that stuff. I can see however, you are one of those people that will argue the point forever with pages of commentary and if I were younger and more energetic I’d argue those points. Don’t forget those “rich people”are the people who contribute millions of dollars to the Arts, Museums, Universities, etc that “poor” people get to enjoy as well as every other person. Poverty means different things depending where one lives. But KKK activities, sundown towns, etc led to the stealing of land from so many blacks. He actually tried to understand the larger conditions that have created the world we live in. You don’t even need to look to the third world. He wrote, “The greatest threat to the American Dream is the idea that dreamers need close government scrutiny and control. The Carlyle Group was named after the luxury hotel where founding members first met in 1987 to discuss the creation of a multinational private equity corporation. If you like arguments for more and better jobs, Sanders is your man. Understand that whoever deemed it as such was never a woman. Democrats haven’t been particularly liberal in a long time. Like you, I also have a cynical side. I was one of the lucky ones who through luck, hard work, GI Bill funded education, and willingness to relocate found my way out. I was able to obtain a Masters as well, and with luck and many office hours, I earned enough and invested savings that allowed me to comfortably retire at age 40. She could be (like me), wrapped in student loan debt, because an education is one of the few things no one can take from you. Which is ludicrous so many issues should be so easy. It doesn’t even get included in all translations, considering its uncertain origins. From a business perspective, he’s trying to cut out the middle man — the politicians who have become puppets of the wealthy elite. That isn’t the world we presently live in. But if you don’t share these views, that is problematic. For you to feel the way you do I believe this article offended you. It’s basically their trademark – after all, what’s a fundamental difference between liberals and conservatives? And there was no governmental oversight. But after the war, ex-slaves were left to linger and die in a world created by those in the North who no longer cared and those in the South who now resented their existence. The region is also about 94% white. More importantly the premise that forms the basis of the conclusion (Bernie is more economically like the majority he therefore must care about us) was refuted by Sanders himself. This is partly why California is tanking economically. Larger and wealthier middle classes. Is it any wonder the Gallup Poll tells us that 48 percent of Americans believe that God spit on his beefy paws and made the universe in seven days? It has become acceptable to make fun of a certain class of white Southerner. Even though he claims to be a libertarian, he has supported a basic income to take care of these poor whites who can’t help themselves. ” The point is you don’t agree with me on the main points. It doesn’t mean flipping burgers until you go to college. , inconvenient polling locations and long lines in poor areas). And then, in response to my criticisms, defend your own position. ” Homeless people aren’t poor. But in the new neocon environment, that wage does not support savings. It isn’t the case homeless people are being kept down by The Man or something, they just don’t want to participate in mainstream society. Very good article but it falls apart at the end when you bring up Bernie Sanders. I served drinks in the middle of the afternoon to people described as America’s “ white underclass” — in other words, people just like me. It’s not out of principle or anything. He depended on both government and private assistance, too, including tax abatements, financial support from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), investors, and, during the company’s 1990 massive financial troubles, a bailout pact involving seventy banks. ‘Rich’ is only partly about money. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Their unwashed, uncomprehending children with cavity peppered chartreuse colored teeth. Anyway, you must not be from America, bc the “welfare” system was essentially dismantled in ’96 when Republicans shut down the govt and Clinton took the opportunity to eat young twat, get blown, end welfare, and begin the for-profit jail system by incarcerating millions of black men – gettin that good ole Jim Crow shit started all over again. They know that if we come together, we will have the numbers on our side. I’m just a plain liberal. Even for older folk, times are tough. S. The intent of that propaganda was to seize power. Sanders is only socialist in the old sense of the word as a social reformer, although more accurately he is what is known as a social democrat. Even for my parents’ generation, the economy was booming and there were a lot of opportunities. Without speaking, we were to cross to the other side if the statement applied to us or stay in our place if it didn’t. Jesus doesn’t make clear what ‘mark’ specifically is being missed, allowing for diverse interpretations. But the racism can only ever be combated after it is correctly identified and determined. I think it’s the older generations that don’t realize what is going on and what needs to be done. Even between whites, the class divide has included race. Reaganomics actually began under the Carter administration. None at all. Hillary says she’ll be more like Obama; that’s not what we need. The African slaves imported to the US were not Muslim, because they were sold by Muslims, and while Islam forbids Muslims to make war upon each other, slavery and sale of captives are explicitly permitted. Knowing the data, this refers to the fact that blacks experience higher rates than whites of severe poverty, multi-generational poverty, economic segregation, ghettoization, and legacies of redlining, racist housing loan practices, etc. I like to think that because he understood this concept of selfless giving, of helping all of those people who were down on their luck (including the homeless man), then he could understand the concept of why we need an economic and political system that works for us all. “American society has made it perfectly clear: if you are poor, it’s your own damn fault. And the working poor have even less of a chance. Ariel and Leerone are returning to the reservation for a second summer, using the Arts Leadership Grant to expand a program that began in 2016. It’s not as if rural Iowans look or talk differently. ” Gustafson’s inclusion of inequality is important, because inequalities in both income and wealth distribution would soon begin a steep climb. The South is a complex place. Consider this for a moment; What if we actually make it difficult and highly illegal for companies to get away with such a practice and not just a slap on the wrist? Poor or rich, we all hate our women. “Didn’t they know that, from 1988 to 1990, Bill Clinton gave Tyson Foods $7. That the poor white has been put into this position, where through blindness and prejudice, he is forced to support his oppressors. America was close to being a Communist welfare state, and people had better start taking some personal responsibility, they thundered. Why has Bernie not shared with the people of these areas his views on how he will help them work again, and share what you have written, why are politicians afraid to share this information. The premise that Trump is wealthy and therefore is going to be like a slave master and not care about others is a false equivalency. It’s not that I’ve never heard a liberal ridicule poor whites. That was when I was mostly working as a janitor, which I did for several years. Even the public schools in Finland with high teacher unionization rates and high immigrant students do better than US schools. Forgive me if I’m underwhelmed. These new laws gave poor whites another elevation in status over their Black peers. His funeral procession passed through Resurrection City. None of the Republican candidates are suitable. Another fact. I guess I have to remember when pointing at someone that there are three fingers pointing back at me. The “poor whites” may not be so dumb and misplaced in their beliefs as the author wants them to be; and that is where her argument for Bernie falls flat and calling for a classism based political revolution is not going to happen in today’s USA where there is little social cohesiveness among people. Democrats absolutely do bait race by not denouncing the follies in baseless and violent groups such as BLM. Realizing it was a futile battle, he abandoned it all and walked away. With the potential election of Abraham Lincoln, however, the upper class began to worry they would lose their most valuable commodity: slave labor. Are you sure that Johnson filibustered the 1957 Civil Rights Act? On both sides of the Mason-Dixon line, wealthy elites were allowed to pay other men to take their place on the bloody battlefields. As it always has been. I have poor whites in my family as well. But you are free to dismiss all those facts out of hand because I don’t offer a citation by some libarts lecturer who has no firsthand knowledge either. Neither Reagan nor Congress was willing to touch Social Security, Medicare, or Medicaid; they were too popular among the middle class. As a Jew, he was being held in secret by a guy who was a Nazi. I’ve never been on welfare myself. Liberalism is a lot more common than is obvious. They want to be free of endless prejudices and oppression. First, insofar as it’s true, factors such as economic selection of certain classes of immigrants and cohesive families are strong negative indicators for violence. Interestingly, there is a strong overlap in maps of percentage of Catholics and rates of union membership. I have no hard feelings toward you. But he has always opposed pointless wars, especially wars of aggression, from Vietnam War to Iraq War. People have to be desperately poor before welfare kicks in. My father’s cousin during middle age went back to college to get an engineering degree. I’m not an ideological purist. It was actually relatively diverse for its small size, but it was surrounded by mostly white middle-class neighborhoods. His campaign won’t negatively effect any of his businesses in the long term. I never claimed my ideology is more inherently moral. But female university professors and students have complained since then of assaults and intimidation by Islamists for not wearing hijabs, while many women’s rights activists wonder how talk of Islamic law will affect the actual law they will live under in post-revolution Tunisia. There are many ways to try to make sense of it all. By early 2013, private defense contractors had collectively earned more than $138 billion. For you to say, “Someone like Clinton can’t claim to have done much that is principled in her entire life,” is just a ridiculously simplified dig and just flat wrong. Welfare is viewed as sort of like economic heroin. Throughout most of recorded history, power came from the capacity to command scarce resources, typically via either money or force, and money was itself based upon a scarce resource (no , not paper). One necessary next step is that there might be two parties, but there is only one establishment. They want the cheap labor. If you think conservatives aren’t paternalistic, you haven’t been paying attention. While myself and my family have a fighting chance because we are aware and support conceal carry, the fact that more Americans will be murdered just like the priest in Paris that was beheaded or the five terror attacks in Germany. Presently they are devising methods to smuggle resources to those American madrassas, the Christian fundamentalist schools, a sure way to make the masses even more stupid if ever there was one. Great piece, I am a 28 year Army Veteran who likes Trump, and I do agree he is a Wealthy all for him Billionaire, but I also believe that we need to enact regulatory policies, rules and actions that enable our tax dollars to be used properly. The political records and personal histories of the candidates is easily found. It doesn’t mean saving up a few extra bucks of “your” money while living with your parents in your upper class suburb or asking if people want fries with that while paying down student debt on your worthless liberal arts degree. We must join together and fight back against the wealthy elite and corporate politicians. Having a college degree these days is about like having a high school degree earlier last century. Then there’s Egypt, where less than a month after President Hosni Mubarak stepped down, the military junta that replaced him, ostensibly to “protect the revolution,” inadvertently reminded us of the two revolutions we women need. When more than 90 percent of ever-married women in Egypt — including my mother and all but one of her six sisters — have had their genitals cut in the name of modesty, then surely we must all blaspheme. The Iraq war seemed to demonstrate the complete imperviousness of the conservative mind to reasoned argument. This was reinforced strongly under the Clinton administration by what I saw as the overreaching social agenda of the fundamentalist Christian right which seemed to be hypermoralistic and to infringe on freedom of religion. I have yet to hear a discussion, in which someone dares mention, that racism is not a phenomenon limited to the white race, that all racial groups contain individuals, who are horribly, violently and overwhelmingly racist. He’s the only candidate who has not been working in Washington his whole life. Those fundamentalists do take their religion seriously. There is not a candidate on any ticket who appeals to me. 01%). So to the author or anyone else: What do you think would fix these deep divides in America? However some are also trying to scale down their welfare states, because the cost of them is becoming prohibitive. In the process, I’ve learned a lot about American history. In that case, you obviously did miss my point. They don’t represent anyone other than the demographic of people who attend elite private colleges. Less dignity. My ex wife has thyroid cancer, survivable but it really brings in medical bills like nobody’s business; most of my income went towards medication and doctor’s appointments. Trump is so filthy rich that money means nothing to him. But let’s put aside what the United States does or doesn’t do to women. Trump used to be a Democrat and was one for a long time, before running as a Republican. If you’re going to be low income, it’s better to be in a middle class town than in a poor rural area or poor inner city. The presidency of George W. S. No white indentured servant could be beaten while naked, but an African slave could. The wealthy elite! A. Now are there hateful people who support trump, sure! And it turns out that the people of a small Arkansas town in the middle of the Ozarks are not my enemy. ” Many of these families were descendants of white indentured servants who had fled to the Appalachian Mountains. Do wealthy elites and politicians care about poor and middle class people when they send them off to war, or are they anticipating massive profits? And what I often heard was a growing dissatisfaction among poor whites who were struggling to make ends meet in the failing economy. The Anti-Federalists were against slavery as well. I figured they were on a lunch break or they were in town to fish on the lake. But not all states are that way. But you aren’t usually going to hear about them in the MSM or see them represented by either major party. I just wish you’d direct your attention to the people who largely disagree with you and focus more energy on the strong opposing opinions. Burns voice) But I wasn’t raised so much around rednecks on a personal level, as I never lived in a poor white community, in the South or otherwise. Sanders is the only candidate speaking to the youngest generation, not just the young on the political left but across the spectrum. Trump promises to oppose all that and try to reverse it. If someone is getting by on $18 an hour when the minimum wage is $8 an hour, they probably won’t be if the minimum wage goes up to $15 an hour. I loved what you had to say and value your thesis and the obvious passion you can feel while reading this article. Bernie Sanders isn’t a huge supporter of Israel or war either. Like anyone else, they simply want to be free to live their lives as they choose and not be crushed by a cruel society. I’ll criticize Republicans and Democrats alike for not dealing with the problems we all face as a society. A few months later, I left Arkansas and moved to Vancouver, Washington. That is enough to dismiss her as a better candidate on minority issues. Maybe that’s what vermin ghosts smell like. But now the lower middle class and below is experiencing economic downward mobility, as the middle class shrinks. The Lost Generation in their older age, for example, pushed for Social Security and other progressive policies. It actually was found largely in urban areas and its membership was mostly the middle-to-upper class. People on Medicare, disability, food stamps, and unemployment are not my enemy. That is why I despise partisan politics. And they saw plenty of evidence of a shift toward a welfare state, most notably Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society, which for the first time funded school districts, college loans, Head Start, Medicare, and Medicaid, and cut poverty in half. The author failed to explain how exactly how Donald Trump is like the plantation owner. So, for me, to talk to working-class people is not very hard. So where does he get the wherewithal to improve his circumstances? And those at the bottom of the pile simply get crushed and die, either slowly or quickly. Lower income Americans these days don’t necessarily fit the stereotype of working poor. The point is that it is amazingly low. It isn’t. In December 2001, a federal grand jury indicted Tyson Foods and six managers on 36 counts related to conspiring to import undocumented workers into the U. While there I found those around me to be a microcosm of U. Really they all fell victim to a communist, a Palestinian, and racist? The thing that is most interesting to me is that, every time I can remember him talking about anything political, it was usually in favor of Republican candidates. Then I read your remarks. My mother’s family, largely German ancestry, came through the Upper South before ending up in Indiana. If you think I’m exaggerating, watch this video. If Soros paid protestors where the hell is my money?? There’s nothing you can teach me on this topic, I’ve heard all of your kind of liberal nonsense before. ” What all this means is that when it comes to the status of women in the Middle East, it’s not better than you think. Hate is the most powerful tool. People who grew up on farms or doing farm work around here is common. See the work of Anne Case and Angus Deaton, also Steven Woolf’s 2013 Institute of Medicine report “Shorter Lives, Poorer Health”. ) In this culture, the only explanations for Hillary’s behavior would be that she must be a lesbian, frigid, power obsessed, or has her own thing on the side. This isn’t about partisan politics, as you seem to assume. Religion had nothing to do with it – the issues were tribalism and greed, and that remains a constant in African conflicts today, particularly between African Muslims and kafirs. Name me an Arab country, and I’ll recite a litany of abuses fueled by a toxic mix of culture and religion that few seem willing or able to disentangle lest they blaspheme or offend. In the past or present, she has been involved in or supported: cutting welfare, resistant to raising the minimum wage, tough-on-crime policies, mass incarceration, private prisons, wars of aggression, toppling governments, corporatist ‘free’ trade deals, corporate subsidies, bank bailouts, big money in politics, being against same sex marriage, etc. Horrific news reports about 12-year-old girls dying in childbirth do little to stem the tide of child marriage there. “Writing for In These Times, author Jack Metzgar notes that the basis for this assumed white working-class support for Trump is his popularity among Republican voters who lack a college degree, who have indeed preferred him to the other Republicans in the race. I’m tired of people fighting against the biggest changes Bernie Sanders is trying to make – campaign finance reform, getting big money out of politics, holding corporations accountable. Slaveholders and slaves—the former having paid a lot of taxes and the latter having paid little or no taxes. His misogyny and zealotry make King Abdullah look like Susan B. Second, if you think Muslims are less likely to be criminals, I would recommend you spend some time in county prison in any metropolitan region. Still, many people have few choices available to them. ” No, not really. His politics are rather moderate in comparison. Now, I’m not saying American society is just fine or perfectly fair. I mostly meant the Republicans, but since you brought up Bernie Sanders, I think that he would be such a weak President that he would be a functional globalist. ” Maybe we should add, “God help them when they come home. And explain why a greater percentage of poor whites are on welfare than the percentage of poor blacks. I’m not a dirt poor rural white person, but I have known poverty and struggle. Nationalism is a bad word on the left, but it shouldn’t be. ” I feel like I am missing something here. I would capitalize “Asian,” “Hispanic,” or “Jewish,” but “white” is sort of a catch-all term that doesn’t indicate ethnicity. It’s an important fact that majority opinion in our society is silenced in mainstream media and goes unrepresented in mainstream politics. It was the way I spoke that landed me the job. This is not a myth this is a reality, so many people see a man who has promised to give them back their jobs, bring back the old ways, when jobs were plentiful and times were great. If we’re missing some teeth, it’s because when we finally get the money up for a visit to the dentist, he sneers at us as though our poverty was willful. I see how schools are trying to be more integrated. In an unguarded moment that Atwater believed was off the record, he said: You start out in 1954 by saying, “Nigger, nigger, nigger. Something is happening in white America that seems quite unprecedented. Book Smarts do not equal out to common sense, which is not really common any more. What I’m saying is Democrats already “bait” lower socioeconomic votes merely by virtue of welfare programs. ” That is part of what left-wingers and left-liberals criticize about the liberal class, the topic of Thomas Frank’s newest book. What’s more, freed white servants who received land as part of their freedom dues had begun to complain about its poor quality. This makes it harder for young people to break into certain fields, unless they or their parents are wealthy enough to support them through an unpaid internship. The corporate media loves Trump. I think that racism is alive and well in a lot of the world, and there are some people who capitalize on that racism for their own gain. If you mean TV specifically, or better yet specific news organizations, please say so! ” It could be that most Americans support a strong welfare state, low inequality, more opportunities for more people, etc for altruistic reasons because they want a better world for everyone, not just themselves. Under the guidance of this powerful lineup of Washington insiders and international leaders, the Carlyle Group soon became known for buying businesses related to the defense industry — and tripling their value during wartime. So, maybe at best you could claim she is a moderate neocon and moderate neoliberal, moderate within the neocon and neoliberal establishment. I’ll admit, it’s an odd construction, but STIR has chosen to err on the side of respect. Sanders, on the other hand, spent decades as an independent and worked with people in both parties. It’s easy to see why the lowest-ranked country is Yemen, where 55 percent of women are illiterate, 79 percent do not participate in the labor force, and just one woman serves in the 301-person parliament. But i agree with one thing he was a radical extremist. Going farther back, President Garfield was shot by an mentally ill man who believed that the Vice President would reward him with a civil service job. It’s just as much a control mechanism as the use of fear. My grandfather was born poor, barely had any education, and yet he got a good factory job that paid well and had great benefits. “I suppose my point is that those that mostly agree with you on the main points, vote in a like-minded way, don’t always require a detailed dissenting opinion that basically causes a wider devide which does nothing but separate you from the other, rather than coming together for the betterment of us all. Sarah; Interesting, you call the prior respondent to your comment “poor dumb white folk” and do not get reprimanded by the moderator but others who express a more right-leaning attitude are chastised. Than in Europe, for example) that come from never knowing anything about anywhere else. Everything can and should be improved: the social safety net, democratic self-governance, a free and fair economic system, environmental regulations, etc. It’s a bs process fought by bs folk and dirty work done by stupid people with a fan envy. Someone making these kinds of claims can’t really say “trust me” and that be sufficient. I’m quite aware of Oregon history. “Army privates made $25,085, while average defense CEO pay was $7. The poor are effed over and then blamed for the results of being effed over. Today’s GOP are a disaster and embarrassment to the world. By 2045 mega-racist whites will, one hopes, be a minority of what for sure will no longer be the racial majority in the United States, border wall or not. Observe Yusuf al-Qaradawi, the popular cleric and longtime conservative TV host on Al Jazeera who developed a stunning penchant for the Arab Spring revolutions — once they were under way, that is — undoubtedly understanding that they would eliminate the tyrants who long tormented and oppressed both him and the Muslim Brotherhood movement from which he springs. It was actually considered, early on, as a ‘whites only’ settlement. Not surprisingly, rural whites were the most likely to be kicked off those systems. To the uneducated racist that has an appeal. And, also what we don’t know or have a hard time understanding. Thomas Frank is an insightful writer. ” Trump didn’t seem threatened by the public sector’s involvement in his four corporate bankruptcies. They manipulate these silly liberals by telling them “Vote so we can import cheap labor from the 3rd world, or else you’re being racist. As the exercise went on, I started to notice a pattern. It’s on this basis that I disagree with you. Most of them haven’t been so lucky. But two things I’d like to take issue with. Iowa has good farmland and it used to be that a small family farmer could make good money. If you’re being honest, you have to admit that she is a neocon and neoliberal. For example, do you realize that most industrial workers walked or took mass transit to work 50 years ago? Bernie is saying attack the 1%, raise taxes everywhere, provide healthcare and college to everybody. North Carolina had way more fundamentalists than South Carolina. An essential part of democracy is public debate. I could find you a host of crackpots sounding off on Woman the Insatiable Temptress, but I’m staying mainstream with Qaradawi, who commands a huge audience on and off the satellite channels. Not all poor people, working class people, and homeless people are the same. Do you believe they stash it offshore, use it to stimulate the local economy, or do something else with it? One of the few good things about growing older is that one can remember what appears to have been purposefully erased from the national memory. Those presidents didn’t grow up hobknobbing with the social elite. I wouldn’t say there is a working class lifestyle. It worked. Even for those who do need welfare permanently, our laws are set up to make it hard for many people to maintain long-term benefits. ). Bernie’s revolution needs to involve how white privilege will be dismantled…then maybe more PoC will be interested in his revolution. This is my main reason for supporting Trump. Television? Morocco, often touted for its “progressive” family law (a 2005 report by Western “experts” called it “an example for Muslim countries aiming to integrate into modern society”), ranks 129; according to Morocco’s Ministry of Justice, 41,098 girls under age 18 were married there in 2010. As long as white people are living in fear of losing their livelihoods, verbal and physical mob assaults and worse for merely poking around a racial theme, and at the same time it is universally tolerated for blacks to keep screaming about how the white devil needs to be killed, keep calling white people the entire array or racial slurs for whites, keep blatantly discriminating against whites every single opportunity they get, racism will remain firmly rooted and will keep flourishing among all racial groups. Yet some freed servants didn’t know what was due them, and they were swindled out of their land grants. I have friends with college degrees who have working class jobs (bus driver, baker, etc) or who are unemployed. ” By “unprecedented” I was referring to the sudden increase in white working class mortality rates. If their mentality is incomprehensible to us, it’s because the voices of the white working class have rarely been articulated as passionately as they have been here. This is why the democrats struggle to get together, arguing minute details over points they really tend to agree on. Going back to my point about peasants, what you don’t grasp is that the world turns on such people. Ultimately I could not continue to identify with a movement which – though I actually agreed with some of its theoretical foundations (myopic though they sometimes are) – sought to sacrifice the principles of equal treatment under the law on the alter of “progressive” politics. But my point is she isn’t moderate compared to the general public, a point that I know you can’t refute and so you dismiss. ” The divides aren’t primarily between the South and the North or between rural and urban. “The truth may be, that when voters are tasked with casting their votes, they truly believe they are doing something altruistic, something that is good for the country and not themselves. This is a large, diverse country. Italy in the mid 1920’s through the 30’s had none of the cultural or ethnic divisions we have in the US, but had eerily similar class stratification. And last but not least, meet one more of the many people who do care about you. Thanks to your bar patrons, your family, your trailer park neighbors, and for all of the education that you have given yourself. The Carlyle Group wasn’t the only corporation that would profit from the wars. I heard one Republican politician explain that he respected Sanders honesty because one always knew where he stood, even when one disagreed with him. Has STIR considered hiring a fact checker? Many on the political left don’t fit into your stereotypes of the political left. The serious issue of democracy you consider mere minutia. What is obvious is that poor whites don’t understand what it is like to be a poor black. Most so-called “welfare queens” are white—this is true if you go by total numbers or by percentage of each race. As soldiers go off to war we say, “God bless our troops. With Colson’s comment following, both shed light in straightforward, relatable prose that speaks directly to working class people’s anger and fears. Second – Regardless of your skin color or net worth, I offer this rebuttal. The author has an interesting take on the history, and not necessarily wrong. Gays, lesbians, bisexuals, and transgender people are not my enemy. Some people get ahead and some don’t, no matter what they do or don’t do. If we know what is good for us as a nation he will not win his dream of being top of the game as President because it is clear that it is just a game to him. All he cared about in those final days was using the knowledge he had from 40+ years of working with cars, machinery, tools, to help the people in his community, and to help his friends, free of charge. Even now, it’s not as if I’m that far above the poverty level. I don’t know if he voted, I remember hearing him say favorable things about McCain. 9% of the population supported rebellion that is all. Undocumented immigration is at its lowest point that it’s been in a long time. I guess shame on Trump or Republicans to try and steal some of those poor votes from Democrats… I can tell you one thing, the poor votes Trump gets are at least WORKING CLASS contributing to society. And most of them are only on welfare temporarily. I am curious why “Black” is capitalized throughout the piece, unless it is from a direct quote where the original author used “black”, while “white” is not. Once you’re on it, you’ll never get off, and you’ll spend the rest of your life doing nothing but waiting for the next fix. Thank you for you thoughtful analysis. Far more than the last two POTUS’ to be sure. Bottom line – you don’t understand what “working class” means in the context of the article. ” That is a phrasing used by Gandhi, a non-Christian, in paraphrasing a letter by Augustine to a nunnery about disciplining nuns who had dedicated their lives to a life of holy renunciation. Another friend has a degree in computer graphics and it turns out it is hard to find work in that area. I don’t blindly follow partisan groupthink in a lockstep manner. Absolutely. Sorry, sounds like a whining crybaby who was lazy and never worked hard or felt they needed to! I like both Bernie and Trump, I think they both stand for true change, but I also believe that we will not see either of them on the podium during the coming elections. My father was lucky to start a new career when the economy was doing well. I was living in a trailer because it was what I could afford. Do be so smug thinking you’re college educated so it can’t happen to you because they just signed a bill to bring over college educated Indians to do the all IT and tech jobs, and compete against American workers to get paid Indian wages. But in many communities, there simply are few jobs available. And even when the Great Depression hit three years later, the lack of immigration prevented the economic carnage that would follow from being a lot worse than it actually was. “Well you have a computer so you must be well off! Like wealthy plantation owners who just happened to be politicians, Trump does not need to be bought; he is already rich enough. We must direct a truly united voice against those who, four hundred years ago, created the American Dream and then held it out of reach. Along with the middle class now shrinking, the US no longer has the wealthiest middle class in the world. We’re all becoming educated together…. In the comments here like life in general, there are those on the political left who are poor or defend the rights and interests of the poor, just as there are those on the political right who aren’t poor and are condescending and judgmental toward the poor. When you started justifying your stance I quit reading. Once in office, they become puppets of the richest ten percent of Americans. Case in point, the last civil war was won by oppressed people with guns, thus their use of guns is the reason for the abolition of slavery and the enforcement of subsequent civil rights for freed blacks It’s not implausible that a single person would decide to shoot the President: Gerald Ford was shot at twice by two unassociated unstable women, and Ronald Reagan was wounded by a mentally disturbed man who wanted to impress Jodie Foster. It’s offered them servitude to their master, the government. Finally, it is a fallacy to claim that Muslims in the US have a lower rate of violence than Christians, for at least two reasons. It would only take one major economic problem and life could get very tough for me. Or should I have slept on the streets to appease your vision of poverty? It doesn’t matter to me which candidate wins if in the process democracy loses. For example see the Atlantic: Who are Trump’s Supporters Really? It’s partly ethnic cultural differences, since the largest ancestral groups in the Midwest are from Northern Europe. I know FBI agents who tell me that there is no way to vet these people. So much so that 15 girls died in a school fire in Mecca in 2002, after “morality police” barred them from fleeing the burning building — and kept firefighters from rescuing them — because the girls were not wearing headscarves and cloaks required in public. (This seems to be what Hillary herself thought. Meanwhile, the conservative Republicans ballyhoo “personal responsibility” to working-class employees like the guys and gals here at Royal Lunch. By “white trash,” I could interpret that as meaning poor white people who have been severely and continuously poor for more generations than anyone can remember. This is severely uninformed and misinformed. ) Attempts to control by such regimes often stem from the suspicion that without it, a woman is just a few degrees short of sexual insatiability. I’ve known working class people my entire life. You’re not going to achieve that by saying poor whites are racists, or being played by Elites to be racists. In the context of the time, it would’ve been political suicide for the good senator from NYC to vote against the war in Iraq. The truth may be, that when voters are tasked with casting their votes, they truly believe they are doing something altruistic, something that is good for the country and not themselves. ” The working poor are a diverse group. As Bernie Sanders did with the gun manufacturer in Vermont? I used to vote Democratic, but I finally matured and grew up and grew out of my ignorance of believing rich Liberals! Rather, the Democratic party abandoned Southerners. That was the work of the CONSTRUCTION COMPANY he contracted to do his work. We are all people. Even many of the Federalists realized that slavery wouldn’t end well for the country, but they lacked the moral courage to do the right thing. But it can. But our future leaders, the millenials, are decidedly secular, materialistic, pro-choice and find religion annoying. Yet if you read his policy papers he also talks about mandatory instant employment verification to make it virtually impossible for illegal aliens to get jobs with fraudulent paperwork. ” I always dreaded driving into Portland with my big F150 truck sporting Arkansas plates. “As long as white people are living in fear of losing their livelihoods, verbal and physical mob assaults and worse for merely poking around a racial theme, and at the same time it is universally tolerated for blacks to keep screaming about how the white devil needs to be killed, keep calling white people the entire array or racial slurs for whites, keep blatantly discriminating against whites every single opportunity they get, racism will remain firmly rooted and will keep flourishing among all racial groups. I think this article should have gone into detail about this. The article actually argues for trump when you consider the wealthy establishment is against trump. What’s the story Sanders should be delivering to that demographic now, and how can he reach them? I know many religious people who really had different priorities and when they stated that the religion is the most important for them, they mean it; in one interview a liberal (in american sense) journalist asked his friend why he has to talk about Jesus all the time, couldn’t he restrict this views to private? The people who support Trump aren’t my enemy. Don’t bother responding, I know your kind – bleeding heart that can’t see that getting the government out of the way and reducing the need for welfare is the way to make people happier. S. Here in Iowa, I’ve worked numerous jobs. There is a higher percentage of poor whites than poor blacks who live in wealthier communities. It’s really those people who would most benefit from reading such a well thought out article, and I’ve shared it on social media that with the hope that it might educate some Trump supporters I know. Even my mother is far from a genius. The nice thing about progress is it’s never ending. As far as I can tell, I agree with your basic message. He is simply leveraging the myths that keep the average working class American angry at all the wrong things. Life is about perspective. Besides, it is a major risk to leave behind everything you know and depend on, to leave your family, community and church in order to bet everything on the hope that you’ll make it in the big city, precisely at a time when the economy is doing badly and opportunities are decreasing, wages are stagnating, economic mobility not being what it used to be, and homelessness on the rise. Don’t blame the average Southerner for everything done by the Southern political and economic elite. That was an editorial choice. So: Yes, women all over the world have problems; yes, the United States has yet to elect a female president; and yes, women continue to be objectified in many “Western” countries (I live in one of them). Some Christian humility is needed. Let’s have a dialogue. A very well written, well researched article. That is pretty much the complete opposite of being a communist revolutionary. You don’t have much money and you find simple, cheap ways to occupy the rest of your time. No one knows exactly what is the total unemployment rate. It isn’t much wealth, but it is more wealth than having no money at all. Besides veterans, there is a high unemployment and underemployment rate, when one counts all unemployment. The media has lied about, or exaggerated his statements – ascribing meaning to them that was not explicit in his wording in order to smear him and calling his followers “stupid” and “racist” for wanting the laws of this country (such as immigration laws) to apply equally to everyone, and for (however clumsily) identifying the problem of Muslim extremism and urging caution in potentially importing that sort of extremism to the United States. Awesome post, Rich. All he knew was that he worked hard his whole life and was never rewarded for it. Money couldn’t be frivolously spent by either of my families, and my dad’s reckless spending habits (he never considered money important, and would blow all of his spare income making him and his friends happy because that’s what mattered more to him – good times with good people). For me, it was a way to cover my head. Master the skills to rise here as they will prepare you for the next eighty years of duplicity and distrust. She considered the issue. I’d also suggest reading Joe Bageant, a left-winger who wrote about the poor white Appalachians he grew up with. You want income equality we want racial equality…. I’ve had less than positive experiences with welfare, when I was married I made little enough that we were stuck on SNAP, and they made it hell to keep the benefits (a disadvantage of living in a red state)–and we didn’t qualify for health care. I Honestly don’t know who I’m voting for. The entire culture wars that have driven the political right for decades is the most paternalistic expression of politics around. Simply put, you talk in the terms of leftist privilege. Actually, data I’ve seen shows that pro-wrestling is popular among liberals. Yet it’s the men who can’t control themselves on the streets, where from Morocco to Yemen, sexual harassment is endemic and it’s for the men’s sake that so many women are encouraged to cover up. The failure of democracy, including Clinton’s corruption and bad political record, is not minutia. On Mother’s Day, May 12, thousands of women formed the first wave of demonstrators, led by Coretta Scott King and joined by Ethel Kennedy, wife of presidential candidate Sen. It’s about opportunity. Everything I have seen reported seems to suggest that Trump supporters trend poorer, more rural, and less educated than supporters of other candidates. This introduced the first racial divide between skilled and unskilled workers. They aren’t hard to find in real life. Most is necessary only to fill pages and the gist of the article would not to compromised if you had eliminated it. Sanders seems clueless on Foreign Policy, and has failed to condemn the outright nation building activities of USA (he condemned Iraq but has not taking a strong stance against Hillary in Libya and USA fighting Assad in Syria today). It is always the have-nots who are the staunchest republicans and makes me shake my head! Data shows that inequality increases, unemployment grows, recessions happen more often and last longer, and suicide and homicide rates increase under Republican administrations. And I felt ashamed for judging that woman’s life based entirely on her appearance. They might want to be a bit more grateful. And I am an unskilled, working class bum and Union cardholder (CWA & IWW). 4 billion), DynCorp ($4. Yet they are totally oblivious to how they are perceived or why their message is not well-received. However, this same question could be asked of wealthy liberal elites who advocate for higher taxes, more welfare programs, and more progressive platforms. I’ll admit, it’s an odd construction, but STIR has chosen to err on the side of respect. They have a bit of the Upper South culture about them. Urban, liberal culture is the dominant culture, so urban liberals don’t need to know anything about white rural culture, and often don’t. I imagined the liberal urbanites seeing me as one of “those people,” as if they expected me to barrel down the street chucking Walmart bags full of trash out the open window while blasting “Sweet Home Alabama” on my way to shoot up an abortion clinic. Nor did he imply that it applied to all Christians as a universal law of Christianity. Again, anecdotally, many people were on SSI for reasons entirely preventable by diet (diabetes, etc. I can tell you that I have paid attention to all of the candidates, I will not be voting for Trump, or Clinton, but have actually been considering Sanders. The weekend before New York’s primary I’m traveling there to join the march for Bernie in Foley Square (I hope it ends on Wall Street) and to canvass the rest of my time. John F. Truman, in 1948. And all you are living on is the satisfaction of your skin being white, and the drum major instinct of thinking that you are somebody big because you are white. These people end up in New York or Houston or Boston—places where they can buy boutique coffees or go to the art cinema—holding down jobs in broadcasting or research or economics. Many of the poorest, uneducated, and most religious people in the country actually vote Democratic or else they don’t vote at all, even when they do support Democrats. How conveniently she ignores the Islamic method of subjugating women to second class citizens, which is the best they can hope for, or at its worst, condemns them to near slavery and death for the slightest perceived infractions against their archaic religious edicts. As evidence of this, please study these two charts, presented with no further commentary. Trump doesn’t care about poor American whites either. They’ve been Republicans there since it was the true Party of Lincoln. With more than 650,000 deaths, the end of the Civil War eventually brought freedom for African-Americans. ” The underlying distaste you feel is that Sanders, a white politician, chose to listen to rather than shut down the voices of blacks. But I expect this kind of nonsense from you. People have an amazing ability to categorize each other as different, such as the division between southern and northern Italians. After feudalism ended and British imperialism came to power, there was a period when the fate of indentured servants was often horrific. Right now there are millions who will be lucky if they are accepted by the military, and if they are extra lucky they will qualify for a vocational school before they are absorbed forever by America’s passive, ignorant labor pool culture. There was promise of a better life, but the workers on the railroads were often not paid–not even allowed to bury their dead because it would slow progress–far from the romanticized version of history shown in drama, novels, or television shows such as Hell on Wheels. It’s not as if public school teachers have ever made a ton of money, but it’s enough money to raise a family and save for retirement. But then there is this one concerning Democrats: “President Johnson, a greater ally to Black civil rights leaders than Kennedy had been, took over the program after Kennedy’s assassination and expanded its scope. Saudi women far outnumber their male counterparts on university campuses but are reduced to watching men far less qualified control every aspect of their lives. The American bootstrap myth is merely another strap that makes the working poor privately conclude that they must in some way be inferior, given that they cannot seem to apply that myth to their own lives. Admittedly, in the quest to fight for the oppressed — people of color, women, religious minorities, the LGBTQ community — we often overlook the fact that classism never completely disappeared. The only reason I support Sanders is to help change the narrative. He was rolled so easily! It’s the society, not the individual, that makes someone rich. It wasn’t unusual for parents to indenture their kids to learn a trade and in most cases such as these the children lived to know freedom in which to work the trade they learned. The wealthy corporation! I know that Bernie is our only chance to correct this awful mess that we are all in! You didn’t live through security lockdowns as our embassies were bombed. He says if you are poor, take my hand. That is why younger liberals and leftists support Sanders. , it’s just a massive coincidence that at a time of increasing political instability, a president who had taken money from the same military industrial complex warned of by his predecessor, then attempted to withdraw from Vietnam undermining their profits was assassinated, and his brother running for president and a massively popular civil rights activist were then both assassinated within weeks of initiating a campaign of national working class unity and anti-war agitation. ) In “Blue America”, Bill Clinton’s adultery was a private matter between him and Hillary. By 2012, those gains had been replaced by losses. TRUMP is going after the political neocons who make money from illegal wars in the Middle East (who have blessed Hillary’s pro-war foreign policies). This is only true if you have strong preconceptions about what kind of degree you are going to work towards or what kind of work you want to do. S. Why stay put? His support for the 1964 CRA and the 1965 VRA (which both passed largely because of Republicans), and the nomination of Thurgood Marshall in 1967 (again, whose confirmation relied on GOP votes) had more to do with a cynical move to get votes rather than being an ally to civil rights leaders. After having spent time in the Deep South, I traveled around the country a bit and then moved back to the Midwest where I was born. I find that odd. And shame on you if you are unwilling to admit that the reason you employed it was because you thought the opinions of the person to whom you were responding were not worthy of consideration. I share your interests in trying to make sense of where we come from. How can any person on any side of the isle not say yes to all of the above? We need tax cuts, support for the working class & the lazy needs to be taken off government assistance & go back to work like the rest of us. But one thing is missing: you never truly spoke Blue Collar. Just as regime-appointed clerics lull the poor across the region with promises of justice — and nubile virgins — in the next world rather than a reckoning with the corruption and nepotism of the dictator in this life, so women are silenced by a deadly combination of men who hate them while also claiming to have God firmly on their side. Please keep me inform of any and all of your writing and Posting…Par Excellence in disecting our current political climate…Again thank you Any aid or welfare program in modern history, in America or in Europe which is seen like a role model by USA liberals, would inevitably end up with ten bureaucrats being assign to monitor and control a welfare check of each single poor person. Even if there was public transit, he probably would have been too proud to use it, just as he would have been too proud to go on welfare even if he needed it. My God! David Rothkopf Donald Trump Is America’s Experiment in Having No Government Rosa Brooks There Are No Real ‘Safe Zones’ and There Never Have Been Lauren Wolfe Savaging State and USAID Budgets Could Do Wonders for Results Gordon Adams The End of the End of the Cold War Julia Ioffe If Anyone Can Bankrupt the United States, Trump Can Daniel Altman Exclusive: International Criminal Court Poised to Open Investigation into War Crimes in Afghanistan David Bosco Africa’s Hottest Frozen Border Boils Over Michela Wrong Splitting Hairs and Trump’s Fascist Heirs Matt Bors A New Way To Read The Crisis in Greece Kalev Leetaru Yahtzee Meets the Hot Zone Michael Peck. In hindsight, it makes perfect sense that President Reagan would share Don Tyson’s desire for smaller government. While the field may indeed be unfair, voting in a hard core socialist will do nothing but bankrupt people on all levels with huge tax increases. Hunt Transportation, Glad Manufacturing, and Tyson Chicken. Its analysis of southern history is so close to this one that I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s where Jonna learned it. Indentured Servants were at the bottom of the class system, remnants of which persist in the South to this day. Let’s just be clear about one thing. It is a linguistically different language from Middle Class Bourgeois American English. Too many people have had bad experience from history classes. Trump isn’t appealing to stalwart Republicans. This was a really thought provoking piece, and I enjoyed reading your take on the situation, especially as it relates to your personal experience living in poverty and in different parts of the U. Despite this he heavily criticized the bill and called out all of the negative effects, including that it would provide a financial incentive to arrest people of color and drum up ridiculous drug possession charges. Jonna…thank you for an exceptional perspective on how we are divided by class and how it developed. Not sure if the error is with the year or the President. The kinds of policies he suggests are what even Republicans used to support, earlier last century. He was simply pointing out that race makes a big difference in being poor. To offset tax cuts and massive increases in military spending, Reagan slashed federal social programs — for low-income Americans. ” My labor has been exploited my entire working life, ya’ whiner, so this ain’t yer pity party, n’k? A variant of the word leads to the forensic evidence used in court. That part of my family comes from Indiana and before that Kentucky. No one really knows why capybaras are so magnetic—maybe they just know something about kindness and compassion humans don’t. He was rolled so easily! Perot saw it, Nader saw it, and now Mr. I know that the nature of capitalism is to put profit first – that’s why we can’t have privatized social security. Poor and middle class people of all races who despise handouts and socialism given to individuals see the solution being more jobs for citizens, and Trump is telling them the things he wants to do to make that happen. And you should wear the title ‘Motherfucker’ like the badge of honor it is while inserting the word ‘Tough’ in front. Those are the real enemies. The rich benefit the most from all of this. Most Americans, left and right, simultaneously support gun rights and stronger gun regulation. In Kuwait, where for years Islamists fought women’s enfranchisement, they hounded the four women who finally made it into parliament, demanding that the two who didn’t cover their hair wear hijabs. The Lost Generation in their older age, for example, pushed for Social Security and other progressive policies. I suppose it was the polite, non-judgmental thing to do. But people fight over these issues. Trump wants to secure the borders. I lived in a mostly Jewish suburb. Well, his children ended up having fairly decent careers. There has been a long tradition of American socialism going back to the 19th century. Three men I’d never seen came in and sat at a table on the patio. He is no ideological pacifist. W. So why weren’t they angry with Tyson Foods, a company that could easily afford to pay higher wages? It’s totally rural. S. ” “Trump is running a simple more relateable and realistic platform – he is saying go nationalistic, reverse globalist trade laws which have enabled rampant outsourcing, bring manufacturing back, stop illegal wars, seal up the border. Don Tyson didn’t make poor people in town feel inferior, but outsiders did. ” What doesn’t make sense is that America’s white underclass would agree with him. My father was much like one of the white underclass you mention. It used to be that hard work counted for something, no matter one’s education. Finally, the Washington Post published data on the Republican primary that shows that those counties with the highest white working class mortality had the highest support for Trump. It was a group of rich, libertarian (in an COMPLETELY greed-based way), primarily rural individuals that brought this group into a position of power by financing their move into the political process, first at the local and then at the state level and then into the House and Senate. Wouldn’t it be great if Jeremy Corbyn wins here in 2020 with a victorious Sanders in the Whitehouse? I don’t hate or fear those who are different from me. And this problem is a thousand times worse in states of high poverty and inequality. Can you get any more condescending ? I’ve watched what we fought for and what Johnson did for us fall by the wayside. He doesn’t discuss working class liberals, partly because working class liberals like me don’t hold political positions nor work in the MSM. Homeless camps are growing in size and number all over the country, specifically in the big cities. My heart tells me I would see the tension this caused and walk back to the middle with my hands out, saying, “join me in the middle here….. First there was the wealthy land-owner class, beneath them the slaves, and at the bottom the indentured servants. And of course, no mention was made of the deeply hostile cultural politics that the Left has engaged in since the later sixties, while it largely abandoned economic issues. The problems the US economy faces has little to do with immigration. Mussolini got started as a populist leading marches and invoking class conflict, and successfully morphed a populist agenda into a fascist takeover, supported by the masses of the poor and uneducated. Yes, it comes down to cost of living. I know I’m relatively luck living where I do. The haves and have-nots rarely share the same view, with one exception: politics. BDS, you are proof of what George Will succinctly stated last month on television: “You cannot reason a person out of a position that they were not reasoned into. There are other revealing errors in what you say. Amina Filali — the 16-year-old Moroccan girl who drank poison after she was forced to marry, and beaten by, her rapist — is our Bouazizi. To his everlasting credit, Mr. As for welfare, besides most recipients being white, most recipients are employed but not earning enough to make ends meet and most recipients are only temporarily on welfare. The words ‘sin’ and ‘sinner’ are one of many possible translations of the original language. Technology, reason, knowledge are all we need. Bernie has also written more legislation for Vets in the last 30 yrs than any other politician. That is where I started regretting the last 30 minutes digesting the article prior. We are ready to develop unique papers according to your requirements, no matter how strict they are. (I have lots of screen shots that I sent to the pd) There is also been us Native Americans. Sanders has made quite a case for how working-class white males like myself should support him, but he has been tone-deaf for how this relates to systemic racism and sexism and making opportunity equal for everyone. I’ve had working class jobs my entire life: working newspaper routes as a child, working fastfood and mowing lawns in high school, and since then doing housecleaning, janitorial, dishwashing, and presently working as a parking ramp cashier. They rent until they die, with no hope of passing along to their children any accumulated wealth in the form of equity in a home. This is something that the establishment candidates aren’t doing enough of. I was working my day shift at the bar, the same regulars sitting on the same barstools. What a well written argument that the 99% have been strategically pitted against one another racially by the 1% since slavery in order that the 1% maintain their economic status! Maybe that’s impossible, but maybe that isn’t. They breed anencephalic children, mouth breathers like themselves. You ought to be marching with us. But the people he won over so easily turned on him, not because of economic issues, but for violating cultural norms. All the poor Southern whites have to do to get the representation they crave is to set their bigotries aside and be willing to work with those who are trying to uplift all people. Most Americans barely make enough to live on and don’t have much left over from taxes, despite those natural resources being on public land from which these poor people should be as rich as some of the Nordic people who also have resource-rich countries, just not a class of exploiters. Working class whites may view economic struggles as temporary setbacks, and see their use of social services as a last resort. There were Marxists in Abraham Lincoln’s administration, Theodore Roosevelt argued that mainstream politics should take the concerns of socialists seriously, agrarian socialists were all over the Midwest, and sewer socialist governed Milwaukee for about a half century. A primitive breed with prehistoric manners, unfit for anything beyond petty crime and random bloodletting. It makes sense if you assume that work is something only other people should do. It is also where was developed some of the harshest tactics of big biz against organized labor (see “Right Out of California” by Kathryn S. Part of that has to do with the recession and its aftereffects. Wages have stagnated or even decreased, good benefits have been lost, and buying power has fallen. And author Jonna Ivin is one in a million.. My mother’s family are working class whites. I hear you and agree 100% MoveOn, Soros and Alinsky tactics are the things that really kill it for me with the Bernie crowd. He isn’t as far left as FDR New Deal Progressivism or Milwaukee Sewer Socialism, much less authoritarian communism. The very people who support Democrats the most are the least likely to vote, whether because of apathy or because of voting difficulties (e. The point of view is extremely valuable as it sets our sights beyond the media’s horse race narrative and looks for common (! Either a politician is bullied by others or he becomes a bully himself, which I assume is probably why you support Trump who is the ultimate bully. One neighbor was an old Southern Belle who had married below her class, but she had inherited money and for her entire life she had a personal black servant who followed her around doing everything for her. There are myriad photos of capybaras cuddling with with turtles, birds, and monkeys. The real enemies fear us. High rates of innovation. People today in USA feel threatened and alienated in their own country and NO this is not because the political elite are poisoning their mind to say it. Anyone who votes for open boarders is in the back-pocket of the wealthy elite. You obviously must be living a comfortable lifestyle if you don’t understand what is happening in our economy right now. Everything in life is relative. And I’m still not that far above poverty. Why? During the pre-Civil War era, there was plenty of racism in the Northeast, and there weren’t any wealthy plantation owners manipulating people in that part of the country. From this, Bernie Sanders learned a life lesson, “An election in 1932 ended up killing 50 million people around the world. Yep. I was an outsider. I can’t speak to how much assistance people with children or disabilities receive, but I can tell you what I received as a single, childless adult with no assets and a zero balance in my checking account. Also, don’t forget that a place like Oregon was the only sundown state in the country, where blacks were legally excluded from living there. The thinking public will not easily believe freedom and education more brutalizing than slavery, and the world knows that the crime of rape was unknown during four years of civil war when the white women of the South were at the mercy of the race which is all at once charged with being a bestial one. I don’t consider as enemies to be defeated those who are conservatives, Republicans, poor whites, or anyone who isn’t like me. But, for me, eugenics isn’t a joking matter. If you’re a land-owner who are you going to treat better: the slave for whom you paid 20 gold guineas (a fortune) and who own outright, or the servant who you owned only for the period of indenture (usually 7 or 10 years)? I would die for my country, I would burn our flag in protest if I felt so moved, and I would duke it out in the streets for what I believe America stands for (not this class war that the poor and middle class are getting crushed in). No one had to pay him to help the homeless man down by bay fix the boat he would sleep in. She was surprised at how calm she was,” Rifaat writes. Politicians, the corporate media, and giant employers (like Tyson) have continued to drive socioeconomic wedges between poor whites and poor minorities. ). You have a lot of ideas about class identity, but you don’t seem to realize how different it can mean to be working class. I am with you all the way brother! They spend their days ingesting large quantities of grass (nice) and hanging out by freshwater streams and marshes. From the factories of industrialized cities in the North to rural farmlands in the Midwest, from the Statue of Liberty in the East to the filmmakers in the West, racism had replaced classism as the most blatant form of oppression. And I spent a large part of my life in the Deep South growing up. If the world is going to hell, it has little to do with what the poor are doing or want to do. I wish more Americans could realize how interesting history can be, when you get the right books that make it compelling. The scaly pale-gray skin of buck toothed men who huff turpentine chased with dilaudids and Oxy’s. But you have to understand that many liberals aren’t particularly wealthy. While it is important to enlighten those on the left not to stereotype poor Southern (or other poor) whites and to understand the history of racism and how it continues to be used effectively to divide and conquer, her conclusions seem to be directed at poor racist white Republicans and other Trump supporters. As classic conservatives, their main objective was not ensuring the hegemony of any one group, but maintaining the stability of American society as a whole. He often referred to sin in more general ways, as having fallen short. It got me thinking of all the different ways we keep each other down doing the work for the upper class. ” From the time of slavery (yes, slavery) to the rise of Donald Trump, wealthy elites have relied on the allegiance of the white underclass to retain their affluence and political power. My grandma lived in a four bedroom middle-class house in a nice area of town. We are both educated and I am a retired airport paramedic firefighter. They don’t love Sanders, which should tell you a lot. According to Rev. She had grown up in a Republican family in the northern suburbs of Chicago and this was what she saw as civic involvement. As the war lingered on, poor whites in the North and South began to realize the rich had waged the war, but it was the poor who were dying in it. Your initial comment suggested eugenics. I truly believe that bringing people together for a cause is the answer, but we need to speak in a language that all can unite under, we need someone who can speak to the progressive and the conservative and until we can find a happy medium we always have pitted sides. You are culpable for the actions of the politicians you vote for. It was a crude, rough-hewn, purely instinctive sort of communism; still, it touched the cardinal point and was powerful enough amongst the working class to produce the Utopian communism of Cabet in France, and of Weitling in Germany. Just give you free stuff others earned and that will be the bliss filled “Revolution”! Please. Poor people aren’t so fortunate, since a single mistake can ruin their lives. King Abdullah is 87. They had only one child in order to support the family in the best way they could, and subsequently taught me the value of education. His own father was born in an abandoned house where the family was squatting. I’m not blind to the struggle–but I sure as hell don’t look at a man who inherited his money as any better; and arguing that he might have to give up an extra car or a vacation home to help better the lives of his countrymen is simply absurd–I give what I can, I expect others to do so as well from common decency. “That non-voters are non-voters speaks to the fact that the U. Now, you’re talking about cutting taxes, and all these things you’re talking about are totally economic things and a byproduct of them is, blacks get hurt worse than whites. Cheers! Last summer’s flood of migrants pushed immigration and border security to the fore, with almost 69,000 unaccompanied minors crossing the border in fiscal 2014. And when those brothers told me what they were earning, I said, “Now, you know what? I dare the author that. Two reports published last year by the Pew Charitable Trusts found, respectively, that 55 percent of households didn’t have enough liquid savings to replace a month’s worth of lost income…” “Wolff also examined the number of months that a family headed by someone of “prime working age,” between 24 and 55 years old, could continue to self-fund its current consumption, presuming the liquidation of all financial assets except home equity, if the family were to lose its income… He found that in 2013, prime-working-age families in the bottom two income quintiles had no net worth at all and thus nothing to spend. When my dad had enough of trying to scrape by with his mechanic shop, he let his best friend have his property to reconstitute it as a concrete company that my dad’s best friend had inherited from his father. Very few liberals and leftists attend or even have the opportunity to visit private elite colleges. Obama’s record is actually pretty horrid as far as getting people out of poverty and into the workforce. On capitalizing “Black”: That was an editorial choice. Nobody knows how many permanently unemployed there are, as those are excluded from the unemployment records. Perhaps the truth is that Americans, collectively, are not very bright? No one knows do animals deserve rights essay its origin, although by the 4th century there are mentions of it. Lunacy on both sides. The economy has been hitting hard across many demographics. Donald Trump – has time and again – faulted THE 1%, The political elite, the lawmakers for shipping jobs out, taking the globalized thought too far and has attacked the banks as well as the Fed for facilitating the lawmakers. The causes of death are still being explored but it appears that many of these deaths are being driven by drug and alcohol abuse and suicide. Not everyone is so lucky. ) What hope can there be for women in the new Egyptian parliament, dominated as it is by men stuck in the seventh century? We progressives are always wringing our hands about why “they” (poor whites) are always voting against their own interests. Those are facts. He would watch CNN or Fox or CBS or MSNBC. I had no experience, but the owner of the bar told a friend she hired me because, “she speaks well and has all her own teeth. Please be careful; we all need to be more careful about how we talk about “the media. This is why the democrats struggle to get together, arguing minute details over points they really tend to agree on. The catholic answered: “why you want me to stop talking about thing which are most important to me and limit myself to things which are of secondary importance”? We too often don’t get to hear that perspective except in trite sound bites about government being the enemy or “takers” and “moochers” ruining America. Also reminded me of what an enduring tragedy it was, beyond MLK and Bobby’s deaths, that the Poor People’s Campaign and Resurrection City ended in the way they did. Have you read many articles? This is a terrible and silent crisis. What that entails, of course, is a matter of opinion. I didn’t. They want basic rights and opportunities. If that is the case, then poor white voters who vote for wealthy elites may be doing so because they believe that person will help this country the most even if the candidate has not promised to provide them with upward mobility. He also is the candidate with the most support from low income Americans, including poor whites. This is happening while black and Latino death rates are decreasing. This article is simply one of a million that will fail to draw more than an eyeroll (and perhaps, amongst more charitable readers, a genuine “At least she tried”) from anyone who does not already share all the author’s views. Citizens an option more enticing than a night in. But, you seem to think it’s only racist if it’s against white people. ” Baiting, and absolutely uninformed and false As for hiring illegals. It is no accident that number corresponds roughly to the percentage of Americans with college degrees. Some of research paper for sociology the rich may prefer Trump to Clinton, but I bet most of the rich would prefer Trump to Sanders. Don’t forget that rich people wouldn’t be so rich if not for government tax breaks, government subsidies, no-bid contracts, natural resources on public lands sold at below market prices, government-maintained infrastructure and services, a publicly educated and trained workforce, government-enforced free trade agreements that favor big biz, bills often written by corporate lobbyists, regulatory capture, average Americans enlisting in the military to fight wars that defend the interests of big biz (defending trade routes and access to foreign resources), and on and on. As a long term resident now of the PNW, a lot of us moved here from crap-ass parts of the country, where everything from Walmart to NAFTA to Bain Capital and vulture capitalism (the deal where they buy the company, load it up with debt, then sell it as a paper asset after they move the jobs offshore).. There is a reason the candidate who identifies as a socialist, Sanders, is not just the most popular and most trusted candidate with the biggest crowds and the most small donations. Our country was founded on, how can i say this … On the backs of people, was stolen from people, denied and continue to be denied to others. I love being American…. In fact, most people on welfare are employed but don’t make enough money to pay for basic necessities. He is just an ordinary social democrat, a moderate liberal and an old school New Deal progressive. He steered clear of the steerage class and catered exclusively to the rich by buying or building luxury residential properties, office buildings, hotels, casinos, golf courses, and resorts. But to entirely discount the opinion held by those “poor white mf’ers” as something only planted by Rich CEOs and 1% Elite is extremely patronizing and basically, the author is calling them fools for voting against their own interests by not being democratic. Or at least there is a lack of legal unemployment, although the black market is booming, if you don’t mind being a drug dealer, prostitute, or whatever. Republicans seem more worried about who sleeps with whom or what idiot 5000 year old goat herders had to say about morality and law, as you cherry-pick your way through Bible quotes and come up with things you can hate people with, or ignore your real problems as a result of. By 2003, as the war effort shifted focus from Afghanistan to Iraq in search of weapon of mass destruction, the defense contracts leapt to $2. This analysis fails to account for two things; first that people select candidates for reasons other than economic interests, and second, that people should select candidates that will provide for their own self interest. It was a different culture than I grew up with. Dr. It had to be the narrative about hard work that so easily lulled him in to voting for Republicans. “So what if a conservative candidate wants to ban abortion? They cease beating their wives just long enough to let the little woman squeeze out another deformed crumb-snatcher. Great piece, although I also noticed an error. What Ivins does have is conventional liberal stereotypes applied roughly and readily, barely varnished with a compassionate mode of rhetoric that (as is again, typical of the genre) makes an earnest attempt to rise beyond the standard liberal pose of abject condescension, but largely fails, mainly because it fails to transcend the conceit of liberal self-congratulation. I’ve been dedicating hours and hours to phonebanking for his campaign. ” There are overlap between all of these terms, but they aren’t the same. Now they’re learning it’s been a lie all along. This changed my father’s opinion as he came to relate more with the poor Mexicans doing very hard concrete and construction work. Veterans struggle to find proper healthcare in a system ill-prepared for the number of wounded, particularly those with catastrophic injuries and mental health issues that require long-term care. So intelligent liberals are advised to save their depression and the good booze for later, when things get worse. He could throw millions of dollars left and right and still be rich beyond imagination for several lifetimes over. But it is an absolute canyon now, and growing deeper. The numbers were not on their side — not the financial numbers, but the number of bodies it would take to wage war should Lincoln try to abolish slavery. It’s a passage that Christians have struggled with for many reasons. I could have sworn that when I read “Master of the Senate,” the authoritative biography of Johnson’s time as Senate Majority Leader, it described Johnson as the one who tried to push it through the Senate. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said recently. Immigrants and refugees are not my enemy. The “redneck hillbillies” in that Arkansas bar could have laughed with the three Klan members, or said nothing at all. We’re all in this together, and frankly, divided we WILL fall. If that is the case, then poor white voters who vote for wealthy elites may be doing so because they believe that person will help this country the most even if the candidate has not promised to provide them with upward mobility. Amplify the voices of the region and poke the hatred in its eye. For opening a window to one’s soul. Economy as a whole would take a hit if immigrant workers disappeared. ) Actually, if Twain had had any knowledge of language, instead of engaging in his own bigotry, he would have known that “faith” (pistis in Greek) is trust and loyalty, based on either direct experience, or the testimony of reliable witnesses. He talks about many of the same things as Trump, such as the problems of ‘free’ trade agreements. I have to wonder how many people could withstand such microscopic personal scrutiny over such a sustainable time. We are talking about ideas and beliefs, rhetoric and talking points, perceptions and prejudices that have been developing over generations and even centuries at this point. I have no interest in joining your team to ensure the Democrats win no matter what. With whites and Blacks divided, the wealthy elite prospered enormously for the next two hundred years while poor whites remained locked in poverty. But these officers reserved “virginity tests” for female activists: rape disguised as a medical doctor inserting his fingers into their vaginal opening in search of hymens. In 1968, he joined his father’s real estate business, then conservatively valued at $40 million. I’m also critical of our plutocracy. ” Shame on you if you are unwilling to apply that George Will quote to your own political position, but only to people who disagree with you. As for the 2nd Amendment, polls show that most liberals and Democrats support it. It is one of the purposes of our Constitution. Colonial law provided “freedom dues,” which usually included 100 acres of land, a small sum of money, and a new suit of clothes. Immigration opponents have long argued that immigrants are taking jobs that would otherwise be filled by Americans who are out of work, but numerous studies have found the contributions of immigrants to the U. ” But who are we keeping it great for? This is why the democrats struggle to get together, arguing minute details over points they really tend to agree on. Sanders is also a supporter of gun rights and, in a debate with Clinton, even defended corporations that make guns—as I said, not exactly what most people mean by ‘socialism’. Racism is certainly one example. Thank you to all of the people in your life who have educated you more than many who have traditional and formal degrees. Otherwise, onwards and upwards. I don’t have a college degree. When this happens, a “tip credit” is given to employers, and they save money by paying less than the standard minimum wage. After all, shouldn’t everyone get basic rights first, before women demand special treatment? It’s also about social skills, education, connections, and putting two and two together to earn a living. The most wealthy people I know are my conservative parents, as they did fairly well in their careers. For more than four hundred years, wealthy elites have depended on the white underclass to “help keep America great. When compared to non-Arab and non-Islamic Americans, Arab and Islamic Americans have lower rates of violence and higher rates of education, wealth, and professional careers. And we’re in the middle of a revolution in Egypt! Nevertheless, I fear for what it means, in terms of the minds of the American people, if we pass up Sanders. “It could be that most Americans support a strong welfare state, low inequality, more opportunities for more people, etc for altruistic reasons because they want a better world for everyone, not just themselves. It’s all a ploy for power. I figured someone else would have asked about this and had it answered in the comments, but everyone who commented seems either not to have noticed or understands the underlying meaning behind this juxtaposition. You get a C- for your reading comprehension, good luck to you, I hope you have access to resources that can help you improve on this subject. We are simply asking that we no longer allow the rich (who in many cases got that way from getting ‘free stuff’) to divide the poor and turn them on each other in an overt attempt to keep them from looking for the root cause of their suffering – the moneyed organized few expending every available resource to maintain power and wealth. Capital from his father’s company wasn’t Trump’s only empire-building head start. Many people all over the country are in a tough spot. Excellent article. Anyhow, being poor has always sucked no matter one’s race or ethnicity. Recently a DHS analyst made public the same information and that he was told that he was not allowed to go after these groups. Etc. The Second Klan was mostly found in the more liberal North, not the South. My small town has been drastically affected by the wealthy bringing in immigrants and forcing poor white workers to look for work and it has destroyed our town. Apparently, the Arab jury is still out on the basics of human biology. Please wake up to the fact that those on your own economic rung do not cause your fiscal suffering! I’ll never forget hearing that if a baby boy urinated on you, you could go ahead and pray in the same clothes, yet if a baby girl peed on you, you had to change. I used to work cleaning up the downtown and regularly talked to the homeless. “She returned to the living room and poured out the coffee for herself. It’s a revolution in which women have died, been beaten, shot at, and sexually assaulted fighting alongside men to rid our country of that uppercase Patriarch — Mubarak — yet so many lowercase patriarchs still oppress us. They begin at home and continue in grade school. I’m not sure I understand your point. From fiscal year 1980 to fiscal year 1987, federal funding for these programs plummeted by 35. Anyways… There is an old joke about these people and a magic genie. I’d love to her the author’s opinion on organized religion, but that may be a can of worms not worth opening. If trump turns out to be a good president the establishment is done for good. Anyway, Sanders isn’t actually a ‘socialist’. Many prisons no longer offer the Bible on the commisary order sheet and offer only the Quran. I don’t have it in me to go back and re-read all 1,166 pages to confirm, but here’s an excerpt of the NYT Book Review of “Master of the Senate” if you’d like to see a citation: Excellent article that is both insightful and a breath of fresh air in our current political discourse. And that’s precisely what it was. But leftists, who see themselves as superior despite making no real contributions to society from the comfort of their liberal arts colleges, and, in spite of their worthless degrees and non-falsifiable crackpot dogmas like “critical theory”, have far less understanding of real conditions in this world, are actually hostile to poor whites’ very existence, have an instinct to shame, punish or defame them, and export the consequences of their misguided leftist ideology to those with the least ability to insulate themselves through economic privilege. That is central to everything I’ve written here. 63 an hour. Should every man woman and child have the same rights as others? ” Then they laugh all the way to the bank. All of it is from the exact same playbook, the one rich white conservatives in America have always used to guard and augment their power and wealth – they keep everybody else busy and distracted by pointing at an outside threat, an “other. S. Several different sources have made public these groups and the attack in Florida, San Bernidino, and the Boston Marithon are loosly connected. The history of leftism in this country has been mostly the poor and minorities fighting for themselves. If anyone found out he was a Jew, he would have been killed. How many more have to die from terrorism before the public see that we are being invaded? The only thing that differentiated my mother from her poor white trash ancestors were the opportunities to better herself. (It generally involves crying, apologizing, and invoking Jesus. Because we don’t know the answer to that question, we assume that their voting patterns are as mysterious as dark matter in the universe. In Iowa, it’s been common for a long time for farmers to send their children to college. ” By 1968 you can’t say “nigger” — that hurts you, backfires. I’ve been fortunate, for example, not to have been raised in a severely impoverished community with high lead toxicity rates that is a known direct cause of permanent brain damage, learning disabilities, psychiatric conditions, behavioral issues, and physical health conditions. -I never said that economics was unimportant. I spent my childhood in a rather strange dichotomy. They have no motivation (and no power) to keep you down. Cat-piss and dirty diapers. Once Chavez had the presidency in his grip, it only got tighter. Manifestation of one’s fullest potential was considered a national goal, even by Republicans. While having resources can make life a bit easier, some of the most satisfied and happiest people I have ever met have been poor people. Well written article beyond that it is basically Propaganda to enhance a particular candidate . At the same time I was active in GOP politics. I didn’t choose Vancouver because it is the “hipster mecca,” I went there because a friend offered a roof over my head. It’s not your fault or anyone’s fault. I grew up in Germany, and their system is now suffering at the hands of countless refugees and immigrants that are milking the system for all it’s worth. Working class people don’t have the time to read economics books, or history books related to the economic changes that have taken place over the past few decades. Poverty isn’t a personal failure. Because that’s why so many poor displaced Americans swim the Florida straights to enter Cuba; and the VISA lines to permanently relocate to Russia are so long at their Embassies; Yes comrade, in Bernie’s World its just one “Big Rock Candy Mountain” One man,One vote, one time; and See you in Siberia if you complain… Do svidaniya Comrade Citizen Ivin’s article here has become something like a genre piece amongst liberals. The government was originally formed to protect people going about their daily lives (doing their businesses, working their jobs, practicing their religion). Poor whites in the South aren’t the same as poor whites across the country. Right now, even by the government’s spruced-up numbers, one-third of working Americans make less than $9 an hour. And many people I know are working class liberals. The government needs to go under and people should see the result of bs division when finding food, safety and dwelling the to the point struggle it is. I’ve never been that way about either candidates or parties. Ricks Time Is Up on Rex Tillerson Max Boot Back to the Future in Afghanistan James Stavridis How Not to Handle the Opioid Crisis Laurie Garrett The Real Threat to America Comes From Americans Kim Ghattas Cancel Your Steve Bannon Victory Dance Kori Schake Things Don't End Well for Madmen Stephen M. So I liked Bernie, too, but what’s your Plan B? More well educated and well trained workforces. Class often trumped all else. They were successfully using them on election day and ignoring them for the rest of the year, probably because they felt that they were gullible enough to put up with that. 7 million. Clinton’s Welfare Reform has shifted those percentages quite a bit because urban Democrats were able to carve out exceptions for their constituents while Republicans who represented rural districts would have loved to have seen the entire system scrapped. It’s just rare. “Black” has effectively replaced “African-American,” which was always capitalized. ” In doing so, they gave a name to an ultrarightist political strain that passionately hated taxes and welfare of any kind, and that favored a national defense strong enough to dominate any part of the world—or the whole world—at any given time. At the YMCA camp I worked at, I was surrounded by Christians and they were nice people who were trying to have a positive impact on the world. People like me get ignored by almost everyone in the mainstream, even by populists like Trump. Martin Luther King Jr. From that context, it is clear you have no idea what actual “working class jobs” are. It may be mean-spirited, but it is not irrational. If anything, Sanders takes even further his criticisms of our plutocracy and corporatocracy, including the military-industrial complex and defense industry fraud. Where does the author see that Trump will stand against this, by the way? I don’t think you had a bunch of wealthy people working overtime to convince poor dirt farmers that they were better than blacks. Many present whites came from ethnic immigrants who weren’t considered white. Seems like there is a huge opportunity here to reshape politics and break the back of the odious Republican dog whistle scam that’s gone on for too long. Poor people are allowed to wear hats. I know it’ll be hard to teach by example because it has become nature to us to be the way we are or act certain ways but try anyway. Poor whites also defend social security and medicare. There is a lot of judgment of government assistance. Whats so different between the Poor and the Wealthy. It does not support higher education. I understood their anger. Yet many of these poor whites only think it is entitlement when someone else gets it. I do know what it’s like, though, to skip meals when money runs low. Even though few of them ever benefited from it. If allowed to rule this once great nation for too long, it will be game over, not just for the poor white people of this article, but for the entire Republic. Tyson, they felt, was one of them, a working class man who’d bootstrapped his way into the top one percent. Enslaved Blacks were an asset to the wealthy, but freed Blacks were portrayed as a danger to all. We are unable to make it from paycheck to paycheck because of them. Sladec – you’re everything that this article says of poor, dumb, white folk. That fact is ideologically inconvenient for party-line feminists, but it is difficult to argue that traditional welfare didn’t economically reward single-motherhood, initiating a brand-new flavor of the cycle of poverty. News broadcasts? You’re assuming that these are entirely separate populations. For example, you conflate “the poor” and “homeless people. Just rhanting is what you doing. The average working class Westerner in a highly developed country is far more wealthy than the average working class non-Westerner in a third world country. About 40 percent lived long enough to see the end of their contract. And what is so wrong with voting those political holes get closed up so companies do not do that anymore? By 1968, when she was 22—the same age Bernie Sanders was when he was arrested—she had become a Democrat and supported Eugene McCarthy. They think that his reality show and his “style” somehow make him better than the current establishment, all the while ignoring the fact that he has many ties and in-roads to the current powers. TysonDon Tyson wasn’t just a chicken farmer, much like the plantation owners weren’t just cotton growers. I tend to identify as a liberal, but this is more about my psychological attitude than any particular ideology. Clinton’s supporters are willing to overlook her violations of US Code and her non-disclosure agreement in regards to classified material, as if they were somehow a Stepford wive’s club of mindless sychophants, and STILL VOTE FOR HER! There used to be high economic upward mobility that brought many poor into the solid working class and much of the working class into the lower middle class. There was a period of time when someone could have a nice life as working class—back before union member ship rates declined, before offshoring and mechanization, before wages stagnated and buying power decreased (while housing and education costs went up), before job security and pensions became rare. I heard this over and over from unemployed men at the bar. His own father was born in an abandoned house that his family was squatting in. “Writing in the New York Times last November, ProPublica reporter Alec MacGillis cited data from the Pew Research Center showing that a majority of “likely nonvoters,” the majority of whom are white, are both less wealthy and more liberal than voters, thinking “aid to the poor” does more good than bad, for instance, while the average voter thinks the opposite. The communist wishes for 100 bars of gold. Thank you! I have looked at her record in a fair amount of detail. Not on scoring small little points with those with which you may agree more than dissent. “Instead, many of those entering the U. I don’t support a clear ban on immigration any more than I support a ban on LGBT marriage rights or misguided gun bans based on aesthetic features; but I do support stricter checks to ensure that those with extremist ties do not enter the nation because I grew up with bomb threats, armed soldiers patrolling my schools, and armed checkpoints. What he did is what democracy is about. Some of my family lines probably were poor whites for centuries or longer. He did send his kids to a state college. Penney or Toll Brothers Homes or Home Depot? I agree with you completely! Rolling landfills of curdled whiteness. It’s a bit of a Catch-22. Let the West Coast go on to be one of the worlds’ great countries, let middle america and rural Southern America keep shooting itself in its own foot trying to pretend its moral when in reality it’s anything but. ” I’ll take any flaming responses I get. Trump’s boisterous and outlandish talk is pushing buttons on a large population of people who see him as an answer to the problem in DC. It’s not as if the middle class professionals living around here give me part of their paychecks for the my happening to live in the same town. Trump sometimes makes statements that are more left-wing than Sanders. If you don’t share my concern for democracy, you aren’t on my side and I’m not on yours. None of us get through life without benefiting from a variety of things that are government-funded. Government benefits provide another restriction where employees who are receiving benefits ask for their hours to be cut so that they don’t exceed an income threshold for benefit entitlement. There is nothing I can do about that. In a world seemingly intent on destroying itself, the humble capybara is a wholesome good. Ike wanted national health insurance and so did Nixon. You’d think the Ozarks would be a shorter trip. The author says that Muslims are not her enemy. “With whites and Blacks divided, the wealthy elite prospered for the next two hundred years. Republicans have voted out every bill for Vets except for a fee that they padded for profits for them. I grew up poor in a tiny rural town in the economically repressed Douglas county of Oregon. And in actuality, when you consider the history of the federal income tax in the United States, Sanders is no where near a “hard core socialist. In Western satellite research papers countries like the United States, no reasonable person could say “leftists are much more abusive towards these people than right-wingers. Certainly, this kind of humor doesn’t translate well to the internet. If poor white people take so much pride in staying off welfare, why are they more prone to being on welfare than almost any other demographic? Most working people around here believe in the buzz phrase “personal responsibility. Soldiers have died. Sanders isn’t a socialist in the sense that is meant by most socialists these days. A very long article which is, unfortunately, preaching to the choir. Most major politicians and pundits aren’t going to inform them. It’s not a matter just of having been in politics a long time. ” Seeing as how I have the most education out of anyone in my family I guess I shouldn’t be surprised that I’m liberal. You are worse than white trash. Of those apprehended, 15,634 were Mexican. Now Democrats are cultivating some sort of culture of entitlement of those who don’t work, and punishing those that do. Many, many Venezuelans voted for and believed in Chavez back then. Whereas, at the beginning of the country the economic suppression of poor whites was used to set them against slaves, as blacks and hispanics have achieved political and social mobility “white trash” have increasingly been used as an acceptable release valve for the latent bigotry and elitism of the middle and upper-classes as well as lower-class minorities. He protested racial segregation on his college campus by chaining himself to a black woman so they could not be separated, and was arrested for it. ” Living in a trailer in Arkansas was a fun bit of slumming. So, an American is more likely to be harmed by a white Christian and then have their live saved by an Arab Muslim. A large number of people with working class jobs have college degrees. “Further proof that you have a college degree is your very claim that a college degree is not a guarantee of employment. They could give a rip about school, and they care even less about what educated upscale people think of them. We are all one race, human. And as several on this thread above have demonstrated, you seem to have no idea about the broadness of Trump’s base of support or the real sources behind that support. Money itself is an artificial creation of society. (Poor women were of little value to the rich, since they couldn’t vote or fight in a war. Angus Deaton and Anne Case, also of Princeton have published white working class mortality data showing a dramatic increase in death rates for poorly educated white Americans. But as an adult, I learned the joy of reading about history. Thank you for your insight here. That might lead them to read articles like yours; today far too few people seem to want to even question the status quo. I am NOT disagreeing with this article or saying that there are people who are poor and are not blaming the right group for their situation. It assumes everyone wants the same outcome and attributes all things to monetary value of a candidate. 5 percent more likely to favor Donald Trump if they do animals deserve rights essay “somewhat agree” or “strongly agree” with the statement, “People like me don’t have any say about what the government does. You can be assured that that 60-80% includes those who use welfare for what its meant for, to help them out while they continue searching for employment, and those that have been abusing it for years like this lady. No one was put on trial. Such a stunning, sweeping, urgent piece of commentary, written in a language accessible to any poor white motherfucker. Anyone who thinks that circumcision is the best way to protect his daughters should do it,” he wrote, adding, “The moderate opinion is in favor of practicing circumcision to reduce temptation. It wasn’t found in the earliest versions and must have been added at some later point. Poor , ignorant white folks….. It would be a gross oversimplification to pretend that the masses shout, ‘Trump. He measured his success by his ranking in the Forbes 400 list of billionaires. I live in a farming state and the younger generation have left the rural areas for the bigger cities. That’s where the conversation usually ends when you try to discuss why Arab societies hate women. Yet it wasn’t all that long ago that it was Communism that was the big boogeyman. ” Bea M – maybe it’s because they don’t like handouts or socialism given to individuals (or corporations and don’t start telling me that infrastructure is socialism, that’s not what I’m talking about). Much of my mother’s family is working class. For what it’s worth, Jonna strikes me a kickass human being who’d be cool to hang out with for a day and wouldn’t for a millisecond make me feel like I have something better to do. When Egyptian women are subjected to humiliating “virginity tests” merely for speaking out, it’s no time for silence. Why, generation after generation, sit there bitching about how much life sucks? Execution was legitimized with thinly veiled “crimes”, disease and starvation were rampant, and it was all acceptable to the elite because until the middle of the 20th century, Asians and Irish folk were considered “abhuman”–there’s a particularly hateful flyer from the early 1900s titled “The Albino Nigger”, which extolled the horrible nature of the Irish immigrant. One of the big things poor white people take pride in — when they can — is staying off welfare. Then again, being a poor Anglo-American wasn’t necessarily better. This is only true if you have strong preconceptions about what kind of degree you are going to work towards or what kind of work you want to do. So Socialism will help us all live a prosperous and happy life; it must be so…. In contrast to wealthy individuals who became even wealthier, those who were sent to do the actual fighting comprised disproportionately high numbers of working class Americans. However, they’ve traveled hundreds if not thousands of miles, busted their asses working long hard hours for crappy pay, and still save up money to send home or to build a business of their own. I admire them greatly for that. I have known many people who have worked as grocery store clerks and they can attest to seeing the stereotypical “Welfare Queen” (for lack of a better term) loading up on steaks and lobster with the 6 kids in tow all on the taxpayers’ dollar. State colleges were well funded back then. Still, even having a college degree doesn’t mean what it used to. This is such an important article I wish everyone would read. Yet even if the entire working class in America suddenly got religion and wanted to send every child to college, and if all children made perfect grades and wanted to broaden their worlds, it would be financially impossible under the present system. I prefer to call him one of our own. My Grandmother always described our family as Scotch-Irish and our “Irish” surname supported at least the Irish part and there were at least a few Scotch ancestors. Nor did he do sufficient public penance for it to show that he knew he had messed up. He was talking explicitly about racism. If anything, it just keeps him in the media and promotes his brand image. Being a white on the lower end of the class scale, I have some basic sense of what it means to be poor white, even though I’ve never known desperate poverty. Work harder. First we stop pretending. “Heritage said the U. Obviously, we don’t have a functioning democracy that allows for socially just reforms to happen from within the system. But i can tell you certain polls have found 60-80% of those receiving public assistance vote Democrat. I turn again to Saudi Arabia, and not just because when I encountered the country at age 15 I was traumatized into feminism — there’s no other way to describe it — but because the kingdom is unabashed in its worship of a misogynistic God and never suffers any consequences for it, thanks to its double-whammy advantage of having oil and being home to Islam’s two holiest places, Mecca and Medina. But to overcome that strategy, it is equally necessary for white people to realize, that blacks and latinos are not the enemy, as it is for blacks and latinos to realize, that poor and working class whites are not the enemy. Any mention of Senator Sanders will, of course, draw the gnashers in from the outer darkness. Thus the bizarre theories about Hillary. This is not Racist, it is common sense. Well, no, it’s basically correct. A check is a check? You kind of missed, and somewhat misinterpreted these things as you explained all the social, cultural, economic and political factors that have impacted the Blue Collar Class for the past, oh, what is, it, 150 plus years. Two, are you trying to say Democrats don’t rely on the loyalty of poor people? ” Because, you know, you and this article are part of “the media” and when you say “the media,” what exactly are you talking about that is not actually specifically defined there — newspapers? Divide and conquer is the strategy, that has been working for the rich elite for centuries. How much does Saudi Arabia hate women? In recent years are coming from Central America. And anyone slinging mud here needs to find a friend. Had they been legal citizens they would know their rights! ) had been straight with me and told me, the first day of kindergarten, “This is pretty much gonna be the rest of your life kid. He has not built a fortune from his position holding office. Changing that will not happen over night. Some of them did later go to ivy league schools, but not all of them. There weren’t any minorities to blame. And making that a racial issue only encourages divisiveness in people, no matter if conscious or unconscious. Sure, my people were blue-collar rednecks and my mother often reminded me that we were one generation removed from poor white trash, but I wasn’t Southern and I didn’t speak their language. I am the white underclass, and I am no one’s enemy. Some of my mother’s family is still poor, even severely poor. He’s essentially promising to do something about illegal aliens financially undercutting the citizen labor force, and continuing to support the wall is how he signals to his supporters that he is serious about addressing the problem. However I maintain that while rhetoric plays a part in peoples’ opinions, people in general (rich, poor, black, white, whatever) have legitimate reasons for the things they believe. He is only a socialist in the oldest sense of the word, as a social reformer. That while offering lip service on social issues the very same boogie men they create are actually funding their Party. But in class that night, I didn’t feel especially welcome. So my question for the author’s point of view would be this: If we can do it, why can’t these folks in rural Ark? Okay. ) So how did wealthy plantation owners convince poor white males to fight for a “peculiar institution” that did not benefit them? Same sex marriage) Since the first English colony, Jamestown, was not founded until 1607, there was hardly time before the first Africans were brought over in 1619 for wealthy plantation owners who used indentured servants to exist. With bureaucrats receiving 99% of intended funds and poor person getting his 1%, and with the eventual tax increase to finance whole scheme. The problem is there is massive disenfranchisement and systemic voter suppression in the South. Later on I did a research paper for a class on the concept of “white-trash” in America and saw reflected in the articles and statistics that I gathered a reflection of exactly what I’d experienced in my life. A nationalist is someone who seeks dj premier resume to put the interests of their own country ahead of the interests of the rest of the world. Why weren’t they angry with CEO-turned Chairman John Tyson, whose personal net worth is over a billion dollars? What a bunch of scared little cry-babies. For all the reasons you support Trump, rationally and morally you should be supporting Sanders. It creates a different kind of attitude than a poor farmer working in a region that has poor soil. I wouldn’t exactly consider myself poor these days. Anyway, I’m sorry about our conflict. The problem is whites , hispanics we all have been played for fools, why the rich manipulate the facts that place and hold them in power. Hell, it doesn’t even enter liberals’ lives these days. For this reason, I want to support the greatest challenger to plutocracy. He was truly a jack-of-all-trades, master-of-all type guy. They want to import cheaper and cheaper labor so they can go buy another yacht. From Poland and struggling through the Great Depression. ” My takeaway from this article was that the “identity politics” that Trump has been capitalizing on has as much to do with political and social elites fostering racism and xenophobia (effectively allowing Trump to apply Nixon’s “southern strategy” to the nation as a whole) as with people aspiring to become wealthy. He needs to real talk poor whites and help them understand Blacks will no longer carry the water for them. Have you not noticed the last decade of mass protesting and grassroots organizing, of the likes never before seen? It only allows the wage earner to survive from paycheck to paycheck, hoping he doesn’t lose his job and feeling like a loser down inside. The article is worded in such a way to make the reader think that the Jamestown settlement was well-established by 1619, when in fact even ‘fledgling’ would be optimistic. Many social programs — the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), Women, Infants and Children (WIC) — provide benefits that cannot be abused. Manal al-Sharif, who spent nine days in jail for breaking her country’s ban on women driving, is Saudi Arabia’s Bouazizi. You will achieve that by listening to them, which Trump is doing. ” Most everyone would rather have a good job than welfare, but when you have no other choice (i. Also, generation plays a big difference. It’s humiliating and terrifying, but sitting around and crying about it isn’t an option because we know that the only thing more pathetic than someone living in poverty is someone living in poverty and crying about it. Labour is a significant percentage of the cost of all products and services so if you increase the cost of labour you also increase the cost of products and services. I know he probably still would have voted for conservative candidates had he survived to this election, perhaps I could have easily changed his mind with a 30 minute discussion where I talk about some of the things mentioned in this article. I bet she’d never accept that part of Islam as a guide for her life. Bernie is just offering free stuff, more theft of income from those that earn it to be given for those that want free stuff, and the old envy and envy avoiding message of take it from the rich and give it to the poor (pitchforks). Trump spends a lot of talk promising to build a wall. I know it to be true for me. But how can people fighting for social equality include poor whites who see them as the enemy? He pays taxes at the Mitt Romney rate or thereabouts. During periods of economic expansion, the bottom 90 percent saw a decline in income gains. 9% – an all-time record low in peacetime – and everyone ran out and bought cars and radios, and wired up their homes with electricity and telephone service. The problem with Trump is that he was born into plutocracy and spent his entire life as a plutocrat. Call out the hate for what it is. Skull face after skull face of dull-witted peasantry, zit-scarred with filmy yellow eyeballs. Your article brilliantly portrayed their reality with the Tyson chicken story and perhaps the fervent anti-Muslim sentiment comes from having their sons and brothers sent to seemingly endless wars in the Middle East where Muslims have been enemies (and allies). Compared to homeless people, a working class person paying a third of their paycheck or more to rent alone is wealthy. They may not like to talk about their being on welfare because they feel ashamed about it or they might not even think of it as welfare, as in their mind it is only welfare when those other undeserving people get government help. This is one of the best and most cogent articles I have ever read. ” I don’t have fervent support for Sanders. In his 2000 book, The America We Deserve, Trump criticized governmental interference in American business. The poor all across the country understand this all too well. The intent was to encourage the upper classes to spend and invest more, which would boost the economy and create new jobs. ” Click To Tweet The answer I always got was that John’s father, Donald “Don” J. My own troubles, though, have bred in me a deep sense of compassion and understanding. I don’t lack comprehension. “There’s a certain pride in that that those who insist on ‘entitlements’ will never understand. People who lived and grew up in the US and not on base overseas have this weird bubble. I am trying to find Bernie signs to put up here in Nunda, NY! They can accept personal responsibility. The Arab uprisings may have been sparked by an Arab man — Mohamed Bouazizi, the Tunisian street vendor who set himself on fire in desperation — but they will be finished by Arab women. One side was my Hispanic family (who were well respected among the community) in a poor, primarily Hispanic neighborhood, in a rather comfortable house with a large yard that was always bustling with my cousins, aunts, and uncles. Millennials have likewise been hit hard with high rates of unemployment and underemployment having become the norm. Instead, they stood up for me — an outsider — and made it known that the Klan wasn’t welcome there. Even many urban Iowans live in or grew up in factory towns. E. You can cause great harm to a person (brutal whipping, hobbling, or chopping off minor body parts) while leaving them still able to do manual labor. Sadly, a moment’s reflection should make clear that the dynamics of the voting behaviors of various poor white communities (unfortunately for Ivin’s thesis, there is no such thing as *the* White Trash Vote) cannot be explained in a single unreferenced, unresearched autobiographical essay that unfailingly flatters liberal sensibilities (hence the predictable ovations from predictable audiences). I don’t know what else to say about that. , etc. He just walked around meeting and talking with people, enjoying life for the small things. That there’s more ‘freedom’ in the U. He didn’t have to. I’m no one special. By the way, if you conflate Democrats with the political left, that is your first mistake. Sanders has pointed out that if we stopped wasting money on such things as the military-industrial complex and corporate subsidies we’d have more than enough money to improve the lives and opportunities of the American public. I told myself that once the flesh was gone, dissolved into the nothingness, the smell would go away, but it never did. Much more of a different story for an independent from Vermont, isn’t it? They are Americans like me who are trying to navigate a political and economic system that is rigged against them. This isn’t the Republican base and so they have no loyalty to the party. By the way, it is hard to argue that most poor whites were treated worse than slaves. He wore a khaki uniform with his name embroidered over the pocket, spoke with an “aw shucks” southern twang and was often quoted as saying, “I’m just a chicken farmer. Even though I was raised Christian by conservative parents, I wasn’t raised fundamentalist. I was raised by conservative parents. Heck, what’s the difference? Even a flat tax with no standard deduction or personal exemption would still need a discrete agency to administer it; Pennsylvania, which has such a state income tax, is living proof of this. In the conservative moral order, some people deserve funds, resources, and opportunities while other people don’t. 3 billion). You — the outside world — will be told that it’s our “culture” and “religion” to do X, Y, or Z to women. And the only thing he has going for him is the false feeling that he’s superior because his skin is white — and can’t hardly eat and make his ends meet week in and week out. (Still hubris, but I do appreciate being intelligent) In short, I know a rising tide lifts all boats (that’s how it works in nature, at least, but the rich all have their own yachts while the rest of us take on water in our junkers). A large majority of his hospitality workers are imported from Eastern Europe on H-2 visas because they are white and not hispanic or black. We have a system in place of keeping us occupied with constant bickering and never solving anything of importance (mostly equality in pay)! Which protestors did he pay?? He has, I’m sure, not nearly enough patience to build up this base and get them to agree with him. Today it’s undocumented immigrants (almost exclusively ones which are of a different racial or ethnic background than the white majority), Muslims, and blacks that are being branded the enemies of the white working class (and, somehow, by extension, all of America). And yes, this article has a good point, united underclasses would have been a powerful force, and those underclasses can not be united, as long as they are repelled away from each other by forces of racism. Just a heads up: you reference “military generals with 20 years experience,” which is likely the lowest item on the general officer pay scale, but as an example for argument it sounds very fishy to service members — it’s *extremely* rare to see a general officer with less than 30 years of active-duty experience. Correct! And as long as that’s the case, we’ll fall for each diversion that’s tossed our way (e. Permanent unemployment rates are so high that the government stopped recording them back under the Reagan administration. Together we can lift you up. That is what we are doing here. Everything is up in the air and partisan politics for once isn’t dominating. Government regulations that stifle ambition are a threat to American dreamers everywhere, but laws that can be used to the advantage of top-of-the-business-world warriors are just fine. You may already be aware but I feel that it aligns perfectly with your argument. ” Many educated urban women would find this exact same attitude horrifyingly paternalistic, even if she would never have an abortion herself. But at least Yemeni women can drive. Instead of fighting for them to have better housing, we joke about tornados hitting trailer parks. I have often yearned for an intelligent white working class perspective on how the Republican and Democratic elites are killing the middle and working classes. We have protested in Chicago, KC, Florida and Arizona (there were two other groups there, we weren’t the crazy people tied to cars they were Clinton supporters) As for Israel you are right but Sanders is fighting military spending and wars which both lead to Israel as well as these greedy corporations.. As for the freedom of other people to do things that they want to do, but that you don’t think they should (like gay sex, for example), you are ANTI-FREEDOM. My research led me to early settlement in what was then Bertie County, NC along the shores of the Pasquotank River around 1700 where my Irish ancestors, and perhaps a ship-wrecked Portuguese sailor who swam ashore nearby bringing the Iberian Peninsula DNA, were likely absorbed into the emerging tri-cultural “free men” society of Irish, Native Americans and Free Blacks. I would just like to add that my grandparents were poor, white sharecroppers in Louisiana. I really want the author to consider this – When the “Poor Whites” no longer have illegals to place the blame on – who will they go after next if they are not paid well? If the poor white or black trash Americans put in half as much effort as the illegals do day in and day out, this place would be much better off. More poor whites support Sanders than Trump. That is one of the strange things about humans. There was great diversity in the history of indentured servants. So I agree with this article, because I’ve witness this first hand. The three “races” lived in harmony, inter-married, and worked as equals with united in their resistance to British rulers who controlled their lives, to some extent. Clinton. Capybaras have become internet-famous for their ability to befriend just about anything, from kittens to alligators. Years ago, there were college scholarships, loans, and programs out the yin-yang, and a high school education more or less prepared a person for college. There were already cracks forming in my convictions as a liberal. From 2003 to 2013, KBR — a subsidiary of Halliburton, once run by Dick Cheney — was awarded $39. I’d also point out that in the US Muslim and those of Arab ancestry have a lower rate of violence than Christians and those of non-Arab ancestry, while having a higher rate of being doctors. You would fit right in with the KKK. It always depends on what you’re comparing to. President George H. Many of them had mental illnesses. Drugs are rampant, businesses closed, and all people see are immigrants form Mexico and Guatemala who have taken their jobs, and who have 6-8 children living off the system. This created a potentially explosive situation for landowners, as oppressed workers quickly outnumbered the upper classes. I don’t doubt that there are ignorant poor people. No, I am truly voting for my interests, values, and morals! It depends on what one means by open borders, as few people are advocating an unregulated immigrant free-for-all. People the author clearly doesn’t understand. They are legally deemed to include any beating that is “not severe” or “directed at the face. Instead of fighting for them to have better health care, we laugh at their missing teeth. By the way, many homeless people are even employed, but they can’t afford rent. The whole disaster, post-war, was dumped in the laps of abolitionists and blacks. That does create a certain kind of attitude about life, but I don’t know what that has to do with lifestyle. Robinson. Besides pervasive racism, blacks experience high rates than whites of severe poverty, long-term poverty, and economic segregation. ) In “Red America”, Bill Clinton’s adultery was a very public matter. In 2002, they received $677 million in government contracts. They’ve never bought me cars or economically supported me. A couple of things, though – The charges against Tyson were dropped, not sure why you mentioned Clinton being president when you fail to mention GW Bush was POTUS during Iraq war; and governors quite often give tax breaks to industries to keep jobs in their state, no? That’s why Sanders beats Trump by 5 points among all white people but by 15 points among white people earning less than $25,000. Do you really believe that Muslim women in America are following their men 6 feet behind, unable to vote, drive, get educated, or hold jobs? For some one to talk about sin, I must ask this question. Clinton goes after “Republican” donors, Trump hires “Democrats” to run his campaign. In various comments here, I’ve mentioned some of this. “Life for actual poor people, the working poor, is something you evidently don’t have a good frame of reference for, probably because you don’t live in a part of the country where homeless people are a common sight up-close-and-personal (as opposed to seeing them occasionally from your car or something) and you can get a good sense of how they actually think and act. At this point in my life I’m forced to apply for disability, which is humiliating enough; but also listening to much more well off people tell me I’m looking for a handout and lazy because of it–which is infuriating. But self-reliant as they are, what real chance do they have living on wages that do not allow them to accumulate savings? If you want to know the closest example of actual socialism he might be akin to, you’d have to look to the sewer socialists who successfully governed Milwaukee for about a half century. Didn’t they know that in 1997, Tyson Foods pled guilty and paid $6 million in fines and costs for making gifts to Mike Espy, then President Bill Clinton’s secretary of agriculture? The root causes may be a profound despair that has overtaken white working class America as they recognize that the American Dream has become unattainable. It is faulting the white people for the rise of Donald Trump. Would my bar customers in Arkansas more easily identify with Blacks, Hispanics, and other people of color than with billionaires like Don Tyson? Even as a kid, I was expected to earn my own money. Robert Kennedy. I know how to look up info on the web. I am not saying I am against welfare by any means, I just recognize that it is a broken system meant to keep poor Americans down rather than bring them up. That is where your light shines the brightest. I may not have much formal education. Having said that, I do agree with most of your posts, and I like you. In the combined efforts of Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan and Operation Iraqi Freedom, almost 7,000 U. Young people don’t seem to realize the need to keep fighting, if they don’t, everything we fought for will have to be redone. In reading the comments, it seems to me that Lee Atwater and Rush Limbaugh have been successful…. He was the local boy who made good. ) We are finally seeing cracks in the foundations of deceit. Someone like Clinton can’t claim to have done much that is principled in her entire life, and she too has a long enough political record to demonstrate this. Not even Trump can stop it at this point. Their land use permit expired on June 24, and Resurrection City closed. The United States is probably the wealthiest state on the Earth in the history of mankind. Did you read the article? Many poor people seeking higher education right now simply find they end up with massive debt and still facing few job opportunities. In Arkansas, I was struggling to survive. Poor Southern whites have been lost in the shuffle. Most of them are employed, not unemployed. Tyson, the college drop-out who built his own father’s chicken farm into a multi-billion-dollar company, was a good ol’ boy. It means, literally, people who work, generation after generation. The author REALLY wants a Capitalist Villian to make her story complete and instead got dealt a nihilist who probably doesn’t have any clue that all of that history even exists. This from someone who’s had the little trailer and clunker car and has worked her way up from there to something nicer, knowing that NO ONE, government or otherwise, has paid for any of it other than me. How inclusive of you. Yet we never hear how a later marriage age affects women. I’m blaming both the ignorant messenger and the ignorant message. One new friend, knowing I came from the city, asked me why land wasn’t provided in the city for growing food plots. Very sad state of affairs when people don’t want to read anything that has the possibility of changing their minds. In other words, as a liberal I wouldn’t have been good enough for your AF! Job one for us is to make sure the public sector does a limited job, and no more. Social and political status and views. They even mate in the water, which we won’t get into as this is a family website. I would like to go! Of course a lot of poor whites are on welfare, but they want a paycheck, not a welfare check. His supporters know that companies are sending manufacturing jobs overseas, bringing in cheap imported foreign labor legally to replace them in the domestic workforce, and standing by while floods of illegal aliens self-import themselves to undercut their job opportunities. The poorer we are the smaller our attention span. Or even better yet, why keep blaming the big cities and all us awful evil Liberals, when it was we that actually went out and made something of ourselves? You are usually spot on with your comments and I enjoy your posts. The elites do not want this, and they also spend lots of money to paint progressives in a poor light as well. My experience is just the opposite. He doesn’t care what he has to do to get there. ” So even among “moderates,” girls’ genitals are cut to ensure their desire is nipped in the bud — pun fully intended. They assume responsibility for their lives and don’t want a handout from the government. She is a one-woman revolutionary force who pushes against an ocean of misogyny. I firmly believe that education, income inequality, and a corrupt political system are all tied together. So many people think they have you figured out or else they dismiss your struggles. It’s a nitpick, but it’s a worthwhile detail to correct in an otherwise spectacular and timely piece. Your entire argument falls apart. These days, working-class people who own homes have no equity left due to refinancing to pay credit card debt or medical bills. Where she veers off into Progressive dogma and misses what’s going on today is what occurred Post-Reagan. But in the following centuries, it became a more normal part of society and the treatment of indentured servants improved vastly. Only 28 percent of Americans believe in evolution. When they came up to the register to pay, one of the men made a comment about my hat. It took decades of Political and Cultural Manipulation to get the working class to vote against there own self interest. The younger generations understand how much the world has changed. Ralph Abernathy, the campaign’s goal was to “dramatize the plight of America’s poor of all races and make very clear that they are sick and tired of waiting for a better life. I don’t even have a college degree. What I care about is truth, democracy, justice, etc. While your historical analysis may expand a lot of the South, I doubt it really applies to Northwest Arkansas, including Benton County. That is just wrong. He probably made more money than my mother who was a public school teacher and he certainly made way more than I do. Radio? They deserve this government help, while others don’t. It is impossible to believe that anyone came by their political stance out of sheer logic. It’s not just that he is older. Let me try to get at the meaning that might be behind your question. 8 million in tax breaks while turning a blind eye to 300 miles of rivers polluted from chicken waste? My people, Irish Americans, were involved in just as many “terrible criminal acts” for -quite- some time; but the elite don’t give a damn because it doesn’t support their efforts to divide the American citizenry. I certainly achieved a better life than my parents. Ultimately, the political establishment is bipartisan, rather than partisan. But I think it’s good that Americans are beginning to learn about socialism. Similarly, a division in early America that led to the Civil War was the North and South seeing each other as separate peoples, based on old divisions of the English Civil War (Roundheads and Cavaliers), and at times that regional division played into class issues. What about this latest generation of kids left to suffer the same multigenerational cycle of anti-intellectualism and passivity? He was a multi-billionaire running a global corporation. I’m just saying – you can apply yourself and pull you and your future generations out of poverty. In a general election, polls Sanders would not only beat Trump but destroy him: Reuters currently has him up by nearly 10 per cent overall, and that with far less media coverage. My grandfather did all of that having come from a family that could have been described as white trash. I get really frustrated by the Democrats, they’re corrupt, but one thing they do not do is try to tell Americans how to run their own bedrooms or who they have to worship. Human beings are too prideful to change. ) That Hillary didn’t kick his lyin’ cheatin’ ass to the curb is truly incomprehensible. So the author is saying that Donald Trump is just like one of those plantation owners – banking on illusion of hate, racism, and bigotry to pit the “poor whites” against the “poor blacks, mexicans, muslims” and other minorities against one another. This from someone who’s had the little trailer and clunker car and has worked her way up from there to something nicer, knowing that NO ONE, government or otherwise, has paid for any of it other than me. Also conveniently ignored is LBJ’s rampant racism (which is the norm for most liberals, who spend their voices talking out of one side of their two faces). Poor whites didn’t fare much better. Sanders isn’t really a socialist in how most socialists mean it. His brother had moved to England for work, and both of his parents had died. I signed up for training to be a court appointed special advocate (CASA) for kids in foster care, and attended a series of classes in Vancouver. ) ground beyond this cycle. Sanders has spent decades in politics as an independent working with politicians from both parties. This explains his motivations but I’m not convinced that you have correctly identified why people are voting for him, or, as in Wisconsin, switching their vote to Cruz as the better alternative, but I appreciate your attempt and perspective. Also, it is the claim of the article I responded to that poor, white, and rural voters are flocking towards the Donald, not my own, I was just giving an alternate explanation that would account for their support that I think the article overlooked. Sanders has nothing more to do with the Democratic party than Trump has to do with the Republican party. They are coming all the way from places like Bulgaria, and Trump pays for their air travel. And they aren’t worried about making the world turn. Across the river in Portland, they call it “Vantucky. I was angry that I couldn’t afford to paint my walls in shades of possibility. He is not a millionaire. Only then were the colonist in a position to bring over indentured servants. All of the angst and bickering over the years regarding “third” parties is now seen to be meaningless foam from the mouth. Actually, loathe is a strong word for me. ” In fact Germany just arrested a group of Syrian immigrants plotting acts of terror. Even in an all white place like Oregon, the absent minorities can be used as a tool of division, with the allegation that white liberals care more about minorities elsewhere than the poor whites living right there. None of them were particularly smart. I totally agree about reading American history books. Would they feel as if their voices mattered, as if they had some say in what their government does? I’d point out that Trump’s largest support doesn’t come from the poor but from the lower middle class. If the there hadn’t been a pseudo-Federalist coup, slavery could have been ended peacefully. Conservative leaders understand quite well that education has a liberalizing effect on a society. Should a person working 40 hours at Mcdonalds be able to pay rent and eat? Yet, no one is asking why someone like Warren Buffet is advocating for more taxes on the wealthy in America, or trying to show that wealthy, urban, elites in the democratic party are similarly self sabotaging by supporting people that are not in favor of their best interest. But classism lingered, despite what wealthy elites would have Americans believe. There is race-baiting on both sides of the political spectrum, and it should not be like that. Of course in the US, any attack of any kind is usually immediately tied to the NRA or Christian extremists until day three when evidence opposing the opinions during the Breaking segment is finally brought in, but by then it’s always cemented as “truth”. Though both groups’ economic status rose, the gap between the wealthy and poor widened as a result of slave productivity. I’ve been way more fortunate than people living in severe poverty. They did not own their house – they worked the land and were “allowed” to live there. Music, clothes, manner of speech, etc are all included. My computer was cobbled together from second hand parts given to me by friends who had money to build their own systems. I don’t even conflate “the poor” and “the working class. That’s why this week on Animals Are Good, we’re celebrating the world’s largest—and chillest—rodent, the capybara. ” There are many degrees besides liberal arts that have relatively higher unemployment rates. Is it really welfare queens or immigrant laborers or Muslims, as Trump claims? Many blacks used to own their own land in the past. Maybe that is why he just won West Virginia. My contention is that if Trump had emerged in the late 60’s he would have wiped Hubert Humphrey off the ticket for the Democrats (who, let’s face it, weren’t particularly turned off by rich people) by taking the far left rhetoric of the time and turning up the volume there. Everything the rich have comes from the society they were raised in. I, too, am scared that they are going to screw this up! The Lost Generation in their older age, for example, pushed for Social Security and other progressive policies. I’m not excusing her personal indiscretions and political missteps, but she has been treated like a criminal since 1992. He met an immigrant wife from Moldova who made him very happy in his final years (his relationship with my mom was completely finished sometime during my high school years). He had not a penny to his name when cancer took him in the spring of 2015. I take that seriously and so should all Americans. Bravo and thank you! Donald Trump is reminiscent of Samuel Gompers: In all things economic, he is a Malthusian, not a Social Darwinist like Ronald Reagan – or Ted Cruz, whose goal of eliminating the IRS would necessarily lead to the income tax being replaced by a “head tax” in which everyone pays the identical dollar amount: The worker at Tyson’s pays $7,000 a year, Bill Gates pays $7,000 a year – the amount it would need to be in order to be revenue-neutral. As for Tax loopholes… One can spend days arguing the pros and cons of them, but funny how Democrats point the finger at large businesses that employs hundreds of thousands of Americans with high paying jobs, dump billions of dollars into our economy through their business ventures with local businesses, many times improve american infrastructure, but Democrats point the finger at the millions(less than the good we get from them) of dollars they’ve evaded in taxes (which usually get spent back into the economy as companies usually reinvest profits after payroll back into Research and development so they can compete with both national AND international companies), or the fact that certain companies outsource cheap worthless labor to whatever 3rd world country (because of minimum wage laws supported by Dems, that are non existent in the rest of the world). We deliver papers of different types: essays, theses, book reviews, case studies, etc. I’d make clear one issue. If you were downtown, it would only take you 10 minutes to drive to the edge of town where farmland begins. People of religion often have less desire to be wealthy even some seeking poverty as a life style. A major portion of this dissertation database proquest work was to illustrate how we are taught to hate one another so that real progress is never made in our favor, and we are consistently exploited by the mega-rich. By Socialists, in 1847, were understood, on the one hand the adherents of the various Utopian systems: Owenites in England, Fourierists in France, both of them already reduced to the position of mere sects, and gradually dying out; on the other hand, the most multifarious social quacks who, by all manner of tinkering, professed to redress, without any danger to capital and profit, all sorts of social grievances, in both cases men outside the working-class movement, and looking rather to the “educated” classes for support. The last Democratic president Benton County voted for was Harry S. He has criticized the money we waste on military adventurism and defense industry fraud. How was it that the debunking of their WMD “evidence” was available months (perhaps even years) prior to their airing in the MSM – usually to the refrain of “who could possibly have known” that the war was based on false evidence and would come to a bad conclusion? I am also a life-long student of history and do not see anything in the article that is untrue or imagined. True. ” Just as her husband denies her an orgasm, the call to prayer interrupts his, and the man leaves. Cut to today and the backlash against the ‘political establishment’. They’re embarrassed when they do accept SNAP or some other assistance. There is no arbitrary definition. His family had left him with that guy. When the Poor People’s Campaign ended, so ended King’s vision of turning the nation’s attention to eradicating poverty among all people, and guaranteeing all people the opportunity for meaningful jobs with livable wages. Poor whites in some areas tend to vote Democratic, not Republican. Was it a good thing? You also have to recall that Oregon didn’t become so white on accident, as it was the only sundown state in the country. When people hear opinions repeated enough by certain politicians and pundits, they begin to take on those opinions as if they were their own. But what about what happened in the 1920s? The editorial in question was prompted by the many inhuman and fiendish lynchings of Afro-Americans which have recently taken place and was meant as a warning. But I have long been intrigued by the culture there and have spent countless hours trying to understand my own roots as well as the roots of those I grew up with and define both white and black culture in the region. I’ll always root for the underdog. I didn’t grow up wealthy. They scatter their genes in a degenerative spiral of dysfunction. But in 1971 that last constraint on the money power was eliminated. It’s an archery term for “missing the mark,” sometimes translated as falling short. My maternal grandfather went from poverty to his kids going to college and yet I don’t think he even completed elementary school. Olmsted). That means that everyone finds that their cost of living goes up, but unless they’re in that group whose income was previously between the previous minimum wage, and the new minimum wage, their income hasn’t. Ben, Norway is an extremely wealthy country, made so by its vast petroleum reserves. Trump doesn’t know what the hell he’s doing, Cruz wants to Christianize the US, and Kasich doesn’t believe women are people. And some still do — including a prominent female parliamentarian, Azza al-Garf. We must build a new country that belongs to all of us, a country where no one ever has to feel like just a poor motherfucker no one cares about. All of that has changed in recent generations. If you’re really so against the ‘wealthy elite’ then why do you keep voting for policies that benefit only them? They trained slaves to take over the skilled jobs of white servants. Those two experiences helped me see more clearly than ever how fool-headed it is to stereotype people based on how they look and where they live. I am quite certain that if I were trying to get into college today with the mediocre grades I made back then, and no family college fund or family home to second-mortgage, I would not make it as far as I have. I was angry at my life choices that never felt like real choices. But what about the rest of the class? One defendant shot himself a few months after the indictment. Joanna took the time to write such a insightful and passionate article and share it with anyone that wanted to read it sharing a part of herself. We have bigger issues in America than kicking Muslims out of our country and Mexicans and what ever type of people he uses to gain favor. It’s some sort of magical hat. Most do not take anything from the government. But what you don’t comprehend was that this minority of rebels included those who were extremely radical. It’s similar to why these kind of people are often less critical of subsidies to big biz and big ag, bailouts to big banks, and foreign aid to countries like Israel. We all need to be united and stand together for a way out of poverty. It was an exercise in non-judgment — and it was humiliating. And many jobs available don’t pay a living wage. When the recession hit, my dad’s best friend was building a million+ dollar home among the other wealthy elites of Pueblo, CO. Realistically, in a situation like this, love, acceptance, and embracing one another for a common goal of progress is the answer; something we could all use a lesson in these days Unfortunately, most people are easily manipulated. Instead of attacking the victims of our own policies, maybe we should change our policies. For example, in the Civil War and post Civil War era I’m pretty sure that After the war, in the South you’d be hard pressed to find someone that didn’t think that white people were superior to black people. , suburbanites who feel differently, most native hometown kids are not concerned with upward mobility at all. My point is that the observation made by the article and other posters in this thread that neoliberals such as yourself lack a real understanding of or empathy for “poor whites” or actual “working class Americans” and are primarily preoccupied with reinforcing your own privilege or sense of superiority. I wasn’t living in a trailer ironically. “In the meantime, solace: The ugly, dumb xenophobes and actual Nazis supporting Trump are older than the U. While their politics are very different, could anyone have predicted 20 years ago that the country with the largest oil reserves in the world would be on the brink of collapse today? Generation X actually experienced a recession when they reached adulthood, but it was a recession that only impacted their generation. One of the interesting things about Trump’s populism is how much it draws from the rhetoric and issues of concern from the political left. I am an independent, raised by a “poor white man” and my “leftwing lesbian aunt’s”. Construction on his million dollar home didn’t end, instead he started laying off Mexicans and cutting my dad’s paycheck. Other poor people are not the enemy, no matter how they look, how they pray, or who they love. And what ultimately is the point of all these taxes? It’s about who they think deserves government largesse. Consequently, they don’t like social spending to give people a lift. So you say stuff like, uh, forced busing, states’ rights, and all that stuff, and you’re getting so abstract. Yellowed armpit stains on the t-shirts. And as our notion, from the very beginning, was that “the emancipation of the workers must be the act of the working class itself,” there could be no doubt as to which of the two names we must take. The conservative movement seemed to be an amalgamation of willful obtuseness and callous disregard for their fellow man…and yet…. I’m an equal opportunity critic. They see accepting public help as a sign of failure and moral weakness. None of that is what matters!! Big or small, our government has failed everyone but the wealthiest class. You’re just as poor as Negroes. No one is denying abuse never happens, for that would be bizarre. Please enlighten us with specifics to make your case that liberals are patronizing toward poor whites. All of the other problems – racism, sexism, whatever it is – stem from the same rotten root of income and wealth inequality and unequal representation in government, and people have become so accustomed to this disgusting system that they won’t even listen to a candidate like Bernie when he comes along and points it out. Most did not survive the term of their indenture. C. The world isn’t as black and white as you appear to believe, and there are terrible things that terrible people do in the name of a large number of organizations–that doesn’t stop by offering to hug it out. Trump and his followers as one party with two candidates: those two being, of course, Clinton and Bush. I’d have to agree with your last point as well, when you write that much of the political left has “largely abandoned economic issues. No doubt a squirrel or a rat had died in the walls. I’ve been doing genealogical research in recent years and it is fascinating. You clearly sought to exclude yourself from that, as you clearly believe that your political opinions were arrived at solely through reason. What was the point of your question? I agree with the truth of what you’re describing, as I’ve observed it first hand, first when growing up in a rural part of the midwest not far from Arkansas, and second by talking with people as part of my job, people who are from these parts of the country and do match some of the experience the author is retelling. ” Click To Tweet Did slave owners care about white indentured servants when they pitted them against African slaves, or did they want to ensure a steady supply of cheap labor? What a load of crap! And even many liberals who do manage to do better in life didn’t necessarily start that way. Yes, classes which addressed multi-cultural issues paid lip-service toward class, but a “white trash” or “trailer-park” joke was – if not common – not considered gauche. The woman who heads the “women’s committee” of the Brotherhood’s political party said recently that women should not march or protest because it’s more “dignified” to let their husbands and brothers demonstrate for them. And so much fear, especially of muslims. That is what society is about. It’s a big advertisement for Trump and it’s effective to that end. Steele, your incessant need to lecture almost even respondent notwithstanding, I am very aware Hilary’s long record. The conundrum we have created is that so many jobs don’t pay enough to allow someone to pay their bills, buy food, keep a roof over their head, and maybe maintain a car. When delegating your work to one of our writers, you can be sure that we will: If your deadline is just around the corner and you have tons of coursework piling up, contact us and we will ease your academic burden. So, those rich urban liberals are paying for the living expenses of those rural, struggling class. A wall is for security. Explain why most welfare recipients are white. Yes, he was racist for much of his life, he was an alcoholic, and he was on the abusive side toward his wife and children. It’s much, much worse. Crusty dishes in the sink. It reads like your own ideological impressions of the past as it existed for people who weren’t your family, rather than how it actually was. We cannot seem able to view issues in any other context that Liberal vs. Jesus never said, “Love the sinner, but hate the sin. The central premise here is that poor white people have been manipulated by rich white people into supporting policies that go against their own best interest. Cairo has a women-only subway car to protect us from wandering hands and worse; countless Saudi malls are for families only, barring single men from entry unless they produce a requisite female to accompany them. They possibly couldn’t know better!! I’d add that it’s Republican states, not Democratic states, that receive more federal funds than they pay in federal taxes. The reality of Reaganomics was that Americans who gained the most were the nation’s richest ten percent. With proper education, that can be changed. As a result, the “poor white trash” are totally unconcerned about this sort of paternalism. My point is that my parents are wealthier than, for example, my friends who work such jobs as a bus driver, baker, etc. ” Click To Tweet In 1963, President John Kennedy had begun planning a “war on poverty” intended to help poor, southern whites — particularly in Appalachia and the rural South. If you want to stop such people ending up at the US border, the first thing to do is to stop promoting foreign policies that create political and economic refugees in the first place. The 2000 census showed that per capita income was $16,581, and that over 13% of the population lived in poverty. I wonder whether working class whites will read it. I just didn’t know how to respond to your original post. It had nothing to do with wanting us all — together — to admit that emotions play a role in the formation of our political opinions. Single mothers and fathers are not my enemy. He doesn’t make money by keeping others poor or sending them to war. I’ve never seen evidence that those on the political left are more likely to be condescending toward the poor than any other demographic. Among unemployed white voters, that number rises to 16 per cent. In 2001, employees and advisors of the firm included former U. My parents are also wealthier than my brother who works as a county naturalist, as county naturalists don’t make much money, often less than a public school teacher. Discouraged by the murders of King and Kennedy, scarce media coverage, and horrible living conditions in the camp, demonstrators’ optimism waned. Many urban liberals were raised in rural and suburban conservative communities. “Black” has effectively replaced “African-American,” which was always capitalized. As a liberal, I see economic issues as central. I just wish you’d direct your attention to the people who largely disagree with you and focus more energy on the strong opposing opinions. I was part of Johnson’s revolution, and also part of Reagan’s tearing it down. In fact, the gop would rather have hillary then loose their power with trump in the long run. I have some interest conservatism from my parents and also interest in libertarianism, anarchism, socialism, etc. The obvious liberal agenda has reared its ugly head. Of course there are some low income people who are do animals deserve rights essay Trump voters, but they’re a minority. Jakes “The Miracle of Survival” and now I came across your piece. The assumption is that tipped workers will earn their own minimum wages by making up the difference in tips. Still, there are racial differences that matter. When an article in the Egyptian criminal code says that if a woman has been beaten by her husband “with good intentions” no punitive damages can be obtained, then to hell with political correctness. Many of our issues mirror those of the USA and the enemy of our people are the same. S. Liberals are usually the ones pointing out that “leading the fight against ISIS are Muslims,” something most conservatives refuse to acknowledge. I’m not going to ignorantly stereotype about all poor whites based on the poor whites I’ve personally known. Sanders is a welfare pusher, and he doesn’t have their votes. The abolition movement was growing before the American Revolution. Why would you have a problem with him pointing out the obvious? I think that his broad support comes from his nationalism. I am sure many of our politicians, especially Bernie Sanders probably are aware of the information in which you speak in your article. Both groups deserve a voice, of course, but in practice it has been the Gentry Liberal voice and the African American vote. Or if you want an even harder hitting criticism of the problems that Trump and Sanders campaign on, you should support Jill Stein of the Green Party. Even STEM degrees aren’t worth what they once were. Dr. Many people reading this financed their children’s educations with second mortgages. S. Still, he was smart enough to get on-the-job training and get promoted. Later, after the war, they would find out most of his family died in the Holocaust. Probably because she sees it as typical dog whistle politics. It’s the same reason he was proud to own his own house and proud to send his kids to college. What a horrible “poor me” diatribe! But I’m not talking about sex hidden away in dark corners and closed bedrooms. The factual errors concerning Republicans and conservatives are, of course, numerous. Until the rage shifts from the oppressors in our presidential palaces to the oppressors on our streets and in our homes, our revolution has not even begun. He’s *not* actually that conservative – so he appeals to disaffected Democrats such as myself. It’s just conservative paternalism often is about punishment in order to maintain the social order, although conservatives also show majority support for the welfare state as well, such as supporting social security and medicare. ” y entire life, I’ve watched politicians bragging about how poor they are, how they came from nothing, how poor their parents and grandparents were. We as a country need to come together. Trump says that our trade agreements are one-sided against us and are fueling the exodus of American jobs. Many poor people in the past had the opportunities and resources (often government funded) to pull themselves out of poverty and live a comfortable middle class lifestyle. At first things were good, as my dad worked for his best friend at his right-hand man, making comfortable amounts of money. Most politicians barely maintain a pretense of representing the people — except during election years when they talk about “issues” and make promises they have no intention of keeping. Well done! We do not share any of your information to anyone. But… and this is a big but, as one of the “poor uneducated whites” I was deeply saddened upon reading through the responses to your article. You don’t have to be a poor white, desperately clinging to his social status (presumably along with his guns and religion) to take a dim view of the prospects of truly bettering the condition of the poor through an ever more expansive cadre of well-meaning government workers. They want to believe their voices matter. This is an article, not a novel or academic paper. Bush further confirmed my liberal leanings. Not all voters should, or actually do vote for the candidate that best supports their own interest. ”, and its definitive motif is that of a writer reciting every platitude in the Democratic Party’s cliché manual while at the same time giving himself or herself a pat on the back for being so bold as to suggest that Poor Whites might not all come from central casting on “Deliverance”. In the US, most of that wealth comes from inheritance. But it is important to realize in the US that class and race have never been separate. I have not read all the commentary, but I did read all of the article. Bernie Sanders doesn’t say that if you are poor, it’s your own damn fault. The real divide in both parties and across the country are the haves and have-nots. As a Canadian who has lived in the US but now watches your politics from a distance I have been mystified by the hold the Republican party seems to have on the very people their policies hurt most. His campaign isn’t about freebies or handouts. Their infrastructure, schools, and high rates of welfare are mostly paid by federal funds. Thank you! You have been swayed and distracted into thinking that those issues are Very important to us all (they’re not). It is faulting the white people for being brainwashed enough to support Elites while embracing xenophobia, racism, etc. There’s no quit in you, my friend. This isn’t just an article or opinion piece, it makes numerous very bold accusations and claims about the history of the country and people in it that need to be cited if they’re to be taken seriously. Depending on how you define it, I can be considered a poor white as well. What worked in the past no longer works, partly because the government used to ensure a middle class lifestyle was accessible to more by heavily funding college, offering generous housing loans, etc. I learned so much from this read. I feel that it’s much more simple than that. ” (And yet Clinton represents an administration that openly supports many of those misogynistic despots. ” I would argue that liberals’ attitude toward poor whites or poor white men is closer to neutral or pity or empathy. I wasn’t living large off the man. Nor is the length and depth going to be the same; you won’t get out of a 30-second sound bite on TV what you would get from a 40-inch newspaper story. (Welfare Queens, Gun Confiscation, Immigration, Government Waste, Foreign Aid, Right to Life Amendment, Taxing Job Creators etc. But Reagan had given poor whites someone to blame for their suffering: the Welfare Queen. Our writers always follow your instructions and bring fresh ideas to the table, which remains a huge part of success in writing an essay. It doesn’t matter what country they’re in or what religion they claim. Political elites in neither party really wants to genuinely represent low income Americans. Still, there are differences between the parties. We will be overpowered and our men will be compelled to wander like vagabonds all over the earth, and as for our women, the horrors of their state we cannot contemplate in imagination. I was born and raised in California. Tens of thousands of middle and lower class white men died in Vietnam and Korea as a result. ” When it became obvious that Johnny is now so dumb that he can’t pour piss out of a boot with the instructions on the bottom—assuming he can even read the instructions—the elite regime in power was quick to get up a posse to lynch the school marm, then resume the theft of education funds on behalf of the rich. ”. People were starving before, but now we have a crisis of obesity-related diseases killing people. I’m sorry to have been so defensive. Lest you think of Muammar al-Qaddafi as a feminist of any kind, remember that under his rule girls and women who survived sexual assaults or were suspected of “moral crimes” were dumped into “social rehabilitation centers,” effective prisons from which they could not leave unless a man agreed to marry them or their families took them back. I’m sure most readers found this insightful! Donald Trump would have you believe Sanders is a “loser” for not taking financial advantage of his position. “Why extremists always focus on women remains a mystery to me,” U. When King was assassinated just a month later on April 4, the SCLC and King’s widow, Coretta Scott, decided to go ahead with the campaign. Most people probably have some basic understanding of that, not to say there aren’t plenty of middle-to-upper class people who have no idea what poverty is like. I learned first hand what Lee Atwater and Karl Rove thought of poor white Southerners. I appreciate you challenging the stereotype of poor whites. I’m such a person. If you would like to discuss the deeper meaning of the hat, you’ll have to take that up with the Klan. What part of, “I am too weary to go on pages and pages with someone like you to defend everything I said,” don’t you understand? You don’t deserve to be an American if this is your idea of a a future! Let’s be honest, none of us here are billionaires. I don’t care about either Sanders or Clinton as people. Back then, a ton of working class kids went off to college and careers like public school teacher were common for those working class kids. Try saying to him to vote democratic after he said to an MSNBC reporter trying to racebate him “What have the democrats done for us? They were given room and board, and, after four to seven years of grueling servitude, freedom. Your story is very informative enjoyed it a lot. (I wish I knew, statistically speaking). Before that it was Mexico, Native Americans, Mormons, and Catholics. I get tired of generalizations. Drawing on Navajo (Diné) traditional education systems, traditional tunes and rhythms and naturally occurring soundscapes in the Navajo Nation, the Heartbeat Project 2017 will employ music instruction as a tool to improve mathematical skills for K-12 Navajo students. To be rich, as the dictionary defines it, is to have way more wealth than most people. Depression really does put me in a bad mood. 1 billion), and Blackwater ($1. Not to an elite status by any means because my parents were teachers making a very low salary, but they continued on to get a Masters and a Doctorate degree providing them with raises over time. With perseverance, your observations will contribute to the basis being formed for constructive discussions on the other side of the spring-loaded cries of fear and wounded pride. He moved to Vermont and held a variety of low-wage jobs, spending many of the following years broke. Then lets solve the problem of blue collar jobs being shipped overseas by huge numbers and depressing the nation – which Trump has been consistently against (anti-NAFTA, anti-TPP, has consistently been on TV for over 30 years saying the same nationalist trade rhetoric). It’s about principles and about real world results, not team sports. He’s definitely a member of the one percent. With no resources and nowhere to go, many walked to regions where land could still be homesteaded, and settled in remote areas such as the Appalachian Mountains. You learn by sitting back and watching people, I do apologize for calling you a Racist but your remarks are in line to what this article is talking about that sense of being superior to others. Only working class people in the South do their own yard work and my family always did our own yard work, just as we did our own housework. There are more whites than blacks receiving welfare. But please don’t let your fervent support for Bernie and the need to jump on every post override some basic point like I was making, which was really about her intelligence and qualifications. It costs more to try to pull oneself out of poverty than it did in the past, and unsurprisingly economic mobility has decreased far behind many other industrialized countries. After a two-year recession, the economy rebounded and continued to grow.